Album/Band battle No 1 Stone Roses vs, Definitely Maybe

[Shaggy]

Going to have a battle of Albums/Bands, just for fun and to gauge opinion.

First up

Stone Roses, Stone Roses vs. Oasis, Definitely Maybe.

Which was the better debut album ?

 

[ifiwasarichfan]

Easy one to start with. I loved Oasis, but the Roses.

 

[BimboBob]

Oasis.

Was all downhill after that.


Never got the Roses.

 

[Shaggy]

1 a piece straight away, keep em coming blues

 

[Stockton Heath Blue]

Stone Roses by a midge's dick. such a good time for music in Manchester at this time.

 

[BlueBearBoots]

Oasis.

Was all downhill after that.


Never got the Roses.

agree

 

[RP2]

Oasis definitely.

 

[shakermaker85]

2 fave albums ever! So a tough one.

Deffo maybe shades it for me. Purely for the fact there's not a below par track on it and I was young enough to get into it at the time. But I'd say the Roses flows better as a complete album. GOD!. this is like choosing between Chips and Ale.

The better argument would be between the Drug fulled overblown failures - Second coming V Be here now

 

[m32blue]

Stoneroses all day long
I really liked both Bands but Oasis were too much of a Beatles rip off in my opinion

 

[everythingchangesbutblue]

Dm imo, Roses are for me one of the most overrated bands ever.