PL charge City for alleged breaches of financial rules

Did the other clubs get to see the full version of the charges officially or un officially or do they just see the same as us
The other clubs likely don't have access to the full judgments and appendices, but probably have more than what is in the public domain.

In many regulatory, disciplinary and legal processes there can be multiple levels of disclosure:

1. Parties to the case

  • Full unredacted judgment
  • Full appendices
  • Confidential evidence
  • Witness statements
  • Expert reports
2. Relevant stakeholders

  • More information than the public receives
  • May see less-redacted versions
  • Usually subject to confidentiality obligations
  • Often excluded from the most sensitive commercial or personal data
3. Wider membership/body (if applicable)

  • May receive summaries, briefing notes or selected extracts
  • Enough information to understand the outcome and implications
  • Not necessarily all underlying evidence
4. Public

  • Most heavily redacted version
  • Confidential business information removed
  • Personal data removed
  • Potentially entire sections or appendices withheld
 
The panel is supposed to be impartial so, in theory, should have examined evidence from both sides. If it is true that they didn't even consider City's evidence which led to us being cleared at CAS then it is a total disgrace. An absolute stain on the UK legal system. The idea that an anonymous panel of three people should accuse a global company of fraud without a proper investigation is ridiculous. How can it be an independent decision when the public don't even know who is on the panel?
IMO that’s exactly what has happened.
Everything I’ve read, Khaldoon’s words and the PL making sure they have legal protection tells me that’s the case.
What was the line the independent panel said?
Wasn’t it ‘if we’re wrong’
Doesn’t sound like they got evidence to dismiss our evidence or witnesses.
They’ve got an opinion.
An opinion that won’t hold up in a court of law.
Hence them shitting it about getting sued.
 
I agree certain clubs want us gone but I'm not so certain the PL do. A club the size of Manchester City with close to 150 years history isn't just going to be closed down or whatever. We are a bit of a juggernaut of a club these days, a behemoth and a global brand and whatever the social media world says the Premier League will not want to lose us. No league would I just don't believe that's what they want. I'm sure they want to fine us massively and put transfer bans on us and points reductions but I'll be surprised if they did enough to relegate us in one single season. They would be stupid to do something that severe and it would affect their own brand and income. They would leave enough wiggle room for us to stay up. And also the more severe they hit us the more severe the counter claim would be if we were to win in the high courts at a later date.
That's why I personally dont think well stop at x or y this will go all way now. I do worry if we were that stupid enough to filter money through ADUG and got caught but we'd of settled by now but I think Etihad funding will be minefield in early days trying to build the brand so money could come from anywhere then PL assumed it was for want they want to suit narrative and it yank playbook tie entities up in red tape. Yank run PL two cheeks interviewed masters they wanted super league they wanted operation big picture they want all to selves and everyone else doffing cap like villa and Newcastle

Ha ha forgot question
 
Our government is in a very difficult position. I don't think it wants to see the PL clubs ruined financially but there is a group of MPs of all parties who are very worried about Cartel influence on the PL . The PL contributes billions every year to the economy and it certainly doesn't want this to end, but neither does it want to see City ruined so that the investment in Manchester comes to an end and an ally withdraws its investments in Britain and takes them elsewhere.

All this would suggest that a compromise settlement is brokered so that neither disaster comes about. This will not be easy since City refuse to accept ant guilt and the PL wishes to be seen to maintain its rules, but it seems the only way. I am biased but a statement that the appeal has led to a reconsideration of the evidence such that the sponsorship deals are no longer considered to be shams and that leaves only minor, inadvertent breaches. But would this satisfy both parties? Or would they slug it out to the ruin of both? What pressure can government apply?
The appeal panel is appointed by Sir Gary Hickinbottom a former appeals court judge Behind the scenes I would expect the Attorney General to be having a quiet word with him to suggest his panel, which I think he will chair, finds a way to resolve the situation for the best of all concerned.
 
We are stuck in no mans land - we obviously, it seems , don’t have grounds off our own back with the appeal - this all depends on our sponsors going for the jugular for defamation or character and potential lack of confidence in their brand. Serious shite , and they will go for the PL in court - it’s the damage to our club on and off the pitch that’s the real worry - the club as a whole can’t put up with this for much longer.
 
Where have you been for the past ten years? The PL leadership group is trying to destroy us. We were cleared by the the highest sports arbitration court in the world but the PL decided to re-open the case. They investigated our accounts going back 18 years (something which has never been done before). They have issued biased and distorted press releases, leaked information to our commercial rivals, changed the rules to try and stop City. They ignored their own legal advice to introduce unlawful changes to tighten up those rules. Judges in a real court stated that they treated us unfairly. Masters won't even attend our stadium. Their contacts in the media have run a campaign against our club, slagging off our players, our fans, even trying to undermine the regeneration of Manchester itself. This is the most vicious witch hunt we have ever seen in the UK media. It has been driven by sheer hatred and racism.
Which is why I want them personally sued. OK, the PL will pick up the bill for the legal costs at least (if not damages), but I want them stained. I want them to have Defamation on their CVs. They have been openly hostile to us and tried to destroy the one thing that links many generations of our families. City is a rite of passage and these bastards are hell-bent on destroying it. I see it as almost akin to an attack on a family member.

This ends with one side being destroyed and it sure as hell won't be us. Sue as many people as possible. Get the sponsors to sue as many people as possible. Sue the organisation. Sue them all in as many jurisdictions as possible. Don't let up until they're sued out of existence. You come at the king, you best not miss. Show them what happens when they miss.
 
Which is why I want them personally sued. OK, the PL will pick up the bill for the legal costs at least (if not damages), but I want them stained. I want them to have Defamation on their CVs. They have been openly hostile to us and tried to destroy the one thing that links many generations of our families. City is a rite of passage and these bastards are hell-bent on destroying it. I see it as almost akin to an attack on a family member.

This ends with one side being destroyed and it sure as hell won't be us. Sue as many people as possible. Get the sponsors to sue as many people as possible. Sue the organisation. Sue them all in as many jurisdictions as possible. Don't let up until they're sued out of existence. You come at the king, you best not miss. Show them what happens when they miss.
IMG_0176.jpeg
 
A previous poster mentioned that the clubs would take out indemnity insurance rather than commit to an huge payout and I’m sure he’s correct. That leaves a couple of questions…

Which insurance company in the right mind would provide indemnity insurance for an organisation which is about to embark on two law suits with two large companies?

Couldn’t the board have taken out indemnity insurance ?

I would love to know how Masters sold this to them even if it is a perfectly regular requirement given the possibility of serious legal action.
Could be bluff like say who in right mind would insure them
Maybe Abu Dhabi firm then money come back to us lol
 
I agree certain clubs want us gone but I'm not so certain the PL do. A club the size of Manchester City with close to 150 years history isn't just going to be closed down or whatever. We are a bit of a juggernaut of a club these days, a behemoth and a global brand and whatever the social media world says the Premier League will not want to lose us. No league would I just don't believe that's what they want. I'm sure they want to fine us massively and put transfer bans on us and points reductions but I'll be surprised if they did enough to relegate us in one single season. They would be stupid to do something that severe and it would affect their own brand and income. They would leave enough wiggle room for us to stay up. And also the more severe they hit us the more severe the counter claim would be if we were to win in the high courts at a later date.
The PL want us gone because their US masters run the league. The PL could have respected the CAS decision in 2020 and protected the product back then.

Instead Masters, the cartel patsy, chose to pursue a vindictive case against City and hence the mess everyone is in now.

The PL have already damaged the brand. There's no turning back now.
 


A Manchester born Everton fan just posted this brilliant video about why the film Jimmy Grimble strangely became an Italian cult classic. It reminded me of why I became a Blue, & will follow City everywhere! Below is my response to the poster about his video. Chin up Blues, we've gone from Moss Side to Istanbul! Khaldoon & Co have got this!

"I really enjoyed that! It's crazy to think the film took off in Italy the way it did, but the way you explained how makes perfect sense.

After winning three Serie A titles on the bounce, Mancini was flirted by Inter in favour of Moureen, so I suppose most Italians were bemused by why Bobby Manc came to City, when most had probably only ever heard of ManUre.

Berlusconi probably saw an opportunity to capitalise on Mancini's move, & brilliantly captured the essence of City’s fairytale transformation from hapless, loveable losers, to becoming the most dominant team on the planet.

With crazy Mario Balotelli being here too, he will have added to the intrigue, & I suppose the historic "Agueroooooooooooo" moment with an assist from Mario, & Bobby Manc being swamped on the sidelines on 93:20, rounded off the fairytale.

City’s journey from the 3rd division in 1999 to becoming Premier League Champions in 2012 by beating their closest rivals on goal difference, with a last minute goal, is the stuff Hollywood rags to riches blockbusters are made of.

With all that's happening to Manchester City Football Club at the moment, Jimmy Grimble is a timely reminder of who we are, & where we come from.

Well done mate, & thanks for sharing your video! :-)"
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top