Israel-Palestine Conflict

[abu13]

Things never end well on an Israel thread, i'll give it 30 minutes before it all kicks off on here :)

 

[HellYeah]

Do you think it's acceptable to storm a country's border, throwing molotovs at the guards?

That's the spirit, answer a question with a question, genius mate. My dad's bigger than your dad etc etc etc

No to your question, by the way.

 

[west didsblue]

But this thread is abt Israel and the state murdering Palistainians. I was told to start a thread on this as to not derail others.

The UNHRC chief is in the title of the thread. I think it’s legitimate to discuss that organisation here.

 

[Ancient Citizen]

That's the spirit, answer a question with a question, genius mate. My dad's bigger than your dad etc etc etc

No to your question, by the way.

Clever boy.
So, if it's not acceptable, why question what happens if you do?
That's another question by the way, and my dad's no longer with us, although he was 6 foot three, so quite possibly.

 

[The blue phantom]

OK.
Is shooting people who are throwing petrol bombs at you permissible?

I would would say there's better ways at dealing with it than live ammunition.

Things never end well on an Israel thread, i'll give it 30 minutes before it all kicks off on here :)

I've looked at every other football forum and they all have a debate on this topic. If it turns to abuse isn't the new policy thread bans?

 

[HellYeah]

Clever boy.
So, if it's not acceptable, why question what happens if you do?
That's another question by the way, and my dad's no longer with us, although he was 6 foot three, so quite possibly.

Answering a question with a question is a very poor debating tool and not normally worth a response. It adds nothing to a debate and sounds childish.

You should have at least answered the initial question.

 

[Ancient Citizen]

I would would say there's better ways at dealing with it than live ammunition.


I've looked at every other football forum and they all have a debate on this topic. If it turns to abuse isn't the new policy thread bans?

How would you have handled this situation?
What if soldiers were frantically avoiding getting burned to death?
It's very easy to scream about murderers and the like, to enforce an anti Israel agenda, but dissection of the
facts involved sometimes makes that stance look ridiculous.

 

[Ancient Citizen]

Answering a question with a question is a very poor debating tool and not normally worth a response. It adds nothing to a debate and sounds childish.

You should have at least answered the initial question.

Instead of questioning my debating skills, why don't you answer the original question?
For what it's worth, my answer to it is yes, I'd shoot anyone who was about to throw a bottle of petrol with a burning
rag in it at me.

 

[Prestwich_Blue]

I wonder if the UNHRC has made any comment on the fact that Saudi Arabia has beheaded 48 people so far in 2018? The independent group Human Rights Watch have so I'd assume their counterparts at the UN would have.

 

[west didsblue]

I would would say there's better ways at dealing with it than live ammunition.

Maybe throw some petrol bombs back?