PL charge City for alleged breaches of financial rules | Etisalat threaten legal action, PL vote on Thurs to give board indemnity (p11454)

have a bad feeling the vote is going to be like 19 yes , 1 no lol.
or 11 yes, 3 no, few not voting either way and it it is still going through as 11/14 is still good for them even is 6 doesnt vote...
Changing Premier League rules requires approval from at least two-thirds of Member Clubs, which equals 14 out of 20 clubs. So if 6 abstain all others have to vote yes.
 
Today is the day that Soriano takes the news from the FT, combines it with the £20 Billion combined turnover of Etihad and Etisalat, and links likely forthcoming losses for our sponsors to the PL through a defamation action that is a direct consequence of sham findings with our sponsors.

If the sponsor actions are credible, they will be enough to force a settlement, because their losses can become PL losses.

You've watched too many 'law' tv series.
 
City can, through the Arbitration Act, take the PL to court through section 68, arguing that the procedure itself was seriously flawed and not impartial, which has been City's core argument from the beginning. City will be seeking an overturn of the judgement, not seeking damages.

That's Etihad and Etisalats engagement.
I think there is a distinction. City wouldn’t be taking the PL to court they would be defending themselves rather than starting an action against the PL.
 
i missed this in a busy week at work; this vote is Masters asking the rest of the league to shoulder potential liability from legal challenges? or just legal costs?

is that specifically for City related cases to come, or just a general PL rule moving forward? is it fees or total liability? thanks
The 5 directors are not indemnified against lawsuits from third parties, so this is a vote to add this to the rules. It is generic but is catalyzed by the City charges and Etihad’s threat to sue to defend its reputation. The indemnity is against legal fees and any consequences.
 
What are we making of the Apollo loan stuff? Immediate reaction is that it is depressive news
In isolation damaging for Mansour and the City Group but it is a double edged sword. It underlines a threat to the Premier League in that this verdict will lead to financial damage to City AND our sponsors.

Our sponsors have threatened the Premier League with defamation claims so sponsor losses become Premier League losses if they win defamation actions. That is a major risk to the Premier League.

The only way the Premier League can mitigate this risk is by reaching a settlement agreement and even then our sponsors might still sue.
 
Unpopular opinion time!

I expect this to pass with 100% support, including City.
Reasons:
1. We aren't the PL & operate with a lot more class than them.
2. We wouldn't want to be seen to be deliberately trying to bankrupt employees in the course of their normal jobs.
3. There are already provisions for removing them from office due to poor performance or malicious acts i.e. there are already remedies if they were to act outside of the boundaries of their roles.
4. The sponsors have issues with the PL commissions verdict & wording. These weren't written by the PL board. I'm not sure what the Sponsors would be going after the individuals for? The board brought the case forward, which we all think is a load of bollocks, but the board didn't name the sponsors in the original charges (I don't think they did but will happily be corrected on this).
We are all blinkered to think in terms of the City case, but if City, or any other club, vote in favour they are covering the board for every other case in the future. Everton, NottsForest can testify to the fact that the board has no qualms about who it comes after. How many other sponsors might take issue in the future with the PL and don't worry we'll all cover trick Dick's costs and dmages. Clubs may be giving a cartel stooge dangerous freedom from any restraint if they support this. Are Necastle really comfortable with this? Are others?
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top