Jamie Jackson’s Player Season Ratings — Do you agree?

[Manc in London]

Ederson - 8
Ortega - 8
Walker - 7
Lewis - 7
Stones - 7
Akanji - 9
Dias - 8
Aké - 9
Gvardiol - 8
Gómez - 4
Rodri - 10
Kovacic - 8
Nunes - 6
Phillips - 4
De Bruyne - 9
Bernardo - 8
Grealish - 7
Foden - 10
Bobb - 7
Álvarez - 8
Doku - 8
Haaland - 8

I think these are better. Maybe Alvarez a 6 and Dias a 7/6.

 

[cleavers]

‘One more goal conceded’ slightly?

The very definition of "slight" obviously, but when you concede less than a goal per game, then the number is always likely to be small.

I just think we defended better last season from eye, than we did this season, it's just my opinion, not something I intend arguing about.

 

[Haaland94]

My take:

Ederson - 9
Ortega - 9
Walker - 7
Lewis - 6
Stones - 7,5
Akanji - 8,5
Dias - 7,5
Aké - 9
Gvardiol - 9
Gómez - n/a (not enough minutes, although a 6 when he was on, always decent)
Rodri - 10
Kovacic - 8
Nunes - 6
Phillips - 3
De Bruyne - 9
Bernardo - 9
Grealish - 7
Foden - 10
Bobb - 7
Álvarez - 8
Doku - 8
Haaland - 9

Other than KP, everyone did well (5 being okay) and more or much more etc.

 

[Middedon]

Please excuse the interruption in the thread. Thank you. :-)

Eccles Blue’s players season rating:

Every single player gets a 9.
None get a ten because then they’ll have nothing to strive for next season.

Thank you. As you were. :-) ;-)

I’m good with this approach. However, I’m slightly surprised John isn’t allowed an 11!

 

[SebastianBlue]

The very definition of "slight" obviously, but when you concede less than a goal per game, then the number is always likely to be small.

I just think we defended better last season from eye, than we did this season, it's just my opinion, not something I intend arguing about.

Fair enough.

At least you indicate “slightly”. Some on here have seemed to think our defence was shambolic compared to last season.

 

[Bluearmy]

If anything too fair imo

 

[BlueMoonRisin’]

Phillips deserves no more than 1, and that's being generous as he's given us fuck all.

 

[Stoned Rose]

Haaland a 7 for me.

Yes he scored lots of goals, but the areas for improvement in his game have been abundantly clear.

Akanji 9.5. He’s been fucking outstanding imo.

 

[HelloCity]

What’s this about Gomez being a rag, or is it just going over my head? Ha

 

[ChicagoBlue]

Ridiculously high for me, the Haaland 10 is laughable.

Ederson - 8
Ortega - 8
Walker - 8
Lewis - 7
Stones - 7
Akanji - 8
Dias - 8
Aké - 8
Gvardiol - 8

We've let in too many goals (some daft ones) for any defender to get above 8.
Gómez - 6
Rodri - 10
Kovacic - 8
Nunes - 5
Phillips - 3 (not sure why he's even in the last)
De Bruyne - 7
Bernardo - 8
Grealish - 7
Foden - 10
Bobb - 8
Álvarez - 7
Doku - 7
Haaland - 7 (missed too many sitters for me)

Bobb - 8 with 7s you gave Lewis, Stones, KDB, Grealish, Alvarez, Doku & Haaland?

You’re Oscar Bobb’s girlfriend and I claim my £5!!