PL charge City for alleged breaches of financial rules | Etisalat threaten legal action, PL vote on Thurs to give board indemnity (p11454)

Wouldn't the best way to correct the liability position of the directors be to take out insurance rather than ask the PL clubs to underwrite their costs? Presumably insurance they now cannot get in light of City's case and the threats made by Etihad and Etisalat?
We only believe they are asking clubs to put up guarantees due press leak reports I am guessing it is just a vote to indemnify directors which would be insurance.
 
Isn’t it a bit more complex than that? Like taking out car insurance after you’ve been involved in an accident.
i used to do the Directors Indemnity Insurance as part of my job yeats ago. its a hell of a faff as I remember and every director has to complete a detailed questionnaire with potential actions listed. I don't remember it being something issued lightly.
 
Forget the vote.

The bigger issue is that the Premier League knows that it is exposed to damages claims from our sponsors.

An example for illustration...

Etihad Airways is 100% owned by the Abu Dhabi Emirate and it has been planning to launch an Initial Public Offering whereby they would sell off 20% of the airline through issuing shares on on the Abu Dhabi Securities Exchange raising $1 billion in the process. The plans have been put on hold due to the fuel crisis and the PL verdict now further damages that prospect.

I am not suggesting this will happen but today's news shows that the consequential losses for City and potentially its sponsors are huge, and the PL can be held liable for the sponsor's losses.
 
God, it's nice to hear a lawyer talking the big picture and, just as importantly, not talking about a case without all the details.

When this guy talks, you listen.
I think that one angle of attack if it goes to the HC is the nature of the whole regulatory system. in the debate surrounding the introduction of the FFP rules the opinion of many/most lawyers was exactly that they were anti-competitive and designed to maintain "the establishment " by limiting investment. Investment is limited to revenue from certain income streams and although investment on infrastructure is allowed it is limited because interest payments mus not violate the break even point on acceptable revenue. Thus clubs with large revenues built on high levels of debt were fine: clubs withe rich owners but modest revenues were not.

Where City might prosper is that the statutes dealing with competition law make it illegal to prohibit or limit investment and furthermore they lay down that any sanctions imposed to limit or prohibit investment are null and void. City can argue that they have not disguised investment as sponsorshiip but that they are being punished under regulations which are unlawful anyway OR, if need be, they can argue that ADUG is quite entitled to invest in Etihad and Etihad is entitled to sponsor City for whatever it wants.

This doesn't affect any other lines of attack and it could stuff the PL good and proper.
 
i missed this in a busy week at work; this vote is Masters asking the rest of the league to shoulder potential liability from legal challenges? or just legal costs?

is that specifically for City related cases to come, or just a general PL rule moving forward? is it fees or total liability? thanks
 
Without wishing to put a damper on the clubs voting against the PL indemnity request today, they are not exposing themselves to potential losses of 50-100 million per club. They will each take out their own indemnity insurance to cover a potential loss.

For example, I have to have Professional Indemnity insurance in my line of work. I pay £400 per year and covered for £2 million. So, should Etihad/Etilsat win their potential case against the Premier League for say 1 billion, this would be 50 million per club. Each clubs Indemnity insurance would cover the payout, costing them (doing the maths from my example) only 10K. Obviously this would be more but not seriously more money.

So, I wouldn’t get too excited about today’s vote.
I wish our PI was £400 per year but when you are advising on clients pensions, investments and mortgages the risks are high and the PI premiums are now eye watering.
 
If IFR steps in & says *STOP*, the battle frontline will freeze where it is. IFR then has the opportunity to be the adult in the room & throw out our breaches, & put in place a fairer more workable solution for football governance.

This is why I strongly believe we need to get ahead of the end game, & craft our own proposals for what comes next after FFP, PSR, ATP & SCR. That will be the final battle of Armegeddon, where hopefully peace will reign thereafter.
This is the whole point of an IFR but I am not convinced by Kogan so far.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top