Search results

It's certainly "better" (quicker) but what's the margin of error? If we don't know that then how do we know that it's ok to use?

You basically don’t need a VAR room at all if you treat VAR as tool to help refs make better decisions. You just need tech guys to cue up footage and the ref can then view it. I’d put a 1 minute clock on those on the basis that if you can’t decide it in a minute your original decision is likely...

Surely you’re not suggesting that a former referee may have been suspect from an integrity perspective………? :-)

Again I sort of agree but end up disagreeing. The chagrin with poor VAR decisions is that with tech available, which refs don’t, they STILL get it wrong The other killer for me is that there are actually sensible things to be done to improve things but there is no interest whatsoever in doing so

This is in dispute. PIGMOL say not https://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/football/article-13336567/amp/PGMOL-Howard-Webb-Nottingham-Forests-Stuart-Attwell-VAR.html

Apologies correct.

Fair to an extent but the omnishambles of VAR (how many apologies this year) is testing everyone’s patience. At what point do you take the gloves off?

As ever with everything VAR the rules they apply are nonsensical. Regardless of whether you agree with the partisan support rules with referees you would surely concede that if it applies to the ref it should apply to the VAR? We shall see what the outcome of it is. If it’s “how dare you...

The fact a Luton fan wouldn’t be allowed to ref the game but can VAR and the fact that at least 2 blatant penalties weren’t given

So you aren’t concerned with the substance of what they’ve said just the way they did it? Why shouldn’t they say it publicly? It’s not good form?

And how do you prove things? Gather evidence and investigate. In both semi finals the integrity of the officiating has been publicly called into question. In any other industry you’d investigate. In football it’s “nothing to see here”. Why?

Presumably an investigation into whether club allegiance for VAR officials should follow on field official rules might be achievable? In addition, an investigation into the competence of Atwell would also be a possibility and given his track record wouldn’t be pretty for him. In any other arena...

All great questions that you’ll never find the answers to

This is exactly how I feel. Well put mate

Circle those wagons!

The integrity of the officials in both semis has been publicly questioned now. Will PiGMoL and the FA investigate ?

For VAR to improve those using it would need to accept that it needs improving. Not gonna happen

My favourite moment was when he pretended he was spark out face down on the floor not moving. 2 minute stoppage lots of worried looks. Then straight up playing again. Absolute clown

Im disappointed

It’s actually a fair point. It would be worth him trying to focus on the ball, just the ball, as the taker approaches. You get half a second to see the foot position so you know which way it’s going and can dive there every time. You won’t save the good ones but if you go the right way every...