MillionMilesAway
Well-Known Member
I'm no expert on offside but I thought if the ball comes off the defender then the Everton player would not be deemed offside even if he touches it, and if onside then not interfering with play.
There are specific things that makes someone who is an offside position offside - it's not at all clear which one Sigurdsson was judged under.
I think if the ball had hit Sigurdsson off the defender, he's definitely have been offside.