KDB or Haaland?

[JewelZee]

KDB end of thread, Halland yes scores goals but KDB has offered a lot more, stunning goals, assists and much more, I am meh over haaland, let's see how he does when we play the top 4 in the prem

You are meh over Haaland?...LMFAO

 

[Johnny Mars Bar]

KDB all day every day.

 

[Mariosfireworks]

You are meh over Haaland?...LMFAO

He's been at the club for a few months mate, yes he has scored goals, he hasn't won anything with us yet, so will judge when he has proven himself for us season in season out

 

[Mariosfireworks]

Calling Haaland ‘meh’ isn’t an opinion. It’s fucking stupidity of the highest order. I sometimes click on the ignored content just to see what’s being said by who and I’m very rarely left disappointed. I’ve got lots of opinions that I expect posters to disagree with. Not an issue unless it’s so outlandish you can only come to the conclusion that they are taking the piss.

In what way am I taking the piss? He has been here a few months so far, yes he has scored a lot of goals, but out of the teams you would expect to be around the top 4 or 5 we have played 1 and we lost and he didn't score, I will judge when he has been here a lot longer, so when I say meh it means my opinion is yet to be made, let's see how he performs when we play spurs, Arsenal, Chelsea and other sides of that calibre

 

[Bill]

KDB by mile. he is in the Bell / Meriln bracket and like them committed to City.
Haarland won't stick around to prove his case.

 

[JewelZee]

He's been at the club for a few months mate, yes he has scored goals, he hasn't won anything with us yet, so will judge when he has proven himself for us season in season out

But you said he's been meh, not what will he do or what will he win. In those few months he's been the furthest thing from meh one could be. Have the expectation levels really gone to a foreign universe? Meh? SMH...

 

[Brodymcfc]

I think a more accurate question would be…

KDB or David Silva

Haaland or peak aguero

 

[Alan Harper's Tash]

I think a more accurate question would be…

KDB or David Silva

Haaland or peak aguero

Can we add Bernardo to the first comparison?

 

[Cambijao]

The Croatia-Belgium game earlier today (once again) just shows it doesn't matter how many chances are created if a team have a misfiring striker like Lukaku up-front.

Lukaku chances against Croatia

Video Lukaku chances against Croatia was uploaded to Streamin.me on Dec 01, 2022.

streamin.me

I know I'm biased, but I've my reasons why I prefer Haaland over KDB without a shadow of doubt.

- Already top 3 striker itw as a 20 yr old. Best player itw right now. He's years away from entering his "true prime years". He may end up as the GOAT striker before his 30s. KDB was never the best midfielder/striker at any point of his career and never will be.

- Elite finishing is the most valuable attribute in football. It's not a coincidence the best players itw happens to be forwards with incredible goalscoring production with outstanding level of finishing. After all, games are won by outscoring your opponent.

- Man City never had a generational talent in their history before Haaland's arrival. KDB has never been that caliber of a player.

 

[WesthoughtonJohn]

Is this really up for debate????
KdB all day long - Erling is brutal in front of goal, but wouldn't score for fun without the support