Joe Hart (joined Torino on season long loan - Official)

Status
Not open for further replies.
It does fit a Pep pattern of making very decisive decisions on playing staff early on his tenure at a club.

Some of it will undoubtedly simply send a signal about who is in charge. It is no coincidence that the players he sells are often big characters.

I will be surprised if Joe is leaving purely in ability terms. Pep will have had the inside track for a good while.
This all day long. It's less to do with playing ability more to do with the ability to do as the manager wants without fomenting unrest in the dressing room.
 
Not really, just trying to understand why things are as they are
I think its fairly straight forward,i'm pretty sure Pep knows Joe's so far in front of Willy in terms of goalkeeping ability.Nothing against willy but he's now just playing his career out, he hasn't let us down and he seems happy with sitting on the bench.So if Pep puts Hart in and he plays well in first 4 or 5 games very difficult for the manager to drop him to bring his own man in without upsetting a vocal portion of the crowd,it doesn't matter how well Willy plays because we know he's not a first choice keeper so when he's dropped to the bench nobody really cares.
 
No I didn't miss anything. You've just been woefully inconsistent and slagged De Gea and Neuer and held them to a completely different standard to Joe in your critique.
No, wrong again. De Gea is arguably better than Neuer at the moment (Buffon, for me, is still the top man), but he (De Gea) made three big mistakes in two games at the Euros (I watched most of the games) - barely a comment from anyone other than Hoddle. Hart concedes two goals he would normally keep out and there's a witch hunt. I hear pundits talking quite a lot about about Neuer's twenty clean sheets for Bayern last season. Given that statistically, he faces fewer shots than any other GK in the BL, how much of an achievement is that ? That said, he can do no more than deal with the shots that come his way. Why is it unfair to compare Hart's international clean sheet record with Neuer's ? Yes, Germany go deeper into tournaments and play the better teams in the last four, but their defence and midfield is vastly superior to England's. To me, there's a lot of criticism of Hart's ability, but when you drill down through the stats his record is exceptional - no fluke.
 
No, wrong again. De Gea is arguably better than Neuer at the moment (Buffon, for me, is still the top man), but he (De Gea) made three big mistakes in two games at the Euros (I watched most of the games) - barely a comment from anyone other than Hoddle. Hart concedes two goals he would normally keep out and there's a witch hunt. I hear pundits talking quite a lot about about Neuer's twenty clean sheets for Bayern last season. Given that statistically, he faces fewer shots than any other GK in the BL, how much of an achievement is that ? That said, he can do no more than deal with the shots that come his way. Why is it unfair to compare Hart's international clean sheet record with Neuer's ? Yes, Germany go deeper into tournaments and play the better teams in the last four, but their defence and midfield is vastly superior to England's. To me, there's a lot of criticism of Hart's ability, but when you drill down through the stats his record is exceptional - no fluke.
Good post mate.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.