What is the similarity about all these teams? they try to play football. They do not blitz you with super hard pressing and indeed some serious/dangerous challenges. He has good reason to be wary of that so i doubt
@quiet_riot is criticizing him as a fair weather, just stating a fact such as it is. There are as you both note plenty of matches perfectly suited to him, he certainly has a place here. There are also matches where he is best kept as a sub to come and help control and dictate the tempo to a slightly tired oppo.
In fairness, we have never seen him play at DM against anyone without success. The notion he will be good against ''just certain teams who don't press" is an assumption that has no basis in evidence.
Tothenham and Arsenal are the 2nd and third best "pressing teams" in the league if you exclude us. And Chelsea ( the away version) is probably in the top 10. And Gundogan excelled against all 3.
He didn't play DM against the only superior press team in the league, Liverpool... So we can't say for a fact he can't handle them.
In essence, he can play DM against absolutely anyone in the league, bar Liverpool. And seeing as no one we've played at DM against Liverpool has succeeded against their press, it is only fair to conclude he can play DM against anyone in the league.
As the only team he '''might" fail against, everyone else (i.e Dihno) has already failed against.
As for people putting in rash tackles. That affects our attacking players more. Not the guy rotating possession efficiently.
As far as playing DM is concerned, I'd have no worries playing him there against anyone. He is different from Dihno, but not necessarily weaker.
It's like Delph or Mendy... They play it differently. But one isn't necessarily better. The path is different but outcomes are pretty similar. We win!