List Your Top Five Most Valuable Current City Players

[Terra Passenger]

My top 5 in order of importance:

Sergio Aguero (if he'd stay fit, could win the Ballon d'Or)
Kevin De Bruyne (just eclipses David Silva because of age)
David Silva (stay calm, and pass it to Silva)
Vincent Kompany (the rock of our D)
Joe Hart (his distribution has improved tremendously - his biggest problem now is consistency)

 

[Manchester33]

I think you're looking at the list with blue tinted spectacles. It would be:

1 - Messi
2 - Ronaldo
3 - Neymar
4 - Suarez
5 - Bale

But if you're just looking at City it's probably;

1 - Aguero
2 - Silva
3 - Kompany
4 - De Bruyne
5 - Sterling

That's with Toure and Hart close behind, their age and position respectively probably reduce value significantly.

 

[Terra Passenger]

@manchester 33
Good list. I changed the title of the thread to reflect my intent to rank current City players in order of importance.

 

[M3 Blue]

Silva
Hart
Aguero
Fernandinho
Kompany

Maybe people wouldn't agree with Ferna but I think we miss him as much as the others when he's out.

Oh that isn't a particular order though.

 

[Dipsis_LTU_MC]

Fernandinho is the most underrated footballer in Europe. Defensively he is at the same level with Busquets and offensively he is miles ahead of Busquets.

 

[Stuuuuuu]

Serg
Dave
Ginge
Joe
Vinny

Although some of them are ageing (I think Dave is 29 now) so that would affect their value.

In a year or two, Nacho will be in that list.

 

[kippax91]

Vinny
sergio
silva
hart
Kev

 

[Gundogan's Moustache]

Kompany
Aguero
Hart
Silva
Fernandinho

(Sterling a close 6th)