PL charge City for alleged breaches of financial rules | Etisalat threaten legal action, PL vote on Thurs to give board indemnity (p11454)

I expect any announcement about this meeting being made next week, next Friday probably. Just before we play Arsenal away.
Depends on the result. If it's a huge majority in favour of Master's requests, it'll be released within minutes so there can be a week of City bashing before the arsenal game.
 
It’s quite simple……

City is owned in Sheik Mansours name but is really Abu Dhabi state owned as a sports washing project, but even though sheik Mansour isn’t really the owner he pays the sponsorship as the multi billion dollar state owned companies don’t have the funds…..

You forgot to mention that he does that, but he doesn't know about it...
 
Masters made a statement saying that they had been vindicated proving that city had systematically broke the rules over a decade, now while the case is still very much pending appeal that could be construed as slander after the 'independent' panels previous statement so he really only has himself to blame, the smart move would have been to come out and say while we appreciate the panels findings it is citys right to appeal and i cannot comment any further until this process has been completed.
Yep, he and the PL couldn't help themselves. You reap what you sow.
 
And not a single quote of evidence to support the story? But as usually the case with anything city, who needs little things like evidence to write a story

Agree i think a 2b loan wouldn't be with drawn on the opinion of a faceless panel. Big business doesn't work like that
 
This is a good post. I would add, however, that there is the possibility of City going to court against the PL in a separate action to the sponsors. To that end, I think it's not a case of us and the club hoping that Etihad and Etisalat help get us out of this pickle and more a case that there are several potential lines of attack, of which Etihad/Etisalat is just one.

We also need to consider what else the club may have up their sleeve. There has been plenty of talk of us having dirt on the PL and certain other clubs and while I'm more than happy to accept that this is no more than wishful thinking at this stage, the way Khaldoon has spoken down the years suggests there's something in it. By dirt, I don't mean THAT photo of various United, Liverpool, and Arsenal execs from 2017. That's fuck-all and not cogent evidence of anything. I'm talking communications that may have been revealed during the APT case, plus material passed on to us by other clubs - it's been rumoured that Newcastle handed over a whole tranche of stuff to City according to someone from the Newcastle side.

Whether there is any substance to the above paragraph remains to be seen but generally speaking I do think there are more moving parts to this that we're either not aware of or not factoring in to the process.

Whatever the club may 'have up their sleeve' (and I think that's wishful thinking and a bit of a cliché fwiw), wouldn't really matter now.

It would only become relevant, if the club were to go to court separate with a case we are deliberately being treated unfairly.

Oh wait..
 
Aren't the sponsors accused to have taken part in the so called sham identified in a de facto manner due to the amount of fraud claimed to have been undertaken (900m)?

Without Etihad & Etisalat's contributions, the figure identified would be much less, so even if they dont show up in the redacted sections of the report, it can be reasonably summised that they are one of the parties having colluded with ADUG.
That will be the commission making those claims & not the individual board members.
 
Should every club in the championship or even lower get to vote as the whole purpose of the league system is to get to the top league.

So if this drags, on a club currently in league 1 could be saddled with a bill of millions in a couple of years.
That's something I thought about as well. It's been touched on that wrapping up the case, if you include possible HC hearings, appeals etc could take 5 years. Who the hell can predict who'll be in the PL by then?
 
What kind of quote would you like? It's the Financial Times ffs, do you reckon they've just plucked a story out of thin air yet neither the club not Apollo wish to deny it?
Maybe you and I differ my friend. But in this world of online fake news and propaganda, I always like to see evidence of some sort with my own eyes, rather than rely on a media outlet to guarantee proof. This is especially valid with anything related to city, as the ratio of bullshit to fact is about 99 to 1
 
Speaking personally, I don't feel I am convincing myself of anything.

When all this started my assessment was that it would be impossible for the PL to prove their allegations, either because the club didn't do what was alleged or because the PL wouldn't have the evidence to prove the allegations to the required standard.

I haven't seen anything to change that belief, honestly. I see conclusions of lying, forging, concocting, dishonesty, sham contracts, limited evidence, and ignored evidence made by anonymous (so far) people and without seeing any detail (so far). I am not ready yet to ditch my initial assessment or my belief in the club's claims of significant errors of law, principle and fact in the judgment.

I don't think that makes me naive, stupid or easily led. Does it make me right? Maybe not. We will see when all this is over.
The verdict PL came to was not predictable bearing in mind the apparent evidence City had.

How could any fair minded legal process predict they would bar such evidence and anything else that threatened their use of a probability verdict ?
 
Masters made a statement saying that they had been vindicated proving that city had systematically broke the rules over a decade, now while the case is still very much pending appeal that could be construed as slander after the 'independent' panels previous statement so he really only has himself to blame, the smart move would have been to come out and say while we appreciate the panels findings it is citys right to appeal and i cannot comment any further until this process has been completed.
He made a statement of fact. Not sure anyone can sue you for that?

If a player receives a red card then you'd say he got a red card regardless of whether he's appealed it or not.
 
Look like the BBC might be expecting some rule changes. Article on there talking about how the 'big 6' keep getting richer at the expense of everyone else.

I'm not linking it because fuck em.
Out of interest are we included in the big six or would this pertain to the old school big six?
 
I could see us abstaining. It's right that they are protected, but we publicly think the league (and its board) have said something about our sponsors and us that isnt true. Why would we vote for us to cover the consequences of that. I think the vote will pass anyway, but our point will have been made.
I can see City voting in favour. It wouldn't affect the Etihad/Etisalat case. It would make the other clubs realise that the PL directors are on dodgy ground
 
This is exactly how I see it, yet some are saying they want the vote to go the PL's way.
I'm not saying they're wrong but haven't seen anything convincing that means they're right.
Basically, frustration wins again, this shit does your head in.
The immediate problem for the clubs is that if they don't vote yes, Masters and the others would probably resign as a) they would be pissed off they weren't being supported and b) the financial implications they would face of an Etisalat win.
Hiring new people would be nigh on impossible and it would become an existential crisis for the PL So presuming the clubs don't want the PL to collapse the only sensible thing is to vote yes.
Even us possibly. If the PL were no more what would happen to the charges. Well they'd probably disappear which sounds good but the media view would be that we bullied it into a collapse and also we wouldn't be able to clear our name in court.
If the FA were to take over the running of Division 1 again it is no guarantee we'd be invited. In fact without the PL the whole thing becomes messy and unpredictable.

This narrative assumes the cartel aren't hoping for a collapse for their own ends.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top