Harry Maguire

[waspish]

Well things will start ramping up this week I guess. When are city back for pre season training?

Nahh middle of next week I reckon.

 

[DMA's]

So if we sign Riesgo (Free), Maguire (£65m), Cancelo (£50m), Rodri (£65m), and Angelino (£6m), selling Muric (£5m), Delph (£10m) and Danilo (£25m) in the process, our squad will be... what?

Ederson, Bravo, Riesgo

Walker, Cancelo
Stones, Laporte, Otamendi, Maguire
Zinchenko, Mendy, Angelino

Rodri, Fernandinho
De Bruyne, Foden, D. Silva, Gundogan (+ Zinchenko)
Sterling, Bernardo
Mahrez, Sané

Aguero, Jesus

Works for me.

One to many foreign players for them all to be in the squad. Worryingly I doubt we signed that goalkeeper and not assured him of a place in the squad albeit 3rd choice gk.

 

[ctid1894]

I disagree with the passes you’re claiming are poor. To anyone who understands the game there is fuck all wrong with them.

Aside from that, the rest of my point stands.

Guardiola knows better than you.

End of.

The one across the box (1:30 into the clip) - Why does his central defensive partner nearly get caught in possession? It’s clearly a horrible pass that puts him in a difficult position. You claim your understanding of the game is better than mine so please explain if it’s not Maguire at fault, how is his central defensive partner at fault? Maguire has two options:

1. The pass should either have gone back to the keeper (safest option) allowing the centre backs to split and a midfielder drop in to support.
2. The pass should have been played with more power across his partners body to allow him to pass the ball out to the right back or into midfield as he would have had more time on the ball (playing out of the press). He would also be on his stronger foot to make the pass.

 

[balotellishaircut]

Zinchenko has been playing leftback for us but that is not his natural position at all. I suspect he will get some time in the middle this season. He’s been incredible in CM for Ukraine.

i understand that, all i can say is international football is totally different from the premier league, Vinny started out as a midfielder, then switched to central defender and the rest is history, so natural positions work for some in a team set up and not for others.

 

[Deleted member 81382]

This is the one transfer in recent times that I cannot work out for the life of me. Goes completely against our transfer policy in recent years where we've picked up young, exciting talent for less than their market value and built them up. A 70m+ figure for Maguire would literally be us inflating the market for a mediocre CB that we don't even necessarily need that will have a poor resale value if it doesn't work out. This isn't a 'in Pep we trust' thing, we're all aware of Maguires abilities and his significant weaknesses. I'd much rather see us promote Sandler/Garcia or bring in a younger, cheaper option that Pep can work with and improve. Maguire seems like a step in the wrong direction for me. If he comes I'll support him but I'm not a fan of this if reports are believed.

This.

It doesn't make sense.

 

[Saddleworth2]

So if we sign Riesgo (Free), Maguire (£65m), Cancelo (£50m), Rodri (£65m), and Angelino (£6m), selling Muric (£5m), Delph (£10m) and Danilo (£25m) in the process, our squad will be... what?

Works for me.

that is one hell of a squad with no discernible weakness and a great deal of flexible cover for all positions.

 

[CC1]

Odd that rags are stocking up in English players under the guise that “Ole’s rebuilding”

Could Gill have alerted them that the number of homegrown in squads is going to be increased??? Another way to stop City buying top foreign players now FFP can’t stop us.

Could also be the reason we’re going for McGuire.

Hope we don’t sell Muric - loan for a season maybe.

 

[@BluePhil8]

So if we sign Riesgo (Free), Maguire (£65m), Cancelo (£50m), Rodri (£65m), and Angelino (£6m), selling Muric (£5m), Delph (£10m) and Danilo (£25m) in the process, our squad will be... what?

Works for me.

We might get £5m for Mangala as well.

 

[Neville Kneville]

The one across the box (1:30 into the clip) - Why does his central defensive partner nearly get caught in possession? It’s clearly a horrible pass that puts him in a difficult position. You claim your understanding of the game is better than mine so please explain if it’s not Maguire at fault, how is his central defensive partner at fault? Maguire has two options:

1. The pass should either have gone back to the keeper (safest option) allowing the centre backs to split and a midfielder drop in to support.
2. The pass should have been played with more power across his partners body to allow him to pass the ball out to the right back or into midfield as he would have had more time on the ball (playing out of the press). He would also be on his stronger foot to make the pass.

If you did a video of John Stones' passing fuckups, it would last 'til Christmas & Vinny's would be even longer.

Central defenders knocking the ball about= mistakes, no matter how 'comfortable' they are.

 

[Stoned Rose]

The one across the box (1:30 into the clip) - Why does his central defensive partner nearly get caught in possession? It’s clearly a horrible pass that puts him in a difficult position. You claim your understanding of the game is better than mine so please explain if it’s not Maguire at fault, how is his central defensive partner at fault? Maguire has two options:

1. The pass should either have gone back to the keeper (safest option) allowing the centre backs to split and a midfielder drop in to support.
2. The pass should have been played with more power across his partners body to allow him to pass the ball out to the right back or into midfield as he would have had more time on the ball (playing out of the press). He would also be on his stronger foot to make the pass.

Have the summer off mate. You’re boring as fuck.

 

[Deleted member 81382]

Just seen report for Mirror is by David Anderson.

Regardless of whether he signs, he's taking an opportunity to denigrate why we are getting him with the bullshit wages figure.

Anderson is your worst kind of journo. A Irish supporting Liverpool fan.

It doesn't surprise me in the slightest that he's a Liverpool fan. Ever since they signed Van Dijk, Liverpool fans have been desperate to justify the 75m price tag. By quoting ridiculous figures like 80m and 280k for Maguire, he's able to paint us as the bad guys who are ruining football whilst also making VVD look like a bargain in comparison. It's so transparent.

 

[Neville Kneville]

It doesn't surprise me in the slightest that he's a Liverpool fan. Ever since they signed Van Dijk, Liverpool fans have been desperate to justify the 75m price tag. By quoting ridiculous figures like 80m and 280k for Maguire, he's able to paint us as the bad guys who are ruining football whilst also making VVD look like a bargain in comparison. It's so transparent.

There is also the point that if Maguire wants to come to City, then Utd fans like to be told it's down to money.

 

[Deleted member 81382]

There is also the point that if Maguire wants to come to City, then Utd fans like to be told it's down to money.

Yep, they still think Sanchez chose them because of their history.

 

[manimanc]

The one across the box (1:30 into the clip) - Why does his central defensive partner nearly get caught in possession? It’s clearly a horrible pass that puts him in a difficult position. You claim your understanding of the game is better than mine so please explain if it’s not Maguire at fault, how is his central defensive partner at fault? Maguire has two options:

1. The pass should either have gone back to the keeper (safest option) allowing the centre backs to split and a midfielder drop in to support.
2. The pass should have been played with more power across his partners body to allow him to pass the ball out to the right back or into midfield as he would have had more time on the ball (playing out of the press). He would also be on his stronger foot to make the pass.

 

[Neville Kneville]

Yep, they still think Sanchez chose them because of their history.

They are correct in a way.

But it's their history of spending stupid amounts of money, which impressed him.

 

[supercity88]

Have you let Pep know you’re letting him do what he wants yet?

No but he seems to work on that basis anyway.

 

[ctid1894]

If you did a video of John Stones' passing fuckups, it would last 'til Christmas & Vinny's would be even longer.

Central defenders knocking the ball about= mistakes, no matter how 'comfortable' they are.

I fully accept that, of course it happens. We all make mistakes, no one is denying that but this is on a “highlights video” of so called positive clips and that’s the best they can find from a whole season?

 

[ctid1894]

Have the summer off mate. You’re boring as fuck.

Hahaha brilliant, so you post something and then run away when someone questions it. I haven’t been abusive, I haven’t done anything wrong other than disagree with you and the dummy gets spat out.

 

[leo_city]

Using YouTube clips for analysis is always a bad start

 

[leo_city]

Otamendi 17/18 is a prime example of players with little passing ability still adapting because they understand the requirements for the system. We already have a ball playing centre half in Laporte, Maguire could be the no nonsense guy.