Carlos Tevez

[pudge]

The world class argument.....

Would he regularly start for Barca,Real or Bayern?

Ah yes, the only teams that have world class players

 

[Vincents Tackle]

The world class argument.....

Would he regularly start for Barca,Real or Bayern?

He won't regularly start for us if we sign Cavani and Isco

 

[FantasyIreland]

The world class argument.....

Would he regularly start for Barca,Real or Bayern?

Ah yes, the only teams that have world class players

You haven't answered?

 

[pudge]

The world class argument.....

Would he regularly start for Barca,Real or Bayern?

Ah yes, the only teams that have world class players

You haven't answered?

For Real, I'd say yes. Benzema, Higuain or Tevez? He'd get a fair few games imo

He's better than Gomez, who's just left though I believe, and Mandzukic for Bayern imo so on that basis...

But those 3 teams don't determine a world class player, so your initial point is void really.

You yourself have said in the past that Tevez is world class, so I don't really understand your point.

 

[daxman]

He is world class, can't take you seriously if you think otherwise

He WAS world class. Nothing in the last 2 years suggests he's still in the World Class category.

Torres was once World Class too. He isn't anymore. ANd while Tevez is miles ahead of Torres, he isn't World Class anymore either. Sell if you can. Open up a spot for a current or future WC player.

 

[kun]

I don't think he is world class.
I reckon we have 3/4 players in that catagory: Yaya, Kompany and Silva with Aguero hovering there or there abouts

 

[daxman]

I don't think he is world class.
I reckon we have 3/4 players in that catagory: Yaya, Kompany and Silva with Aguero hovering there or there abouts

Yup! This I agree with.

 

[pudge]

I don't think he is world class.
I reckon we have 3/4 players in that catagory: Yaya, Kompany and Silva with Aguero hovering there or there abouts

WORLD CLASS STRIKER?!?!
What do you call Tevez
he is definately the closest were gonna get

At some point he was "hovering there and there abouts" for you.

Form is temporary, class is permanent. And more often than not as he has proved in his career with us, Tevez is world class.

 

[Ray78]

He still can do a useful job, however the fact his agent is talking to clubs means that we have given him permission and the sale looks imminent.

 

[kun]

I don't think he is world class.
I reckon we have 3/4 players in that catagory: Yaya, Kompany and Silva with Aguero hovering there or there abouts

WORLD CLASS STRIKER?!?!
What do you call Tevez
he is definately the closest were gonna get

At some point he was "hovering there and there abouts" for you.

Form is temporary, class is permanent. And more often than not as he has proved in his career with us, Tevez is world class.

When did I say that haha

also, Torres was class

 

[pudge]

With regards to Torres, why do the last 2 seasons hold more weight that his many previous good/great seasons?

Are we to think his current level is his future level? He was undoubtedly one of the best in the world when at Liverpool, as much as it may look like it has, that doesn't just go away.

Tevez under performed this season, as did our other 2 strikers, but his seasons of 29 and 23 goals, as well as his carrying of the team when he arrived must not be forgotten.

If people can't forget about Munich, then they shouldn't seemingly forget about the quality he has delivered on the pitch since he came here

 

[jauganaut]

Can't sell Tevez, he is the one player you can trust to pull a hat out of a rabbit's crack when the going gets tough in a match.
Before we sell him, if we must, we have to buy a replacement and give them a season to bed in.
Without Tevez we wouldnt have finished 2nd last season.

 

[zeven]

Can't sell Tevez, he is the one player you can trust to pull a hat out of a rabbit's crack when the going gets tough in a match.
Before we sell him, if we must, we have to buy a replacement and give them a season to bed in.
Without Tevez we wouldnt have finished 2nd last season.

We cant let him walk for free next year either can we? He will not extend his contract so we better sell him and bring in Cavani as a replacement.

No one wants to sell him but its not up to us anymore. City is still a business something we have to remember.

 

[chris63]

Agree with the above :)

 

[dzeko01]

yaya is far from being world class, he's on decline, but he;s still a key player for city. silva/nasrii underperformed as well. Tevez just want to leave, and this is his last chance to leave in good terms with city, its up to the club owners now, i dont think he's going to juventus. and i hope Dzeko leaves too, i have a feeling Pellegrini would keep him on the bench...just a feeling....

 

[Mr. Aguia]

With regards to Torres, why do the last 2 seasons hold more weight that his many previous good/great seasons?

Are we to think his current level is his future level? He was undoubtedly one of the best in the world when at Liverpool, as much as it may look like it has, that doesn't just go away.

Tevez under performed this season, as did our other 2 strikers, but his seasons of 29 and 23 goals, as well as his carrying of the team when he arrived must not be forgotten.

If people can't forget about Munich, then they shouldn't seemingly forget about the quality he has delivered on the pitch since he came here

In that case maybe we should sign Kenny Douglish. When a player reaches a certain age that's exactly what happens, it goes away and it don't come back. Otherwise players would be elite until they were 40.

 

[jauganaut]

Can't sell Tevez, he is the one player you can trust to pull a hat out of a rabbit's crack when the going gets tough in a match.
Before we sell him, if we must, we have to buy a replacement and give them a season to bed in.
Without Tevez we wouldnt have finished 2nd last season.

We cant let him walk for free next year either can we? He will not extend his contract so we better sell him and bring in Cavani as a replacement.

No one wants to sell him but its not up to us anymore. City is still a business something we have to remember.

So let me guess. You're Tevez. No you're he's agent? How about Txiki, did I guess right?
If you happen to be none of those, then tell me how you know Tevez won't extend his contract.
Or better yet, tell me why Carlos Tevez won't extend his mega-money contract with Manchester city but is willing to take a pay cut to go to Juventus.
That doesn't even make any sense.
Perhaps its more believable that the club havent yet or are unwilling to offer him a new contract. In which case, i believe that it is out of his hands. Am I making too much sense?

 

[Lomas has a lob on]

yaya is far from being world class, he's on decline, but he;s still a key player for city. silva/nasrii underperformed as well. Tevez just want to leave, and this is his last chance to leave in good terms with city, its up to the club owners now, i dont think he's going to juventus. and i hope Dzeko leaves too, i have a feeling Pellegrini would keep him on the bench...just a feeling....

I think its a bit early to say Yaya is now in decline.

He had a poor season by his standards last season, I'll admit, and if he repeats that form again next season I'll admit he is in decline, but lets just see how he performs next season first.

After all the club gave him a new deal just a few months ago, a pretty stupid thing to do if he is in decline.

 

[AustinBlue]

yaya is far from being world class,

Anything written after this phrase gets automatically discounted to worthless

 

[dzeko01]

yaya is far from being world class,

Anything written after this phrase gets automatically discounted to worthless

well its just my opinion. i respect yours. he isnt getting any younger, and he isnt world class anymore.