PL charge City for alleged breaches of financial rules | Etisalat threaten legal action, PL vote on Thurs to give board indemnity (p11454)

Whether the story is accurate or not, it illustrates the scale of the problems for City, sponsors and the Premier League because these types of corporate actions are common place. City's ownership and their sponsors will be affected in time, and the PL is exposed to sponsor losses through defamation actions on the sham ruling.
 
It's not really a question of collateral or whether our owner can personally afford it. The more significant issue is that a lender appears to have viewed the potential consequences of a conduct finding as a risk it wasn't prepared to underwrite. That's a very different discussion from CFG's access to capital.

If that interpretation is correct, it also underlines why it is imperative that some or all of the charges are overturned. The real damage is not the ability to raise funds today, but the reputational and legal uncertainty that can influence third parties' willingness to do business with the group.
It’s actually an existential threat to the PL itself and to indebted clubs in particular. If the most successful, most solvent club, backed by a huge sovereign wealth fund find cannot get access to credit, the whole house of cards might well be about to come toppling down.
It’s going to be an absolute shit show unless common sense is injected into this persecution very, very soon.
 
I read on here that if this is not passed the current directors might resign and the board wouldn’t be able to find replacements as no one would take the job. My question is the present incumbents did and they include KC’s so did they not realised what they were signing up to and who advised them that they could now be on a sticky wicket
 
I read on here that if this is not passed the current directors might resign and the board wouldn’t be able to find replacements as no one would take the job. My question is the present incumbents did and they include KC’s so did they not realised what they were signing up to and who advised them that they could now be on a sticky wicket
This place would also tell you that if we're relegated, it's a soft signal we're winning. Proceed with caution.
 
Say the publication of the Commission’s findings forces CFG to secure alternative financing at an interest rate two percentage points higher. On a $2 billion loan, that would mean an additional $200 million in interest costs over five years.

That could potentially form the basis of a substantial damages claim by CFG against the Premier League over the publication of the findings.
 
I think that one angle of attack if it goes to the HC is the nature of the whole regulatory system. in the debate surrounding the introduction of the FFP rules the opinion of many/most lawyers was exactly that they were anti-competitive and designed to maintain "the establishment " by limiting investment. Investment is limited to revenue from certain income streams and although investment on infrastructure is allowed it is limited because interest payments mus not violate the break even point on acceptable revenue. Thus clubs with large revenues built on high levels of debt were fine: clubs withe rich owners but modest revenues were not.

Where City might prosper is that the statutes dealing with competition law make it illegal to prohibit or limit investment and furthermore they lay down that any sanctions imposed to limit or prohibit investment are null and void. City can argue that they have not disguised investment as sponsorshiip but that they are being punished under regulations which are unlawful anyway OR, if need be, they can argue that ADUG is quite entitled to invest in Etihad and Etihad is entitled to sponsor City for whatever it wants.

This doesn't affect any other lines of attack and it could stuff the PL good and proper.

It's almost like the court case at the beginning of this process was a test to see how the courts would view jurisdiction challenges, and the APT case was a test to see how the internal arbitration would view a competition argument.

Who would have thought it?
 
I read on here that if this is not passed the current directors might resign and the board wouldn’t be able to find replacements as no one would take the job. My question is the present incumbents did and they include KC’s so did they not realised what they were signing up to and who advised them that they could now be on a sticky wicket

I dont think there are any KC's on the pl board.
The KC's are on the pl own independent commission
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top