No one does at the moment. We're panicking. Our defensive shape without the ball is horrific. Players are pressing and leaving easy passes available and plenty of space. Or they're dropping far too deep. Here are some images of our defensive shape from last night, and I've compared it to Juventus.
View attachment 140422
City in attack - Juve have their defenders in the box and are all on the front foot looking to close the ball as soon as it's played. You can see Gundo and De Bruyne have some space.
View attachment 140423
But instantly the Juve players have sprinted out to close that down and prevent the ball coming into the box.
View attachment 140424
Meanwhile this is us... Doku and Rico had doubled up on Conceicao. Gundo is...well I'm not sure what he's up to with a man behind him. Despite how many players in defensive positions we have, there's an easy pass back and it's 3 v 3 in the box for any cross - which is what happens.
View attachment 140425
And here's another example. Look how many players are back, but how much space there is outside the box. No one has got tight to a player to prevent an easy pass or to win the ball back. We've just got back into the defensive third and are all stood around watching the ball, which gets crossed in and ends up leading to the goal. You can pick out nearly every player in a City shirt and see something wrong. Haaland should have prevented the cross. Dias has two players he's defending because Gvardiol's positioning is wrong. Gundo and Bernardo don't need to be where they are and should either be tracking a man or on the edge of the box to close one of those players off. Walker's got the man behind him as well as one in front which he's too far off to mark.
Ederson then spills the ball, it's not cleared properly...Walker doesn't get tight to stop the cross and despite three defenders being in the box Vlahovic wins the header, Ederson spills again and it's 1-0.
It's a car crash at the moment. It's like watching kids. Run straight back to your goal as soon as you lose it seems to be the strategy. But don't worry about any shape or defensive structure.