PL charge City for alleged breaches of financial rules

If ‘sham’ falls away from the statement, does that mean that we could still be guilty of the sponsor malarkey, but that the agreements were not a sham?
That's what the alternative findings are for. The sham findings wouldn't knock out everything we were found to have done in breach of PL rules, but they are the most serious. Knocking out those findings would, I think, make settlement much much more likely.
 
But now everyone is saying that they've found us guilty of it in a biased and legally unsound way. So perhaps he was correct, and the accusation we're all clinging to now about the commission proves his opnion.
We've not been found "guilty" of anything. We were found to be in "breach" of the PL's private members club "rules". The PL has zero statutory investigative or prosecutorial powers.

On this basic premise alone, Borson is wrong. If he can't even get this correct, what weight can be added to any of his other bollox?

The only thing City fans have fallen for is authority bias, because Borson is a solicitor who once acted on behalf of Manchester City Football Club. That doesn't automatically make him right in every aspect of this witch hunt against City.

It may have taken time, but many City fans arrived at the same conclusion about Borson, & they can't all be mistaken.
 
The problem with predictions and opinions is that over time they are proved accurate or bollocks. Stefan's accuracy is fairly average. On the big points he was wrong, perhaps we were all naive in the early days. The PL's IC put us right on that score. I reject most of what he says now because it's guesswork
Any legal professional gets things wrong from time to time, makes incorrect calls, misreads things, places to much weight on certain factors, or sometimes not enough on others. It happens. Nobody is infallible.

The key to sorting the wheat from the chaff is who consistently gets the big calls right in their own chosen specialism area, which as you indicate he manifestly has not.
 
If ‘sham’ falls away from the statement, does that mean that we could still be guilty of the sponsor malarkey, but that the agreements were not a sham?

Yes. Which is why the club needs to concentrate on the funding. Disprove the funding, or at least reduced confidence in the funding finding below the required standard, and the rest falls apart, pretty much.
 
Something smells. I was once tasked with editing a statement from an arbitration hearing. The amount of fine tuning that goes on is incredible. Every word is checked and double checked. Every implication or nuance is checked. This panel statement was appalling. Especially as it was released at a different time to the appendices.

Released by people who had the backing of an organisation (PL) (who had the backing of certain clubs) who have never been told no in their lives.

Pure arrogance from them. Assuming they had the final word.
 
I've no idea who Etisalat are and no idea what they do, I,m assuming internet access in part as last night saw someone one complain they should sort out the internet access/coverage in Nigeria before they get involved with the PL :-)
Mobile phones and they are worth ten times more than Etihad who are worth 4 billion. I think they are the biggest mobile phone operator in the middle east, if I'm not wrong.
 
They either resign or drop the charges, there is no other outcome. They won't risk getting taken to the cleaners by Etihad and Etisalat.
Resigning or dropping the "breach" allegations changes nothing regarding our sponsors being labelled "SHAM" & "DISHONEST".

Even if the PL/IC row back & apologise, there's still been a huge amount of reputational damage caused to City, our sponsors & the way we conduct business. I can't see how the PL/IC can put this particular genie back in the bottle.
 
What about this. The clubs won't back the directors, the directors resign immediately with no guarantee they can't/won't be sued. Then, one of them comes over to us as a whistleblower on the promise of getting their losses covered.
Probably the reason why the cartel will move heaven and earth to get the majorith they need.
Nice thought though on a cold damp evening;-)
 
Me too. Been having a conversation with a rag on Twitter who says he’s never heard of them.

I asked him how many Snapdragons he’s bought!!

Waiting for a reply. I know I shouldn’t but was in the dentist waiting room!
Think the Mrs planted some Snapdragons in the summer. Lasted about 4 weeks then withered and died. Bit like a United title challenge really
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top