PL charge City for alleged breaches of financial rules

We did escape serious punishment I have never said otherwise indeed prior to any charges I was stating quite clearly we would and should be charged. There’s absolutely no doubt that our owners and their legal representatives came out ahead.

I don’t think I have ever said that City are guilty. If you can find any of my posts that say otherwise save when I thought you had an issue defending the Mancini case then I will apologise accordingly.
Mate, are you still here?, seriously?
 
The compensation wouldn’t be to City it would be to Etihad and Etislat, I’m not sure even the cartel clubs particularly united would be too keen to risk millions by voting for it either.
Oh the irony if Etihad and Etisalat received megabucks compensation from the cartel and then increased their sponsorship levels
 
Having said that, and I quote, " The majority of the panel nonetheless finds that the conclusions of Ernst &Young do support MCFC's case. In particular, the theory that ADUG directly funded or reimbursed Etihad for its sponsorship contributions to MCFC is discredited".

It's pretty clear to me what they are talking about in paragraph 267 and 268 and they are very different things. How on earth do you think the criticism that Dudney relied on financial information from MCFC has any bearing on the quality of EY's work which was based on ADUG's financial information?

Edit: btw, they didn't say the EY work wasn't reliable or independent, they said it wasn't as reliable and independent as a full independent audit. Not the same.
Don't, you're starting to spoil it for him.
 
Last edited:
Even if it was release now, surely the appendacies would also need releasing for referece. No way this could all be legally reviewed and signed off by Thursday.
Yeah I thought this too, the timing of the report today and Samuels article the other day (now with a vote on thursday) suggests it’ll happen soon but just guesswork, I’d just be astonished if it’s been released to 19 other clubs and not leaked and if it hasn’t been released how on earth can the other clubs sign up to cover legal costs, curious
 
If we are right and the PL will try and negotiate some form of settlement it may not be as easy as they think. Etihad and Etisalat are third parties and will go through the courts not the PLs commissions. Upholding the appeal, not only on disguised funding but also about executives lying etc, may not placate our sponsors if what we've heard about the angry reaction to the verdict in Abu Dhabi is true. It depends on how vulnerable the PL feels and how confident our sponsors are. Much will also depend on the support Masters & Co get from the clubs and I cannot see many being prepared to finance such a potentially ruinous case. Maybe the government will get involved ...
 
I mean it starts with a premise that is extremely unlikely to be true. Etihad have no natural access to the full report and so cannot ‘have their ducks in a row’ to be able to proceed. No brief of the quality they’re said to have engaged would sign off proceeding without seeing the full report.
Tommy ducks , go for a pint.
 
What I struggle to understand is surely their lawyers would have informed Masters and the rest of the PL board that City’s sponsors may sue if you proceed with the case, but they ignored that advice and proceeded anyway. Now they are shitting themselves that they might end up homeless. I don’t understand any of this case, none of it makes sense. Why would these people put their reputations and own personal wealth at risk because of a few clubs that want us gone? I do wonder how much of an influence of their decision making is based on the clubs they are affiliated too. Brittain is a rag, Mistry and Ryder are tarquins and Masters is a cartel shill.
So you know why then!
 
I don’t understand why any of the clubs would vote to make themselves vulnerable in this way.

But nothing surprises me about all of this. I can see the headlines on Friday or the weekend - PL board given vote of confidence to forge ahead.

If that’s the case they must hate us more than they love money. Makes no sense.
 
I'm far from an expert but how could the directors of the PL actually be on the hook? They have commissioned an investigation and set up an independent panel - thee panel found what it found

But there is a separation from the PL to the independent panel

Having said all that, the PL's lawyers are experts and feel it necessary to protect Master's & Co

None of this makes any sense.

We are not arguing over a small technical matter of accounting law/principles. We have a panel that are calling people liars and the sponsors saying that position is totally false

Someone, somewhere, is very wrong
 
This bit just about sums these PL cunts up

“The Times understands the Premier League has now realised that, within company articles of association that were updated as recently as June, the directors — Masters, the chairwoman Alison Brittain, and three non-executive directors, Mai Fyfield, Dharmash Mistry and Matthew Ryder KC — are not provided with indemnity from legal action from a third party such as a club sponsor.”

They’re fucking useless as well as corrupt.
They make it up as they go along, a bunch of incompetent clowns.
Any professional organisation with a multi-million turnover would already have this type of indemnity in in place.
As other posters have said if they're so confident in their findings, why are they trying to bring this in now?
 
I wonder if this is why Etihad instructed a US law firm. Imagine that, they sue the Premier league here and in the USA

'Technically, a “third party” is not limited to the UK courts, however. Such action could be taken in other territories, including the United States. A third party such as a club sponsor is not a signatory to the Premier League’s rulebook, and therefore not bound by its private arbitration process. An American lawsuit, for instance, would involve additional costs, with both sides required to pay its own legal fees regardless of the outcome. Corporate defamation claims in the US have been known to run into the billions.'

Dicky won't be sleeping too well at the moment hahaha
Lovely!
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top