PL charge City for alleged breaches of financial rules

Let's say a club was in the Premier League in 2018, but has subsequently been relegated. Why should it escape responsibility for an indemnity covering that period simply because it is no longer a shareholder?

Conversely, why should a club promoted last season, which had absolutely no involvement in the decisions made by the Premier League in 2018, be expected to contribute towards the potential legal costs?

And what happens to a club that votes in favour of the indemnity, gets relegated the following season and then finds itself facing a bill potentially running into millions?

Does the liability follow the club after relegation, or does it disappear when the club transfers its Premier League share?

These aren't trivial questions.

The Premier League is asking its member clubs to accept potentially enormous financial liabilities arising from decisions made by its executives over a period of years.

But its membership changes every season. Bonkers
Any legal bill should be a 9 way split the 5 execs and the 4 cunts on the Arsenal letterhead, if they need 10 first easier maths throw in reading for spineless abstaining.
 
The league must be confident they can get enough votes on Thursday. Cant see them putting this to a vote without already getting assurances it will pass.

Brilliant news tonight. Thursday will either show a full house against us or we may just have a breakaway and the board ultimately resigning with no support. City’s sponsors continue legal and destroy the bad actors.

Another thread to pull…

We deserve good news for a change and we deserve as a club to be cleared of the awful accusations.

Optimism is high. Still think we win the appeal.
 
If I’m an owner of a non cartel PL club I’m asking my in-house legal counsel for advice, which should go something like this.

Me - so, lay out our options and upsides/downsides?

Counsel

Option A - well, we (the PL) uphold the verdict and punish City heavily. City will not feature in our near future and may go bust.

On the positive side that’s one less team to truly compete with, and no more of those annoying manc accents once a year.

One relatively minor down side is it probably means the cartel will hoover up what’s left, and whoever replaces City from the championship won’t have the same appeal, so TV rights will reduce over the long term,
Especially as no one can invest to break that up, which means we’ll probably lose out position as the top league in the world and the stars that go with it.

The major downside risk is City and its sponsors sue the premier league and win, and likely win due to the burden of proof re Sham ownership being so high (and let’s face it, the verdict was amateurish). This would be an existential threat to you and the PL, and you’ll pay your share of the damages. Maybe should have thought twice about putting your name to 3 no marks defaming a country and several major corporations, but what’s done is done.

Option B - speak to owners of the other non-cartel clubs in the PL and agree to give up this charade. Say we overreached in the verdict, it’s unsafe and sack Masters as the fall guy.

Upside is we maintain the status quo you seem relatively happy with and the PL remains relatively unscathed, and you don’t face an existential lawsuit.

Down side is you’ll piss off a lot of cartel centric YouTube channels and commentators.

Me - hmmm
 
The PL lawyers also have a lot of explaining to do, as to why they completely missed this out of their Regulations of the PL and has only just been noticed. Incompetence at both ends of the spectrum. ;)
In defence of pl lawyers they’ve got form fir advising the premier league they were proposing something unlawful and were disregarded at the behest of the red & pink shirts.
 
Everyone knows he sued them over stud rights which eventually led them selling to the Glazers.

You don't need inside knowledge for that.
From memory and I’ve not googled it, Pisscan was loaned Rock of Gibraltar for one flat racing season, after a sensational campaign Pisscan claimed he owned a share of the horse.

ROG was not a prolific sire, had a few group one winners but had a very average stud record.
 
The PL forgets it has picked a fight with City Football Group. A global sporting entity.

City Football Group has teams and fans all over the world, all with the same global sponsors in Etihad and Etisalat.

If these sponsors have been defamed, it is their right to protect themselves. As the PL have picked a fight on a global level, the sponsors can choose their battle field. If they think a NY judge, in a city where Etihad and Etisalat sponsor the local team, would be more favourable then the PL would have to defend themselves just like the BBC are currently doing in Florida.

And of course the judicial system is much more political so pressure could be applied easier than in the UK. Now let’s see, who did Trump appoint to his Board of Peace recently?

They also have a contract with US companies like Boeing for $7b. If I was a shareholder of Boeing I’d be concerned about that liability with a company publicly called out for operating sham contracts with execs.
 
Etihad and Etislat are threatening to sue to protect their own interests, not to help City,
I'm not sure that's entirely true. Yes both companies will look after their own interests but I'm pretty sure that both companies would also do everything in their power to help City. There must have been very high level meetings in Abu Dhabi about the findings of the pl commission, and a strategy moving forward.
 
They'll get the backing but no clubs outside of the red cartel and their hangers on should be interested in this, there's next to nothing to gain for the majority of them at a potentially crippling cost. City should vote in favour, costing the clubs that want to end us hundreds of millions would be the perfect comeuppance, masters head isnt the scalp we want. If we are to ever come out of this on top, being cleared and avoiding punishment isn't enough, the instigators need to suffer and the only way we could ever see that is financially.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top