PL charge City for alleged breaches of financial rules

English courts have centuries-old "safety valves" to dismantle private tribunals that overreach.

The league will be forced to prove the "sham" allegation from scratch under strict High Court rules of evidence.
This is a bit of an oversimplification. The panel are generally agreed to enjoy privileges and it’s unlikely that a HC judge would rule to remove those. That means that the sponsors would only be able to go after Masters and the PL board for repeating the ‘sham’ statement.

They would put forward at the minimum reportage and public interest in their defence, so to get to a point where a higher court would examine the evidence the court would have to find that there was no reasonable reason for the PL to report the ‘sham’ finding. It’s a very high bar!
 
Putting myself in the place of those who run clubs that are not LFC, MUFC, AFC and their gimpy mate, THFC, I would rather this whole thing just came to an end and reduce the risk of having to potentially pay out a lot of money because of something that only those clubs listed above care about.
The issue for them is how City will take any proposed resolution. It could just be seen as the PL getting a bit of breathing space, whilst giving them time to concoct another cunning plan to nobble City.

I've a feeling that City will only settle for a profound knockout, whereby the PL will never be in a position to come after us again. Ultimately, that ends with the scrapping of FFP, PSR, ATP & SCR & the removal of influence that the red cartel wield over the Premier League board.
 
If the red cartel can convince the rest of the league to risk serious financial damage in order to reject our appeal, then so be it.
I find it hard to grasp given what is a clear direction of travel against the rules that so constrain so many of the Premier League's members.
 
I was stood behind a guy in Greggs Clayton yesterday and I'm pretty sure it was Lord Pannick . As he got his hot ham and cheese baguette I asked ' how's it all going' and he gave me a knowing wink....
I'm taking that as we're home and dry.

Slipped up there mate, no way David Pannick would eat ham.

83b26ddd066a827fd53efe7b55fa3d75.jpg
 
Been in the Trafford centre all day Crimbo shopping with the Mrs. Why is more not being made of our legal team getting hacked? Surely this is big news and more evidence of the how underhanded these twats are
I responded to another poster on this. There is no evidence that our team got hacked. Clifford Chance (who represent us along with hundreds of other clients) did report a hack but everyone and everything has been hacked since last Thu.
 
This is a bit of an oversimplification. The panel are generally agreed to enjoy privileges and it’s unlikely that a HC judge would rule to remove those. That means that the sponsors would only be able to go after Masters and the PL board for repeating the ‘sham’ statement.

They would put forward at the minimum reportage and public interest in their defence, so to get to a point where a higher court would examine the evidence the court would have to find that there was no reasonable reason for the PL to report the ‘sham’ finding. It’s a very high bar!
That old high bar chestnut again. It’s high bar until it’s not.

The panel is held in far too high esteem by many in here. It’s a fucking wet lettuce glorified tennis club.

Simplified, the club has many legal arguments to clear its name. The sponsors also have many legal avenues to explore. The doom merchants can carry on…
 
This is a bit of an oversimplification. The panel are generally agreed to enjoy privileges and it’s unlikely that a HC judge would rule to remove those. That means that the sponsors would only be able to go after Masters and the PL board for repeating the ‘sham’ statement.

They would put forward at the minimum reportage and public interest in their defence, so to get to a point where a higher court would examine the evidence the court would have to find that there was no reasonable reason for the PL to report the ‘sham’ finding. It’s a very high bar!

So is that a high bar for Etihad/Etisalat to prove there's no reasonable reason for the PL to declare "sham" sponsorships?
 
This is a bit of an oversimplification. The panel are generally agreed to enjoy privileges and it’s unlikely that a HC judge would rule to remove those. That means that the sponsors would only be able to go after Masters and the PL board for repeating the ‘sham’ statement.

They would put forward at the minimum reportage and public interest in their defence, so to get to a point where a higher court would examine the evidence the court would have to find that there was no reasonable reason for the PL to report the ‘sham’ finding. It’s a very high bar!

Privilege & public-interest defences could make an Etihad claim difficult, but they don't automatically insulate the PL’s public statements or prevent a court examining the factual basis of their “sham” allegation. Saying the court could only get there by first finding the PL had “no reasonable reason” to publish is legally inaccurate.
 
This is a bit of an oversimplification. The panel are generally agreed to enjoy privileges and it’s unlikely that a HC judge would rule to remove those. That means that the sponsors would only be able to go after Masters and the PL board for repeating the ‘sham’ statement.

They would put forward at the minimum reportage and public interest in their defence, so to get to a point where a higher court would examine the evidence the court would have to find that there was no reasonable reason for the PL to report the ‘sham’ finding. It’s a very high bar!
I agree it is a high bar, but the incompetence of the PL makes me think it is a possibility. The KCs that were supposedly apart of the IC (redacted so we don't actually know) should have had enough information to make an informed decision. But if it could for instance be proven that the IC panel was not made correctly for the circumstances that they were to hear IE Rosen chose people who did not have proper experience or knowledge of financial matters like this. Could it not be possible that the HC at least says that the tribunal was improperly formed and everything needs to be reheard?
 
I wasn't clear. I thought Stefan's point was grasping at straws. It's silly to think that damage would have had to have been so immediate or that it would have made quarterly reports that quickly. It struck me as a bad argument from someone kind of flailing to support his own point.
Yeah that part made no sense. Apart from the timing point, it should be fairly to demonstrate that if you are accused of fraud (which sham contracts are) then you suffer significant reputational damage that will materially hurt your business going forward
 
The issue for them is how City will take any proposed resolution. It could just be seen as the PL getting a bit of breathing space, whilst giving them time to concoct another cunning plan to nobble City.

I've a feeling that City will only settle for a profound knockout, whereby the PL will never be in a position to come after us again. Ultimately, that ends with the scrapping of FFP, PSR, ATP & SCR & the removal of influence that the red cartel wield over the Premier League board.

Utopia - when can we vote on it ?
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top