PL charge City for alleged breaches of financial rules

I disagree - it shows the PL are a little worried about their position. This vote was always going to pass but the PL have shown a glimpse of weakness by bringing it forward & also showing some signs of incompetence that it was ever needed.

Oh, I mean, people seemed to be getting really negative about it, I agree with you, but they're clearly worried.
 
They want us gone or so called big clubs do their owner watch us put profit back in build ground and entertainment complex like they have in America but here they are behind 8 ball and sucked money out game instead of being on front foot build the like themselves. They dont won't to spend here
I agree certain clubs want us gone but I'm not so certain the PL do. A club the size of Manchester City with close to 150 years history isn't just going to be closed down or whatever. We are a bit of a juggernaut of a club these days, a behemoth and a global brand and whatever the social media world says the Premier League will not want to lose us. No league would I just don't believe that's what they want. I'm sure they want to fine us massively and put transfer bans on us and points reductions but I'll be surprised if they did enough to relegate us in one single season. They would be stupid to do something that severe and it would affect their own brand and income. They would leave enough wiggle room for us to stay up. And also the more severe they hit us the more severe the counter claim would be if we were to win in the high courts at a later date.
 
Grim reading as you say.
Worth remembering though that it’ll be their words from their side of the argument.
It’ll be layed on with a trowel the ‘sham’ side of it.
What it won’t say is why they ignored City, SM and Etihad’s bank statements and witnesses, other than ‘we think’ or ‘we don’t believe’
If they had more City, Khaldoon, Etihad and Etisalat would know about it and wouldn’t still be so confident.
Still need this in a court where ‘we think’ won’t be good enough.
The panel is supposed to be impartial so, in theory, should have examined evidence from both sides. If it is true that they didn't even consider City's evidence which led to us being cleared at CAS then it is a total disgrace. An absolute stain on the UK legal system. The idea that an anonymous panel of three people should accuse a global company of fraud without a proper investigation is ridiculous. How can it be an independent decision when the public don't even know who is on the panel?
 
Totally agree with this. I actually joined the forum to say exactly that, as a fellow football fan, albeit a fan of a different club.

Whatever has or has not been done the club staff and the fans are completely innocent and shouldn't be going through all this.

(If you're thinking of replying to say you don't need the sympathy of an Arsenal fan and/or to call me a ****, please don't bother, I hereby withdraw my concern in your specific case.)

How many posts have offered sympathy versus snide comments? I’m curious & won’t look but appreciate the nice words….. on this occasion.
 
Tolmie posted on here that he had been told off a good source that the original leak hadn’t come from Arsenal (through Ornstein) on the original leak on the 29th September. It’s all mute obviously, anyone got any thoughts as to where the leak came from ?
For me it’s Spurs.
And I remain convinced it’s got something to do with Levy stepping down ?
Can’t see it being United either , so if not Spurs it’s Liverpool?
The link is somewhere out there, just very odd that the IC panel remain anonymous through fear of retribution?
Someone is behind this , and it’s either one or the other.
Can’t beat a conspiracy theory!

My money is Liverpool if anyone.

We are responsible in their eyes for them not racking up a near on decade of domination.

Had we not been in the picture, they would have possibly won 5 or 6 league titles under Klopp, alongside numerous FA Cups and League Cups.

Also had we not been there taking them to the wire in gruelling 90+ point league campaigns, they may have had that extra bit in them to get over the line in a couple of the CL finals they lost.

Whilst I don't think we will ever have a period like we did under Pep in my lifetime, I don't think Liverpool will either.

Klopp gave them the best years they have had in 30 years and in my opinion won't be matched in the next 30 years either.
 
Totally agree with this. I actually joined the forum to say exactly that, as a fellow football fan, albeit a fan of a different club.

Whatever has or has not been done the club staff and the fans are completely innocent and shouldn't be going through all this.

(If you're thinking of replying to say you don't need the sympathy of an Arsenal fan and/or to call me a ****, please don't bother, I hereby withdraw my concern in your specific case.)

Tagamet treated acid reflux.
 
I agree certain clubs want us gone but I'm not so certain the PL do. A club the size of Manchester City with close to 150 years history isn't just going to be closed down or whatever. We are a bit of a juggernaut of a club these days, a behemoth and a global brand and whatever the social media world says the Premier League will not want to lose us. No league would I just don't believe that's what they want. I'm sure they want to fine us massively and put transfer bans on us and points reductions but I'll be surprised if they did enough to relegate us in one single season. They would be stupid to do something that severe and it would affect their own brand and income. They would leave enough wiggle room for us to stay up. And also the more severe they hit us the more severe the counter claim would be if we were to win in the high courts at a later date.

It’s not the premier league per se it’s the 5 person board specifically recruited to destroy us.
 
City won’t be in the PL when the court proceedings start against Masters and the other PL directors, so we don’t have to worry about paying their court costs, etc. :-)
But in the meantime we will be financially ruined - sounds like a right laugh . This isn’t some “City will arise from the ruins” fairytale story - it’s the ruination of a successful football club . It all sounds like a good story - we get relegated and this club is finished as a proper competitive club. For the record - I’ve had my best days following this club around at lower league clubs - but that was the old City - not a club with a 60’000 capacity. So yeah , it’s sounds good , but we are Donald Ducked if we get properly sanctioned.
 
TueartsOHK makes a good point that I was thinking about. What Insurance company would provide cover for 18 clubs with a potential billion pound legal fight??. I assume it won't be 18 different companies. Surely we now hear about clubs policies being cancelled or not renewed??
If my home insurance goes up £50 next year because Direct Line had to fork out for Etihad’s £bn payout I’ll be very cross.
 
I see a couple of issues with the idea that Etihad and Etisalat will ride in to save the day…

1. I don’t see the PL waiting to punish us…they’re after blood, our blood. By the time any legal proceedings from the sponsors do anything worthwhile, we might already be out of business. What use is a sponsor win in the courts, if we’ve all been watching crown green bowls on Saturday afternoons?

2. If the big power play here, is that the above can’t/wont happen because the sponsors can destroy the PL, I honestly think we might be pissing in the wind. There is no way on gods earth the government of the time will let football in the country die. If Etihad/Etisalat were to win £billions in damages, the taxpayer would be paying it. The government might let individual clubs go to the wall but they sure as hell wouldn’t let football do the same. They would have overwhelming backing from all sides of the house and the general public. If the PL know they’re safe, I doubt there is anything stopping them from going nuclear on us.
Our government is in a very difficult position. I don't think it wants to see the PL clubs ruined financially but there is a group of MPs of all parties who are very worried about Cartel influence on the PL . The PL contributes billions every year to the economy and it certainly doesn't want this to end, but neither does it want to see City ruined so that the investment in Manchester comes to an end and an ally withdraws its investments in Britain and takes them elsewhere.

All this would suggest that a compromise settlement is brokered so that neither disaster comes about. This will not be easy since City refuse to accept ant guilt and the PL wishes to be seen to maintain its rules, but it seems the only way. I am biased but a statement that the appeal has led to a reconsideration of the evidence such that the sponsorship deals are no longer considered to be shams and that leaves only minor, inadvertent breaches. But would this satisfy both parties? Or would they slug it out to the ruin of both? What pressure can government apply?
 
When you look at what the club is building around the ground then I don't believe they are trying to wipe us out as some have suggested. There are a lot of jobs at stake and that wouldn't go down well. A club the size of City isn't going to wiped out just like that. The fact they want protection must mean they are not entirely 100% confident in their verdict. Now they have that cover in place they may want to come to the table with an offer of a get out. If we are truly 100% guilty then why haven't they dished out the punishment publicly? We could still appeal it. The punishment could still be placed on hold until after an appeal, it doesn't need to be kept secret. Also add in the secrecy around the appendencies and it all doesn't add up. Today they just covered their arses individually.
Where have you been for the past ten years? The PL leadership group is trying to destroy us. We were cleared by the highest sports arbitration court in the world but the PL decided to re-open the case. They investigated our accounts going back 18 years (something which has never been done before). They have issued biased and distorted press releases, leaked information to our commercial rivals, changed the rules to try and stop City. They ignored their own legal advice to introduce unlawful changes to tighten up those rules. Judges in a real court stated that they treated us unfairly. Masters won't even attend our stadium. Their contacts in the media have run a campaign against our club, slagging off our players, our fans, even trying to undermine the regeneration of Manchester itself. This is the most vicious witch hunt we have ever seen in the UK media. It has been driven by sheer hatred and racism.
 
Last edited:
My money is Liverpool if anyone.

We are responsible in their eyes for them not racking up a near on decade of domination.

Had we not been in the picture, they would have possibly won 5 or 6 league titles under Klopp, alongside numerous FA Cups and League Cups.

Also had we not been there taking them to the wire in gruelling 90+ point league campaigns, they may have had that extra bit in them to get over the line in a couple of the CL finals they lost.

Whilst I don't think we will ever have a period like we did under Pep in my lifetime, I don't think Liverpool will either.

Klopp gave them the best years they have had in 30 years and in my opinion won't be matched in the next 30 years either.
Back in the day , under Mancini , we went toe to toe with Spurs for CL qualification, this goes back further than our rivalry with Liverpool, they more or less always had CL qualification, Spurs hated us when we first got the money - they were the 5th club . And didn’t Pep name drop Levy when the charges first dropped in Feb 23 ? I’m sure someone can back Pep up specifically naming Levy ?
It was always United , Liverpool ,Chelsea back then trying to qualify for a CL place ? Bear in mind it was only 4 PL clubs back then that qualified for CL football.
So it was us with our money - Arsenal or a Spurs , , two became three - we pissed on there chips , we fucked them up , we invested - and like Spurs always have been - they think they’re a big club - we pissed on their chips.
 
Last edited:

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top