PL charge City for alleged breaches of financial rules

Tolmie posted on here that he had been told off a good source that the original leak hadn’t come from Arsenal (through Ornstein) on the original leak on the 29th September. It’s all mute obviously, anyone got any thoughts as to where the leak came from ?
For me it’s Spurs.
And I remain convinced it’s got something to do with Levy stepping down ?
Can’t see it being United either , so if not Spurs it’s Liverpool?
The link is somewhere out there, just very odd that the IC panel remain anonymous through fear of retribution?
Someone is behind this , and it’s either one or the other.
Can’t beat a conspiracy theory!
 
A lot of people taking this personally. This isn't a everybody is against us situation here so lets not twist it into that.

Whilst the threat of our sponsors may have caused them to spot it, this isnt specific to our case. The clubs are essentially voting for something that should have been in place already, it was just yet another poor oversight in the rulebook. Taking our situation out of it, Masters and the others should have legal protection from those they represent. I suspect we would have voted for it too if we wasn't at war with them.

Going back to what this means for our case, i'm arguing its a good thing. If we are to come out of this on top, the red cartel can't pin it all on their puppet, Masters anymore. they'll suffer for it financially as will everybody else which won't make us any friends but it also won't have some of the other clubs willing to let the red cartel dictate to them how things should go in the future when its costing them directly.

This was always going to pass, it's nothing to fret about.
I think this is the most appropriate reaction on the thread. The vote has just emphasised the sheer incompetence of the dickheads running the PL. Nothing more.
 
Whilst I fully expected this vote to get passed, I did wonder if a few clubs would make Masters sweat a bit and get the vote deferred. I’m thinking the clubs who’ve been shafted by the cartel like Vile(no spelling mistake) Newcastle (previous letter signers) Everton (keep us informed) Coventry who we’ve loaned players to, but no, only Forest and us.

Now i imagine there was lots of lobbying and in reality I don’t think it makes any difference to our appeal and possible legal action from our sponsors, but you’d think some of the other clubs would say hold on, let’s see the details.

My take away is we have zero friends at other clubs, even clubs owned or sponsored by Middle East. The Arses are sponsored by Emirates, where has the support come from them? Didn’t Adult Dhabi bail out Dubai? Isn’t that tower named after the Abu Dhabi leader?

Whilst nothing has changed today materially, it would have been nice to see a few ripples in the pond.
It's a political minefield, I fully understand clubs passing it as no one want to be the next "city" the forest owner doesn't give a sh!t and we are already in the mud. If was another club in our place we would be probably be pressured into voting to pass it to. Nothing changes league to win and the high court awaits.
 
Totally agree with your last point. Why would you ask the PL to protect you and your cronies from indemnity if your independent commission's finding were watertight and irrefutable?

Their (the IC) findings are all based on "we think", "we feel", "we don't believe", "concocted" evidence, not actual, factual evidence. It's all down to the balance of probabilities. The PL must feel that their watertight case actually is starting to leak and could be torn to shreds if it goes to the High Court and leaving them, Masters and his cronies open to massive damages claims from not only City but Etihad and Etisalat and others.
Agreed 100%. As I keep stressing, there's a world of difference between a private members club rules & UK Law. We were never gonna get a fair hearing with this kangaroo court, hence why I'm relatively unconcerned & relaxed about the situation.

We just need to let the process play itself out, until we have our day in front of proper legal professionals. Masters & Co may have slipped the personal noose, but when push comes to shove the records will still show the PL board were bankrupted because of their blind stupidity, & it's only because of the red cartel why they still have the shirts on their backs.

Masters will have enough money to retire comfortably after today's agreement, which is lucky for him, because after this, I doubt he'd even get a job shovelling shit down a sewer where he belongs.
 
Have we seen what they actually voted on? I find it hard to believe the clubs would take the liability on, even if they wanted to screw us - that would be monumentally stupid. Maybe it's a change to their rules for any future cases? Insurance companies won't cover them retroactively, but any change could be written into future policies/coverage (as any competent company does).

Do we know for sure the clubs are going to cover Masters and Co in this case? If they did, their stupidity knows absolutely no bounds IMO.
 
You surely weren’t expecting support from fucking Arsenal, of all clubs?! They’re one the main drivers behind all this!
Tolmie said that the original leak( through Ornstein) hadn’t originated from Arsenal ? This has Spurs (Levy) written all over it. It’s their jumped up style - always on the outside looking in. It’s a classic we will load the gun for someone else to fire isn’t it ? A jumped up original founder of the original big five back in the day? It’s spurs all over this. Funny how they buy our players when Levy did one ? No chance he would have bought our players if he was still in charge.
 
Dont hold your breath, they are probably lining up "investigations" concerning our 2019-2026 accounts as we type.

Any other clubs outside the cartel will have any ambition nipped in the bud from now on, to save competition.

We are currently paying the price for competing with and beating the red cartel on the pitch.

The worst part of all this is that "if" we self financed to the tune of 850 million, all that figure represents was how much was required to be invested to win trophies off the cartel.

Thats how far ahead they had positioned themselves over the past 30 years, with help from sky/media and the pl itself of course.

Its easy for them to scupper any challenge when clubs with ambition have no route to compete on an even keel, and are asset stripped by the clubs above them every time they try.

Thats what the current "rules" represent, anyone surely can see that, and thats why Im not bothered if we did self finance.

All those "legacy clubs" achieved their best periods without restrictive rules, yet squeal at such an idea now, while enjoying special dispensations themselves.

Should be challenged for the monopolistic cartel it really is.
Like it or not football is a business now, clubs are listed on the stock exchange with owners like the Glazers taking out millions in dividends and as such should be subject to normal business practice, imagine the federation of retailers having rules drawn up by the big chains like Asda,Tesco etc that stopped investment to smaller grocers and start ups, there would be uproar.
 
No surprise that the PL won the vote, I'd hate it if the cunts had the final vote on possibly expelling us from the league, I think its safe to say we've got no mates who'd have our backs.
Yep it’s looking bad in that respect. I had presumed there was no way they would get the votes to throw us out, think they need 15. Now I would say if the panel who did the hatchet job on us recommends throwing us out, we’re fucked. We need to get something big out of this appeal.
 
Interesting stories about City’s risk being managed by financial institutions, credit will be refused for clubs selling, loan of £2b refused. No stories about the premier league risk being managed? At what point did they realise they didn’t have full coverage & surely your first call is to your broker & not to 20 CEOs to take on the risk.

I wonder if this refusal for additional insurance will ever leak?
 
Last edited:
Totally agree with this. I actually joined the forum to say exactly that, as a fellow football fan, albeit a fan of a different club.

Whatever has or has not been done the club staff and the fans are completely innocent and shouldn't be going through all this.

(If you're thinking of replying to say you don't need the sympathy of an Arsenal fan and/or to call me a ****, please don't bother, I hereby withdraw my concern in your specific case.)
What you fail to understand is Manchester City Football Club stand as one, from our superb owner, down to Doris the tea lady & everyone in between.

You come for one, you come for ALL, so go tell the fans of your club & anyone who cares to listen, there's no separating our owner & management from us City fans.

We're Manchester & we do things differently here.
 
TueartsOHK makes a good point that I was thinking about. What Insurance company would provide cover for 18 clubs with a potential billion pound legal fight??. I assume it won't be 18 different companies. Surely we now hear about clubs policies being cancelled or not renewed??

I imagine they are self insured, lose £200m, then every club is £10m worse off.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top