Grappling at corners - my solutions

[Dave Ewing's Back 'eader]

Just need to change the rules to allow players to be booked for a foul when the ball isn't in play.

I think this can be done now. Yer can send players off after the game has finished, or even before, and wasn't Pique sent off from the bench in his last game for Barca. It should be commonly understood that grappling prior to a corner is a bookable defence. Personally, had I been in charge of the whistle on Sunday I'd have told the player to take the corner and then give the penalty - no lectures, no warning, no in-game instruction to players who might, just might, be in total ignorance of the law that doesn't permit a move more common in WWF.

 

[ctwrd]

If the defender is clever he will stop the grappling just before the corner is taken and then he can’t give a foul.

If corner taker doesn’t mess about and kick it and the linesman doesn’t stand in front of the ball to see if they have nicked a millimetre then it won’t start

 

[Stephen230]

If corner taker doesn’t mess about and kick it and the linesman doesn’t stand in front of the ball to see if they have nicked a millimetre then it won’t start

Dunno, City’s new thing seems to be, wait until everyone’s in position. Go through the full range of signals like a baseball catcher. Pick the ball up. Bounce it a few times. One last signal, this time for real. Then kick the fucker to the exact same place as they do with all the other signals.

 

[Hart of the Matter]

But.., but.... But.. bluehammer said VAR would sort all this skull duggery...

 

[The Stockport Iniesta]

Dunno, City’s new thing seems to be, wait until everyone’s in position. Go through the full range of signals like a baseball catcher. Pick the ball up. Bounce it a few times. One last signal, this time for real. Then kick the fucker to the exact same place as they do with all the other signals.

Our corners aren't the best are they.

As for grappling at corners, there's a simple solution, any shirt pulling, dragging anyone to the floor, It's either a pen or a free kick to the defending team. Also give a yellow to any nonce throwing themself to the floor without contact, job done.

The only drawback to this is the rags and dippers getting 10 extra pens a season, while opposition teams have 3 or 4 goals ruled out.

So forget my simple solution.

 

[KS55]

Simple solution: introduce a rule that says at corners and free kicks the ball is in play once it has been put in place. If the side in possession try to replace the ball, the kick is reversed.
Some time wasting would be eliminated too.

 

[Johnny Mars Bar]

Didn’t they announce a big ‘clamp down’ on this a few years ago then swiftly forgot about it after about two games?

 

[OccupiedPalestineBlues]

Just need to change the rules to allow players to be booked for a foul when the ball isn't in play.

That surprises me because I’m sure that I’ve seen touchline staff booked for causing a hoo har when the ball’s not in play, and also seen players booked for kicking the ball away before a free kick’s been taken / ball still out of play.
Was it a recent tule change or something?

 

[Trevor Morley's Tache]

You can be sent off after a game so not sure if this isn’t already possible? Plus keepers can get booked for shenanigans during penalties etc

Well, if you can be awarded a penalty after the final whistle...

 

[Bentheblue]

Semedo was given an obvious warning from the ref that he'd done it twice now, a third one would end up in a yellow. I can't see any need to make it more complicated, I have enough problems understanding the offside rule right now.

So do refs and VAR.

 

[Bentheblue]

Didn’t they announce a big ‘clamp down’ on this a few years ago then swiftly forgot about it after about two games?

Yeah, I seem to remember we gave away a pen as a result of this clampdown, away game at Stoke I think.

 

[jamesha]

Well, if you can be awarded a penalty after the final whistle...

If you play in red

 

[plattlanebenches]

Should leave them to it and have a sort of royal rumble for every corner.

 

[Gorton_Tubster]

sin bin is the way forward. Imagine Pep or Klopp if one of their players has to sit out for ten minutes? It would stop immediately.

 

[Blue Maverick]

Another thing they should bring in is if you get a head injury and the trainer comes on, you go off for a minimum of 10 mins, you can bring a sub on to take their place and they can come back on then. Let’s see how any go down holding their head needlessly and have to go off, when clearly they are feigning it to waste time.

 

[Stephen230]

Another thing they should bring in is if you get a head injury and the trainer comes on, you go off for a minimum of 10 mins, you can bring a sub on to take their place and they can come back on then. Let’s see how any go down holding their head needlessly and have to go off, when clearly they are feigning it to waste time.

What about when they aren’t feigning it? Seems a bit harsh having to sit out 10 minutes because someone has whacked you on the head.

 

[sir baconface]

Just need to change the rules to allow players to be booked for a foul when the ball isn't in play.

If they can’t be penalised when the ball’s not in play, the remedy is simple...

Chin the fcuker.

 

[Hayley Croppers chopper]

You can be sent off after a game so not sure if this isn’t already possible? Plus keepers can get booked for shenanigans during penalties etc

You can be awarded a penalty after the game and everyone has fucked off home if you are united.

 

[Hayley Croppers chopper]

Didn’t they announce a big ‘clamp down’ on this a few years ago then swiftly forgot about it after about two games?

England got to a world cup semi final based on this tactic.

 

[Blue Maverick]

What about when they aren’t feigning it? Seems a bit harsh having to sit out 10 minutes because someone has whacked you on the head.

Concussion monitoring mate, it’s done in American football as well, the actual clashing of heads is usually very low, but you see the tossers ours included btw that roll around like they’ve been clubbed over the head. The team doesn’t lose out as they get a concussion sub, but let’s see how many get straight back up.