PL charge City for alleged breaches of financial rules

never mind all this and that and the other.

today is a very significant day...

voyager 1 has become the first human-made object to travel a distance of one light-day from earth.
(about 16 billion miles)
it took 49 years.

onboard it ,and its sister ship, voyager 2, there is a golden disc.
it looks like this...

golden-1.jpg


compiled by carl sagan.
it contains many many things just in case alien life bumps into it,
including,
and i shit you not,
115 images showcasing science, nature, and human culture on our planet.
I believe Man utd get a mention......
 
Is there a chance that the sponsors, Etihad and Etisalet, will have seen the, as of now, unreleased appendix and seen the full accusation of sham contracts?

Regarding tomorrows vote from a city perspective I don’t think it matters what is voted in but I think it is a positive signal that Etihad and Etisalet are both looking increasingly likely to be going down the legal avenue.

What has always struck me as weird throughout this is that there seems to be opinion out there that it is a surprise or shocking that 3rd parties might want to defend themselves.

It’s almost an arrogance that football (the PL) thought they could accuse all these illegal things and co conspiracy in the football bubble and that there would be no repercussions in the real world. Like they thought Etihad and Ettisalet would turn round and go you got us we did something illegal but it’s only football real laws don’t count.
 
never mind all this and that and the other.

today is a very significant day...

voyager 1 has become the first human-made object to travel a distance of one light-day from earth.
(about 16 billion miles)
it took 49 years.

onboard it ,and its sister ship, voyager 2, there is a golden disc.
it looks like this...

golden-1.jpg


compiled by carl sagan.
it contains many many things just in case alien life bumps into it,
including,
and i shit you not,
115 images showcasing science, nature, and human culture on our planet.
Another coincidence from this is that 1 light-day is the how long these charges are gonna take to be sorted.
 
Only the ones I have read about. Seemingly, we can't introduce new evidence or witnesses, which would again leave Etihad on the outside of the tent.

The only fucking entity they have deliberately kept out and, for the life of me, why City have also!
Only thing that makes sense to me is we submitted CAS findings and judgments as evidence thinking they covered all the Etihad evidence so no need for them to appear and repeat it. The panel decided to ignore and dismiss the CAS evidence which we possibly never expected, and that may be part of our appeal,that ignoring evidence from CAS we provided makes any findings unsafe.
Surely when they decided to ignore CAS evidence, at whatever stage that happened City should have been informed and advised if we wanted the evidence contained in it to be considered they needed to hear it direct from Etihad, I’m assuming that never happened.
 
Only thing that makes sense to me is we submitted CAS findings and judgments as evidence thinking they covered all the Etihad evidence so no need for them to appear and repeat it. The panel decided to ignore and dismiss the CAS evidence which we possibly never expected, and that may be part of our appeal,that ignoring evidence from CAS we provided makes any findings unsafe.
Surely when they decided to ignore CAS evidence, at whatever stage that happened City should have been informed and advised if we wanted the evidence contained in it to be considered they needed to hear it direct from Etihad, I’m assuming that never happened.
Decent shout tbf.
 
never mind all this and that and the other.

today is a very significant day...

voyager 1 has become the first human-made object to travel a distance of one light-day from earth.
(about 16 billion miles)
it took 49 years.

onboard it ,and its sister ship, voyager 2, there is a golden disc.
it looks like this...

golden-1.jpg


compiled by carl sagan.
it contains many many things just in case alien life bumps into it,
including,
and i shit you not,
115 images showcasing science, nature, and human culture on our planet.
1000011754.png
 
I believe Man utd get a mention......

There are some highlights of some of their games in the early 70s. Got to keep the local rags happy.

hahaha

thankfully, the disc contains no sport, zero football matches, and no moving images.

it does have a manchester connection,
the self-clocking data encoding method was invented at the university in the late 1940s.


some yank astronaut took a rag flag to the international space station one time,
but voyager is rag-free :)
 
Last edited:
I think people don't get it. When he was saying the bar is so high of guilt before the decision, he's explaining the likelihood and proving that is so low, that he couldn't see City in hot water. He's a City fan and wants to see that happen. However, he knows that the commission have had enough evidence to deliver not just charges but a damning statement that has very little comeback on appeal. In essence the club have lied and it looks like they are trying every avenue to try and get out of this.
It doesn't look great from our owners as it stands. The sponsorship threats don't seem to have much legs either. But we all have to hold back and wait for the judgement..

It's not beyond the realms the commission are perfectly happy to go through with this and kick it into criminal investigations. However we have the right to appeal.

I think we might need to brace ourselves.

People are looking for hope and and he's basically saying good luck with that.
In their opinion we've lied, that doesn't mean we have though. They had already made their minds up that wed lied before the trial started.
 
I wonder if the club have had words with Borson in some capacity and he's gone on the attack against City. Totally changed his tune of late towards us when the charges verdict came out
I'd imagine it's simply a case of appearing to be even slightly pro-City doesn't get you a slot on tabloid radio or column inches on Football Insider.
 
Is there a chance that the sponsors, Etihad and Etisalet, will have seen the, as of now, unreleased appendix and seen the full accusation of sham contracts?

Regarding tomorrows vote from a city perspective I don’t think it matters what is voted in but I think it is a positive signal that Etihad and Etisalet are both looking increasingly likely to be going down the legal avenue.

What has always struck me as weird throughout this is that there seems to be opinion out there that it is a surprise or shocking that 3rd parties might want to defend themselves.

It’s almost an arrogance that football (the PL) thought they could accuse all these illegal things and co conspiracy in the football bubble and that there would be no repercussions in the real world. Like they thought Etihad and Ettisalet would turn round and go you got us we did something illegal but it’s only football real laws don’t count.
You would also assume that PL legal counsel would vehemently tell the league and the directors that they are not sufficiently guarded against 3rd party litigation. If they decided to ignore legal counsel on this then that is pretty damning of their ability to make intelligent decisions.
 
You can sue multiple people and organisations you know. I'd be suing the lot of them in a load of different countries if I were Etihad
Yes I’m aware of that but just because you can it doesn’t mean you should
I’d be the same as you and go after the lot of them but we’re fans and the club will be more measured
I don’t think it would particularly help us if City are seen to be firing off lawsuits every 5 minutes at individuals
 
Yeah, sponsor litigation wouldn't automatically trigger a complete rehearing of the football case, but your point that Blackstone would have vetted the PL's statement isn't much of a legal answer. If a viable claim gets past preliminary defences & truth is put in issue, the factual basis of the "sham" allegation could still come under much more direct court scrutiny.
This case revolves around where the money came from. If it goes to court and they prove the revenue stream came from ADG and not ADUG thenthis will blow the whole sham contract rubbish wide open and the cases findings will therefore be false and unsafe
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top