In your opinion who's a better player....

[idahoblues]

Pirlo is way better than that annoying scouse **** gerrard. fuck him, guaranteed he'll be a tv pundit just like shearer and people will love his anti every club b/s

 

[Armaan]

Pirlo for me...I cant remember Gerrard running games against good national team opposition like Pirlo has done this Euros.

That's why i would lean towards Pirlo.... The way he dictates and controls games really is jay dropping at times.

 

[TheMightyQuinn]

I can't believe themadinventor and MaviAy are taking TMQ seriously... i don't even think he was after bites.

The latter I can believe as he joined today.

As for the inventor,not totally suprised as he was telling everyone about how he seen the loch ness monster only the other day.

Looks like I've been had lol

Glad to know it was a joke.

Was seriously starting to contemplate whether my pub team could take on Messi!

I think Scott Parker is pretty shit to be honest :)

 

[samharris]

The latter I can believe as he joined today.

As for the inventor,not totally suprised as he was telling everyone about how he seen the loch ness monster only the other day.

Looks like I've been had lol

Glad to know it was a joke.

Was seriously starting to contemplate whether my pub team could take on Messi!

I think Scott Parker is pretty shit to be honest :)

I have it on good authority that when Scotty retires he's going to be a revolving door salesman.

 

[the goats backside]

I think to be fair to Gerrard, if he had played in a good team country wise he could have easily controlled a game . When your confronted with 4 quality midfielders you hope that your 4 will be as good, but in Euro 12 2 of them were told to stay out wide and the other looked like he was about to drop a turd everytime he ran

 

[Anonymous]

Gerrard, pretty much dragged liverpool throughout the years, to win cups like the champions league, fa cup.....

if gerrarad was italian or dutch.... we would be saying hes the best

 

[ForzaMancini]

Tough one. I think Gerrard was too inconsistent but then again I never saw Pirlo week in week out. I think the way Pirlo effortlessly plays these amazing passes and at his age now would probably make me think Pirlo is the better player but I don't think he is much better than Gerrard. Gerrard certainly has a better eye for goal, free-kicks aside.

 

[Armaan]

Would love to hear some Italian opinions.

 

[Zealot87]

Would love to hear some Italian opinions.

Here I am :D .
This is not an easy question, btw I think that Pirlo was really understimate throught years, maybe because Italian serie a in the last years have lost some visibility.
But he is brilliant, clever, pure class player... one of the best midfielder ever.
Two years ago he got injuried and that's why he did not played at his standards.
On the other side, Gerrard is a nice all-round player, I love it... but at the end of the day, I would like to have Pirlo in my team rather than Gerrard.
Because Pirlo can really change a team alone, can turn your the cards in the table more than Gerrad.
That's my opinion, sorry for english mistakes :D<br /><br />-- Fri Jun 29, 2012 3:42 pm --<br /><br />

Would love to hear some Italian opinions.

Here I am :D .
This is not an easy question, btw I think that Pirlo was really understimate throught years, maybe because Italian serie a in the last years have lost some visibility.
But he is brilliant, clever, pure class player... one of the best midfielder ever.
Two years ago he got injuried and that's why he did not played at his standards.
On the other side, Gerrard is a nice all-round player, I love it... but at the end of the day, I would like to have Pirlo in my team rather than Gerrard.
Because Pirlo can really change a team alone, can turn your the cards in the table more than Gerrad.
That's my opinion, sorry for english mistakes :D

 

[Laurent Charvet]

I wonder what views would have been on this a month ago?