I've always been very unwilling to subscribe to the agenda theory — I just don't believe in that kind of thing — but this, from the BBC website,
really burns me:
"Of the Premier League's four contenders, only
Manchester United failed to make it through, suffering a heartbreaking exit against Wolfsburg on Tuesday night."
Now why the
fuck is it "heartbreaking"? Would they have written that about City? Or even Arsenal or Chelsea?
DD, I take your point. I repeat that I am emphatically not one of these people who sees hostility to City everywhere. When we won the league in May 2012 the entire country was behind us, apart from United fans. I have never contributed either to this thread or the Agenda thread before.
But hang on, let's contextualise this a bit. Firstly, the four sources you cite have nothing like the worldwide prestige, authority and general resonance of the BBC. You and I both know that people take about forty-five seconds to surf, and the BBC website is one of the first places they go. Football fans specifically, who know a thing or two about the game, may consult your four sites. People in general who may have a vague interest in sports generally and, maybe within that, football go to places like the BBC. And that's a much, much broader constituency. And the message here is, for that constituency, "poor old Manchester United".
Secondly, the quote I give is a
summarising statement about the four clubs in the CL — not a commentary, as your sources give, on one specific match in the process of the group stage matches. That distinction seems to me to be very important. In that context, one of the four clubs is singled out for privileged treatment. I stand by my stated conviction: none of the other three would have been.
Thirdly, and while we're about it. Your sources discuss City nearly winning or drawing against the likes of Bayern and Real Madrid. These are giants. What is so heartbreaking about going out in a group that by common consent — not just my opinion — was considered to be one of the easier ones?
Ours was termed the "group of death", not by ourselves, necessarily (I never thought it was, personally) but by the media. Nobody, so far as I know, described United's group, which included Wolfsburg, PSV, CSKA, as any such thing. They went out fair and square because they underperformed over the whole group stage.