Search results

Guimaraes, many times. Ederson very little. Reijners 1 or 2. I'd take him over the former 2.

Yes, more like maybe. But yes.

No

Get him

We need a RB, CB, CM, DM, Striker and Winger before LB. . 6 players over 2 windows. So 3 in January and 4 (including a keeper in Summer). I'd say the 3 be a RB, DM and CM.... RB Vanderson, CM Alex Baena and DM Samuele Ricci. Summer add CB Silva, CM Baena, AM/ WF/ ST Rodrygo

Both need to go. Both past 30 and have never been too healthy even in their youth. They can't be counted on at this level. Get Antonio Silva and a Leftback to replace both

Should have left last summer. But will definitely leave after the season. Greatest ever player at City. But his time as a consistent top player has come to an end.

I love Jack. But the club should be in a ruthless mode. And Jack won't make that cut if they are.

That's the cost of bad planning. We are in relegation form right now. Not midtable form - Relegation! The first fix can't wait. Health at CB may shore up the left ( maybe as Ake and John are brittle as fuck) but the RB position needs saving, desperately. There are options. Pick one that's the...

No

There are replacements available. We just need to be brave enough to go get one.

Fair enough. He is probably young enough. I just have a feeling about him. He has all the attributes of a 'plug the hole' buy that would turn out to be disappointing. Shades of Garcia or the Octopus. Someone we wanted a year before but should have moved on from when it didn't happen but didn't...

My mistake, I expect the rebuild to be complete come next summer. By 4-5 years, I meant a rebuilt to make a run the next 4 to 5 years. That means a core of Dias, Rodri, Haaland, Foden , Bobb. Plus the new additions will all be in their relative primes for the next 4-5 years. So between 21-26 is...

A no for me. Short-term and short-sighted. Plan for the long-term.

When the end is coming, id rather prepare rather than pretend and hope.. I don't think Pep is the future. I sense he might even leave at the end of the season anyway. So gets 2 to 3 players in January and try to make a fight of the season and the cups ( whichever is remaining come January and...

- Should Pep be in charge of the rebuild?. Long-term? No 2 - Which players should be moved on in 2025? WALKER, GUNDO, KEVIN, BERNARDO, STONES AND AKE, 3 - Which players should be offered new contracts? HAALAND, DIAS, FODEN, RODRI, AND BOBB 3b - What players should we be targeting? RB...

Or better, find a better #1 and keep Ortega at 2.

Agree on Wirtz and Musialla. Disagree on Simons. He strikes me as the kind of player who's talents would be greatly minimized by our style.

Again, this is bad faith. Reading my response in a vacuum. I responded to a post that said, I'd rather have Mahrez now. My response is pointing out that Mahrez like Gundo and many of the aging players people pine for after they are gone, are often past it and it's a mistake to want them back...

Pep is here 2 years tops. I'd rather he just tries to win and play best ball according to his philosophy. And let whoever the new manager is in a few years build his own team.