joey v shay

[colinbellsboots]

i know there will be loads disagreing but here goes, bring back BRAVE harte, hes had a brilliant season, he honestly now think that if any has to leave it must be shay, great shot stopper , but his distribution isnt as good as harte,s hart is better at croses and im convinced hes a better all round keeper.
ok i might be incorrect in what i say but it seems shay has too many faults, he dosnt seem as competant as joey.

 

[Manchester_City_Blue]

I agree that Joe should play next year, but I think this thing about him having better distribution is wrong. I thought that until I looked at the guardain chalkboard. They are pretty even on distribution

 

[Bill]

if we are being honest not many people on here have seen a great deal of joe this season, on motd etc they will show his highlights etc, when he left us he was just not quite ready, hence shay. not sure he will have the made up enough ground to replace shay at this moment in time.

 

[Colins Bellend]

We need a keeper,look how much more confident utds defence is with VDS.A calm head on a keeper is needed and i don't think Shay has that but i'm not sure Hart has either

 

[standytogilvy]

I'd like to see Hart back at city next season hopefully challenging for the no1 spot but the risk is he wants first team football which could be our downfall in losing him

 

[Dave Ewing's Back 'eader]

We need a keeper,look how much more confident utds defence is with VDS.A calm head on a keeper is needed and i don't think Shay has that but i'm not sure Hart has either

Absolutely agree. I think they are very similar specimens. I also think that had Joe Hart been in our goal this season, performing identically to the way he has at Brum, he would not be getting the same accolades from press and pundits.