PL charge City for alleged breaches of financial rules | Etisalat threaten legal action, PL vote on Thurs to give board indemnity (p11454)

My concern is that a lender may be assessing the legal and reputational risks associated with a potential conduct finding and concluding that those risks outweigh the rewards. If the charges are upheld, it raises legitimate questions about CFG's ability to secure or renew major credit facilities in the future.
Possibly.
 
Maybe the owners of the non big six clubs should read the below before accepting premier league rules.
They have no chance of competing within the present rules..


 
Should we win the case it will be the club's footing the bill anyway.
Yeah, although I was talking about the separate cases by our sponsors as third parties, which is what (reportedly) the PL Board are trying to separate themselves individually from.
 
City should today spell out in the League meeting, in very precise terms, that if they sustain this verdict, then the entire Premier League is one step away from serious damage.

They can burn the Etihad down but it is close now to burning the Premier League.

Risk management is going to lead to a settlement imo.
 
I think that assumption is safe - the reports suggest that's the case.

On the face of it why would you vote to be liable for something you aren't currently liable for?

However, to ensure the PL as a company operates in the best of interests of its stakeholders you'd want board members to be indemnified from bearing the costs of legal proceedings. As I've said before, most would act differently if their own money was on the line. This whole vote is evidence of that. If it doesn't go through I think it's significant for City because you've got 5 individual people with a lot to lose and they'll instantly try and find a way out of that situation.
Agree, but it depends on the context and where the goalposts are. At the start or ahead of any process yet to unfold, of course, that is the obvious default position to take.

However now, when the actions and maybe the proclamations of the board have brought a bout a very real threat with potential financial consequences, then is it such a reasonable stance to take, for their own clubs?

If they do though, I can see the media arguing that as an 'endorsement' of the PL actions in this process.
 
I’ve seen a few posts claiming City could bring a separate case against the PL to the High Court or indeed sue the PL as part of the current 115 case.

I don’t think that’s the case. City would find it hard to claim compensation from the PL even if it won the current case. All PL member clubs sign an agreement to not do so.

The one area that is not clear is if City were outside the PL (say we were in the Championship for example) and then brought the case as a non member of the PL? I still think it unlikely but maybe not impossible. This maybe one of the reasons that the sponsors of City rather than City themselves are more likely to go ahead with a claim.
City can, through the Arbitration Act, take the PL to court through section 68, arguing that the procedure itself was seriously flawed and not impartial, which has been City's core argument from the beginning. City will be seeking an overturn of the judgement, not seeking damages.

That's Etihad and Etisalats engagement.
 
The bit that stood out there for me was the mention of the SWF relationship which was a reminder to me Mubadala have an existing relationship with Apollo. A liitle bit of research and it seems Apollo are taking a minority share in Mubadala Capital ( a subsid.) and that deal was agreed on on 26th October ie a month after we found out about the City shit show.

It could be that Apollo had already pulled out of any proposed £2billion to CFG at the same time and, in any case, had been predicated on City clearing the substantial elements (as everyone expected) of the case first time round.

Negotiations over a $2 billion loan between Apollo and CFG would normally be highly confidential, particularly if they had reached the final stages, as the Financial Times reports.

So the interesting question is how the FT obtained this information. And who might benefit from making public a concrete example of the financial damage caused by the Premier League's decision?
 
Today is the day that Soriano takes the news from the FT, combines it with the £20 Billion combined turnover of Etihad and Etisalat, and links likely forthcoming losses for our sponsors to the PL through a defamation action that is a direct consequence of sham findings with our sponsors.

If the sponsor actions are credible, they will be enough to force a settlement, because their losses can become PL losses.
 
Not really a huge surprise that our credit risk is higher than usual right now, pending the appeal and any possible decision on sanctions. Don’t think this is that big a deal, yet.
I may be missing something and being very naive but :

The Premier League is a competition organiser owned by its 20 member clubs. The FA holds a special share, and the game is moving into an era of greater regulatory oversight through the Independent Football Regulator. Yet we are asked to accept that the same organisation could pursue proceedings that might inflict catastrophic financial damage on one of its own members.

If that member happens to be one of the most financially successful and profitable clubs in the English game, the questions become even more difficult. Any serious damage would affect not only the club but also employees throughout the wider CFG structure.

Whether one supports City or not, that tension merits proper investigation. There is a compelling story here for journalists willing to challenge prevailing assumptions and examine the broader implications of football's governance model.
 
The FT article is fantastic news for us & cannot have been released at a more optimal time (ahem).

There can't be a claim that the chance of damages is negligible, when an article already directly links the loss of a 2bn loan directly linked to the proceedings (i.e. if it does go to court, and we are cleared, then the opening Xm of damages is right there, not including anything that Etisalat & Etihad may choose to tack on).

I very much suspect that we've had a hand in this coming out, as it serves our purpose as a portent of what kind of exposure they're looking at marvellously.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top