For the Maine Daily Mail haters

MadchesterCity

Well-Known Member
Joined
12 Sep 2009
Messages
18,265
The stadium was unofficially rated as one of the most atmospheric stadiums in world football in 2008 by the Daily Mail who commented that “Maine Road will always be one of English football’s legendary grounds”.

http://mcivta.com/maine-road/

The link above is a good read about the history of Maine Road
 
Even more evidence that the issue they have is more about them seeing our current owners as a threat, or at least this is the selling mechanism they use for their main audience (rags)
 
Brilliant read, thanks mate.

I won't deny it brought a lump to my throat reading about it and seeing those old images of Maine Road. I loved the place, but I'm somewhat of a contemporist, so whilst Maine Road was special to me, I was eager for us to move on to a new stadium and progress onwards and upwards.

Ultimately the move was probably the best thing that's ever happened to us as I doubt we'd have been half as attractive as a takeover proposition to Sheikh Mansour if we'd remained in Moss Side.

Looking at our stadium now and knowing there are plans to extend it further, not to mention that fantastic bridge linking us to the CFA, I couldn't be happier about our future. I'm just glad I've lived long enough to witness it because I never ever thought I'd see anything like this happen to City in my lifetime.

Even though we were 'Typical City', I knew we'd rise to the top again at some point in the future just by the law of averages, but I always reckoned I'd be long gone when this happened and our future fans would be turning up to games using flying cars like The Jetsons! :-)
 
Nostalgia isn't what it used to be.
Let's be brutally honest Maine Road was a dump.
What we have now is far, far better.
 
Brilliant read, thanks mate.

I won't deny it brought a lump to my throat reading about it and seeing those old images of Maine Road. I loved the place, but I'm somewhat of a contemporist, so whilst Maine Road was special to me, I was eager for us to move on to a new stadium and progress onwards and upwards.

Ultimately the move was probably the best thing that's ever happened to us as I doubt we'd have been half as attractive as a takeover proposition to Sheikh Mansour if we'd remained in Moss Side.

Looking at our stadium now and knowing there are plans to extend it further, not to mention that fantastic bridge linking us to the CFA, I couldn't be happier about our future. I'm just glad I've lived long enough to witness it because I never ever thought I'd see anything like this happen to City in my lifetime.

Even though we were 'Typical City', I knew we'd rise to the top again at some point in the future just by the law of averages, but I always reckoned I'd be long gone when this happened and our future fans would be turning up to games using flying cars like The Jetsons! :-)
Agree with all of that apart from the last bit. I'd pretty much abandoned hope of us dining at the top table again. I thought the barriers to entry were too great. It just goes to show you how nothing in this world should ever be taken for granted. Something frequently intervenes to move the pieces on the board in a game changing way.
 
with a very special place in many people's memories .

Mine included. I loved the place, though preferred the standing Kippax. Many happy, and not so happy memories from there. But nostalgia apart the club has moved light years, it is just a shame that we have not been able to take the (especially standing) atmosphere with us.
 
Agree with all of that apart from the last bit. I'd pretty much abandoned hope of us dining at the top table again. I thought the barriers to entry were too great. It just goes to show you how nothing in this world should ever be taken for granted. Something frequently intervenes to move the pieces on the board in a game changing way.
And the last bit of your post perfectly sums up my mantra for life, mainly that nothing remains the same for ever and that life is cyclical.

For the last 20 years, every Rag who knew me and even some who didn't would make a beeline for me whenever we'd lost (especially to them) or we suffered more misfortune like relegation or losing the odd good player we had (SWP, Anelka spring to mind). But I remained stiff in my resolve that one day, the natural order of things would be restored and the day would come that we'd finish ahead of them in the league and actually win the damn thing again!

They all though I was a fuckin fruit loop as I used to sit there with a straight face calmly telling them all that City would return to our position of prominence over them and I'd also live to see the day that ManUre were reduced to playing Sunday League football on Hough End playing fields with one man and his dog watching the bastards.

As you may have guessed, I have a pathological hatred for them but bit by bit my hopes and dreams are turning into reality. The significance of our 2012 title win passes most people by, because we could have gone on to win 10 titles in a row, but it would have never carried any weight with those bastards because we'd have always had 'yes but you couldn't do it when Ferguson was manager'. Seeing his crumpled face at the end of that match will live with me forever and is only second to seeing Kun wheeling away after scoring that dramatic late winner.

Now all they have left is, the size of Old Toilet stadium, number of league title wins, number of CL wins, us never having won the CL, their bigger financial turnover and my personal favourite the empty seats at our place. Bit by bit we're happily burbling along ticking off the boxes as we reach our milestones as they continue to count our empty seats. The law of averages always dictated there was a possibility this could happen, I'm just astounded its come in such a stunning fashion and happened so quickly.

Our rise may not have been organic, but a lottery win is a lottery win and however you've come by your good fortune it all comes down to the same thing, to be successful you need money, which makes even more money, which brings even more success, rinse and repeat. All we have to do is cast a glance at our illustrious neighbours, Real, Barca and Bayern to see this is the case. But lest we forget that nothing lasts forever, all we have to do is look at the 2 Milan giants and Ajax.
 
Please. An Atmospheric Dump ; )
Occasionally it was a good atmospheric dump I grant you. For example:
Newcastle (H) - Colin Bell Return.
Everton (H) - FA Cup QF.
Charlton (H) - 5-0 Promotion Party.
Utd (H) 3-1 - The Goater/Neville show.
Most of the time though it could be as poor as anything folks on here complain about the Etihad. Consider the defeat to Charlton the week after the Goater/Neville show...

For example Utd home (2011-12) & QPR Home (2011-12) were excellent at the new place,
Nah nah,
Nah na na nah.
Nah na na nah,
City!
 
Occasionally it was a good atmospheric dump I grant you. For example:
Newcastle (H) - Colin Bell Return.
Everton (H) - FA Cup QF.
Charlton (H) - 5-0 Promotion Party.
Utd (H) 3-1 - The Goater/Neville show.
Most of the time though it could be as poor as anything folks on here complain about the Etihad. Consider the defeat to Charlton the week after the Goater/Neville show...

For example Utd home (2011-12) & QPR Home (2011-12) were excellent at the new place,
Nah nah,
Nah na na nah.
Nah na na nah,
City!

Maybe its me, maybe I had more energy back in the eighties, but I remember the noise the Kippax made especially before kick off every game. Walking down that passage that went down the side of the ground listening to the chants back and forth. Especially United, Leeds, Liverpool, Everton. The atmosphere was even better for night matches. Or maybe I can only remember the good, it never rained in the eighties you know !
 
And the last bit of your post perfectly sums up my mantra for life, mainly that nothing remains the same for ever and that life is cyclical.

For the last 20 years, every Rag who knew me and even some who didn't would make a beeline for me whenever we'd lost (especially to them) or we suffered more misfortune like relegation or losing the odd good player we had (SWP, Anelka spring to mind). But I remained stiff in my resolve that one day, the natural order of things would be restored and the day would come that we'd finish ahead of them in the league and actually win the damn thing again!

They all though I was a fuckin fruit loop as I used to sit there with a straight face calmly telling them all that City would return to our position of prominence over them and I'd also live to see the day that ManUre were reduced to playing Sunday League football on Hough End playing fields with one man and his dog watching the bastards.

As you may have guessed, I have a pathological hatred for them but bit by bit my hopes and dreams are turning into reality. The significance of our 2012 title win passes most people by, because we could have gone on to win 10 titles in a row, but it would have never carried any weight with those bastards because we'd have always had 'yes but you couldn't do it when Ferguson was manager'. Seeing his crumpled face at the end of that match will live with me forever and is only second to seeing Kun wheeling away after scoring that dramatic late winner.

Now all they have left is, the size of Old Toilet stadium, number of league title wins, number of CL wins, us never having won the CL, their bigger financial turnover and my personal favourite the empty seats at our place. Bit by bit we're happily burbling along ticking off the boxes as we reach our milestones as they continue to count our empty seats. The law of averages always dictated there was a possibility this could happen, I'm just astounded its come in such a stunning fashion and happened so quickly.

Our rise may not have been organic, but a lottery win is a lottery win and however you've come by your good fortune it all comes down to the same thing, to be successful you need money, which makes even more money, which brings even more success, rinse and repeat. All we have to do is cast a glance at our illustrious neighbours, Real, Barca and Bayern to see this is the case. But lest we forget that nothing lasts forever, all we have to do is look at the 2 Milan giants and Ajax.
I think there have been two, district primary forces at play in terms of City and united's realignment in recent years.

Firstly relates to City. Certainly there were several factors that conspired to make us the vehicle that Sheikh Mansour chose for his project, but many of those could be said to be as a result of happenstance: the Stadium, our share structure, Dickov's goal. We were, as you say, lottery winners to all intents and purposes.

The second factor, however, has been brought about by united upon themselves. Notwithstanding our rise, they could have maintained a presence around the top of the table these last few years, but they became so bloated and pumped up on their own self-importance that they took their eye off the ball in an astonishingly negligent way. I believe there are fault lines running through that club that will take significant time, resources and guile to correct. One only has to look at their return on player acquisitions and the recent performances of their younger youth teams to see that. Further, their ground, at the forefront of European stadiums a decade ago, is now looking dated and a little down at heel. There is a (beautiful) air of decay around the club.

It would be foolish to write them off, for the same reasons it was foolish of me to assume we could never get back. We live in a universe of infinite chaos and unexpected things can happen, but they've got a monumental task to catch us up imo.

I just hope we never fall into the same trap of arrogant complacency that has left them floundering in our wake.
 
Nostalgia isn't what it used to be.
Let's be brutally honest Maine Road was a dump.
What we have now is far, far better.
Bang on. It was a shit hole. Our ground now is better in every single way.
 
I think there have been two, district primary forces at play in terms of City and united's realignment in recent years.

Firstly relates to City. Certainly there were several factors that conspired to make us the vehicle that Sheikh Mansour chose for his project, but many of those could be said to be as a result of happenstance: the Stadium, our share structure, Dickov's goal. We were, as you say, lottery winners to all intents and purposes.

The second factor, however, has been brought about by united upon themselves. Notwithstanding our rise, they could have maintained a presence around the top of the table these last few years, but they became so bloated and pumped up on their own self-importance that they took their eye off the ball in an astonishingly negligent way. I believe there are fault lines running through that club that will take significant time, resources and guile to correct. One only has to look at their return on player acquisitions and the recent performances of their younger youth teams to see that. Further, their ground, at the forefront of European stadiums a decade ago, is now looking dated and a little down at heel. There is a (beautiful) air of decay around the club.

It would be foolish to write them off, for the same reasons it was foolish of me to assume we could never get back. We live in a universe of infinite chaos and unexpected things can happen, but they've got a monumental task to catch us up imo.

I just hope we never fall into the same trap of arrogant complacency that has left them floundering in our wake.
Agreed!

And your final sentence is my biggest fear too. I just hope we as fans never forget our darkest days nor our out of the blue good fortune. I also hope we fully appreciate the lottery win we've been afforded and that we never turn into the arrogant, self entitled fans we so came to hate and detest.

As you say ManUre are complicit in their own downturn, but that is their issue to resolve. I'll never write them off because they are more than big enough to return to dominance very quickly, but as you say it is going to take a monumental effort and will need a team of savvy operators to achieve this for them.

The football landscape is changing. Traditionally lower ranked PL teams are now beginning to compete with the traditional big boys because of the money now available. Teams like Everton can tell Chelsea to fuck off if they come calling for one of their stars or like us with Liverpool and Sterling they can make us pay close to what they want.

Tottenham have the potential to become the biggest team in London and replace Chelsea in the London pecking order. With serious outside investment, West Ham could be in the shake up too, whilst 2 Northern powerhouses (Liverpool and Everton) could slip down the PL pecking order behind the London shandy drinkers because of a lack of investment in their infrastructure going back over many years.

Liverpool have plans to extend Anfield's capacity to 55000, but Rodgers has already said that their owners plan is to buy potential, build it up and sell it on at a profit which isn't exactly a plan if you intend to return to the summit of English football any time soon. I'm just fucking glad, we made it across the drawbridge before the bridge was raised, because outside of Arsenal, there's an uncertain future on the horizon for many of the traditional powerhouses of English football.
 
Occasionally it was a good atmospheric dump I grant you. For example:
Newcastle (H) - Colin Bell Return.
Everton (H) - FA Cup QF.
Charlton (H) - 5-0 Promotion Party.
Utd (H) 3-1 - The Goater/Neville show.
Most of the time though it could be as poor as anything folks on here complain about the Etihad. Consider the defeat to Charlton the week after the Goater/Neville show...

For example Utd home (2011-12) & QPR Home (2011-12) were excellent at the new place,
Nah nah,
Nah na na nah.
Nah na na nah,
City!

Precisely it reeked in the end of the Swales era and although Lee had bigs plans to develop it, of which I still have a copy of the plans, it would never have got to be anywhere near as good as the Etihad is so I say happy memories but they are more distant than the bad ones. As to the atmosphere yes at times it was great but at lots of times flat and no where as good as the nostalgia recalls.
 
May of been a dump but it holds loads of fond memories. I Even put my grandadds ashes was on the pitch will never forget that moment.
 
And your final sentence is my biggest fear too. I just hope we as fans never forget our darkest days nor our out of the blue good fortune. I also hope we fully appreciate the lottery win we've been afforded and that we never turn into the arrogant, self entitled fans we so came to hate and detest.
Alarm bells should start ringing when we start pontificating about 'the City way'!
 
May of been a dump but it holds loads of fond memories. I Even put my grandadds ashes was on the pitch will never forget that moment.
Definitely lots of fond memories from Maine Road, but as the years proceed at the Etihad, fond memories come in to replace them.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top