Damocles said:
We'll see how many people change their minds when the inevitable loss to Sunderland comes tomorrow.
For the record, I'm a supporter of Mancini being our manager, just as I was with Hughes, Sven, Pearce, Keegan, etc. I'll NEVER boo or slate our manager.
yes and I was thinking of this same thing (our possible result and the match at Sunderland) as I wrote my post.
however, supporting and believing in a manager's ability and approach isn't fickle and dependent upon any singular result.
I've never had anything personal against any of the managers you mention - but that need not stop me turning to the guy next to me at Anfield and asking him if he's as cheesed-off as I am watching the way Pearce set us out for that game; and how we only started playing to win after we went a goal down.
likewise, I wasn't sure (whilst I always supported him & the team) that Hughes was up to the job he was tasked with. That need not mean he's a poor overall manager, just that for our situation he had his limitations and I began to wonder about things around the same time that I signed up on here.
Manciti hasn't gotten fully going yet, but from what I have seen so far, despite our less than purple patch, I have been impressed with the way he approaches things. His is a very different style altogether, and I think more appropriate in our circumstances than anything that Hughes ever laid out, not that he didn't make positive contributions in some ways.
I don't think that judging a manager, and assessing any sort of complex system/situation which is what football is (in total) all about comes down to any one game in isolation - baring something very seldom seen and totally catastrophic.
PSML at BilboBlue's comments after the Zimmer Man