PL charge City for alleged breaches of financial rules

I read something to this effect but can't recall the details.

Can you clarify the time-barring issue for me?

What was brought in as a result of the sham finding that would otherwise be excluded?
They couldn't go back more than six or seven year, unless they went nuclear and basically stated fraud in the executive.
 
How many more times! Do not listen to a word he says. He’s playing to the talksport audience of red shirt fans. If he’s on there standing our corner do you think he’ll be invited back any time soon? will he fuck! Delete talksport from your radio trust me it’ll make life better!
mate its like banging your head against a brickwall talk shite sly news bbc hate us !
 
The first two lines of the PL statement are not correct. Firstly the commission is not independent. Secondly it is not a criminal prosecution so we can’t be found guilty. Nor are there any charges. The PL panel is supposed to investigate the PL allegations impartially. It is not there to prosecute but to find out what has happened. The correct term would be that the panel, commissioned by the PL, has found City in breach of PL regulations. Words matter. The PL press release is biased for starters.

Firstly, legally the IC is independent and was it not the case we fought the authority, the process and the potential for bias etc in the HC in the 2021 HC cases and didn't get anywhere? Sure, I get they appear to have been partial, overreached etc with the likes of "sham" etc and we'll get to find out more with the appendices if it is ever released or when we have a victory.

Secondly, disagree about "charges". It is widely used by the IC in the 40 page document. Would you also say they shouldn't have used charges in the document?

Thirdly, I agree about "guilty" and the PL are wrong to use it. It's not included anywhere in the IC document which concludes with "we find the charges set out above to be proven to the requisite standard".


And at this point I'm thinking what a waste of time this post is and about to delete :)
I mean seriously, who fucking cares about using "charges" and "guilty" - strikes me that most fuckers on here have widely used "charges" and "guilty" anyway.
 
I was going to ask: "What would a company alleging defamation by another company have to do to say that any damages awarded should be paid by individual directors (i.e. suing the directors individually as well as the company)?"

So I asked AI. And the most interesting bit (for English law) was one of the criteria for naming individual directors: "Assumption of Personal Responsibility: The director went beyond their normal constitutional role of managing the company and effectively made the tort their own. Courts look closely at whether the director acted merely as an organ of the company (such as voting at a board meeting) or stepped outside that role to drive the wrongful act."

Masters.... Is that what he did?

Apart from having to prove serious financial loss (not just reputational loss), the caution was that "Courts in England and Wales take a dim view of claimants adding directors to a lawsuit merely as a tactical lever to frighten them or force a quick settlement".

And if the clubs refuse indemnity, "might directors resign and avoid liability?" AI: "Liability for a tort attaches to the individual at the exact moment the defamatory statement is published. Stepping down later does not break that legal responsibility."
I doubt he will own it. The blame game will be 'it's the commision who produced the report'.
 
But it wouldn't just be one lawsuit. Wouldn't it be 5 lawsuits for each individual executive/director, and then couldn't the sponsors also sue the PL as a collective? And if the proceedings and verdict were malicious, the tribunal Chair and panel could also be liable, individually. And what about if some clubs conspired with the PL?
Yes this is starting to make sense now very good.
 
I don't get this. If the ceo didnt want to be part of the report from the independent commision then all he has to say is I'm not part of it. If he is part of it then he is liable to be challenged like anyone else who is part of it.
If any clubs in the premier league (the company who is accusing Mcfc of cheating & engaging in sham sponsor contracts), don't want the risk of being sued by Etihad or Etisilat, then all the chief executives of those clubs has to do, is call a press conference & say, we don't agree with what Manchester City are being accused of.
No that’s not how it works, the PL panel released a verdict under the PL umbrella. As CEO and board members if the premier league is sued then the board without the indemnity are liable for costs,whether they try and distance them selves or not.
I’m on a small local town committee, and if there was any debts arising from the organisation as committee members we are liable, we could have indemnity through being a limited charity but like the PL we haven’t.
 
A couple of weeks ago, I said that the wording of the tribunal's report was so inflammatory that I believed that it looked like a deliberate attempt to force action and give the PL an 'out' through a successful appeal. So extreme was the judgement and its labelling of both City and its sponsors as deliberately and wilfully operating sham arrangements that they appeared to be 'demanding' legal action, which they can now put to their members to dig their way out of a problem of their own making.

True, or not, and I have no special insight, I find it incredibly hard to imagine that professional, highly-paid heads of a leading organisation in its field would choose such words with blind ignorance.
 
Last edited:

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top