PL charge City for alleged breaches of financial rules

UEFA felt that the sponsorships were fairly valued. Their argument was that City's owner funded it.
UEFA's position was essentially that the sponsorships were paid at fair market value. However, that doesn't answer the separate question of whether the sponsor itself expected to receive value from the deal.

Something can be purchased at fair market value and still be a poor commercial decision for the buyer. For example, I could buy a property in Italy at fair market value, but if I never travel to Italy and have no use for it, the fact I paid a fair price doesn't mean it was a sensible purchase from my perspective.
 
I've tried to dig out his exact words but can't remember where I've stored them. Perhaps someone can oblige. My memory is that he said that the PL had shown that City had broken PL rules over a 10 year period and then he repeated that part of the verdict that has so enraged our sponsors.
Thanks. Someone gave me the statement. Basically an endorsement of the PL panel verdict. Let's hope he's liable.
 
I don’t think that was the point of OB's post. He's asking why a £4bn corporation, let alone a £40bn one would need to get handouts of a few million to fund any transaction.

I think the answer is partly that Etihad have benefitted enormously from the world wide brand awareness that their sponsorships have provided, to make them the £40bn corporation they are now...
Many state airlines or state owned businesses receive investments from the state. If Etihad is worth billions now, then any state investment was successful.
 
I think a lot of us may end up dissapointed tomorrow, i think the PL will get their numbers.

The more i think about it the less i feel this is driven by us. I suspect when Etihad and Etislat took legal advise the PL understandably reviewed their liability and spotted the potential exposure. And as such they are the ones driving the change.
Tbf I think the glee comes from sponsors taking the PL to court for defamation.

The vote is just a consequence and in all honesty ridiculous that the directors of the PL aren't completely covered.
 
UEFA's position was essentially that the sponsorships were paid at fair market value. However, that doesn't answer the separate question of whether the sponsor itself expected to receive value from the deal.

Something can be purchased at fair market value and still be a poor commercial decision for the buyer. For example, I could buy a property in Italy at fair market value, but if I never travel to Italy and have no use for it, the fact I paid a fair price doesn't mean it was a sensible purchase from my perspective.
Semantic nonsense for the sheer arguments sake.
 
They wouldn't dare impose sanctions with the threat of two sponsors taking them to court hanging over them. If they lost the cinsequences would be horrific.

We'll see. I'm not so bullish.

I think they can impose sanctions, I don't think the sponsors have much room to take them to court (though I'd love to be wrong) and even if legal action is taken it will take many years. Will the HC stay the sanctions until then?
 
It’s effectively a crowdfunder isn’t it? Any club that votes against it can’t be compelled to pay. No insurer will cover it.

Be madness if clubs vote to cover this. Their legal advisors must be against it.

Then again the whole thing is weird.
It certainly is weird, & I don't know where a club will stand if advised to vote no to legally protect themselves, but the vote passes anyway. What then?
 
Agreed, but there wasn't a legal opinion at stake. If a clubs lawyers advises them that they'd be in legal hot water if they go along with Masters' request, & they vote 'not but are still out-voted, what then?
Well you could answer your own question by asking what happened when city (and a few others) voted no to PSR?
It's a 1 club 1 vote system and the majority wins.
What will happen at the next general election when I voted X but Y are elected to power?
 
But what happens if a clubs legal team advise against voting yes, but majority vote yes in any case? Does collective responsibility apply, or do individual clubs have a veto?
Articles can’t be retrospectively changed cover prior incidents so legally clubs can’t be forced to pay on that basis. They may agree to it but it’s a goodwill gesture.

The indemnity issue demonstrates a lack of due diligence but also that the process itself isn’t fit for purpose. So clubs may wonder what other skeletons are in the cupboard. Are the expert witnesses accused of lying going to take action? I would be doing.

I think it’s big this but caveat that as maybe because I want it to be - blue tinted glasses etc.
 
Many state airlines or state owned businesses receive investments from the state. If Etihad is worth billions now, then any state investment was successful.
and global exposure and brand awareness via sponsorship of brilliantly successful football club...
The difference in turnover and profit since 2011 shows the value of the relationship to the airline and makes a mockery of any (pl) argument suggesting the agreement not to be FMV ...
 
To me it sounds like an easy off ramp route for the PL...we couldn't go as far as we wanted to because we'd be sued to buggery...so the report remains redacted to the public and the PL say well we still think they're guilty but the 20 clubs didn't back us to save our skins so this is where it all stops...

Cant see them at all getting a majority vote basically passing any costs to already debt ridden clubs
 
Well you could answer your own question by asking what happened when city (and a few others) voted no to PSR?
It's a 1 club 1 vote system and the majority wins.
What will happen at the next general election when I voted X but Y are elected to power?
You will have to suck it up just like those tobacco chewing, banjo playing, gun totting Republican’s have had to after the US Midterms.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top