Charlie McNeil

[Centurions]

I'm probably misunderstanding this, but what's so bad about telling a 16 year old that u18s is a max? Surely when he reaches 17/18 then he can think about having even a 5% chance of first team football?

I think you misunderstand, Spider is saying that he's been told that City believe he won't progress beyond the U18s full stop with us.

Unless of course it's me misunderstanding ;)

 

[Mayor West]

I think you misunderstand, Spider is saying that he's been told that City believe he won't progress beyond the U18s full stop with us.

Unless of course it's me misunderstanding ;)

Ah ok, if that is the case then yeah you've got to think to yourself whats the point in staying?

 

[SPIDERBOY]

I'm probably misunderstanding this, but what's so bad about telling a 16 year old that u18s is a max? Surely when he reaches 17/18 then he can think about having even a 5% chance of first team football?

Just my opinion mate...just think it would be better with certain kids to say nothing and see how they develop.
As i posted earlier he had a lot of very good offers.....some from clubs bigger than where he is going......people from home and abroad see summat in him.

 

[Mayor West]

Just my opinion mate...just think it would be better with certain kids to say nothing and see how they develop.
As i posted earlier he had a lot of very good offers.....some from clubs bigger than where he is going......people from home and abroad see summat in him.

So was he told he had no future with us full stop after u18s as centurions thought?

 

[Centurions]

Just my opinion mate...just think it would be better with certain kids to say nothing and see how they develop.
As i posted earlier he had a lot of very good offers.....some from clubs bigger than where he is going......people from home and abroad see summat in him.

Well if it's true he's going to the rags then at least he can use them as a stepping stone until a bigger club comes along.

 

[eastmanc]

He officially left 6-7 weeks ago. Looked like he was going to RB Leipzig, but have been quiet on that front for long now. He was a rag even when he was playing here, so I would not be surprised if he joined the rags

I spoke to his Dad about three weeks ago and he hadn’t left then. He also told me that he wouldn’t be going abroad and that the RB Leipzig stuff was nonsense. He said that if he was to move he had had offers from teams in the Premier league but he didn’t mention United.

 

[SPIDERBOY]

Well if it's true he's going to the rags then at least he can use them as a stepping stone until a bigger club comes along.

He's been there before,they got him off the dippers and we got him off them.

 

[SPIDERBOY]

I spoke to his Dad about three weeks ago and he hadn’t left then. He also told me that he wouldn’t be going abroad and that the RB Leipzig stuff was nonsense. He said that if he was to move he had had offers from teams in the Premier league but he didn’t mention United.

Never mentioned them to me either to be honest.
Just said they were sitting down as a family and gonna decide whats best for Charlie.

 

[eastmanc]

he was told he wont go beyond the U18s...........i would say he is more than capable of going further.
he decided to try his luck elsewhere,you cant blame him for that.
personally,imo.....you dont tell a 16 year old kid that,esspecially one who has bagged 600 plus goals,many of them above his age group.
i'd sooner of kept him and seen how he developed.

That doesn’t seem fair how do City know he won’t improve.

 

[eastmanc]

Never mentioned them to me either to be honest.
Just said they were sitting down as a family and gonna decide whats best for Charlie.

That is more or less what he said to me.