Post Match Thread: Election 2017

Status
Not open for further replies.
With respect, what's happened to the lib dems is as irrelevant as the lib dems themselves.

So if you're right, and if I was a Tory, with JC looming and all his 'momentum', why would I call an election in the next couple of years? That's the ultimate turkey voting for christmas analogy. Might as well stick it out for the full 5 years. Again, and it's a point a lot seem to be missing, the Tories have the power and they get to call when the next election is.

Labour were given an unexpected early shot, and they've missed. They might not get another one for 5 years. If you can predict what's going to happen between now and 5 years time you're wasted on Bluemoon, and should be earning millions on the stock exchange. Perversely, odds are you'd be a Tory voter if that were the case.

I'll just leave this here:

Sinn Fein - "Tory and DUP alliance is in contravention of the terms of the Good Friday Agreement".

If this coalition goes 5 years then it will only prove that May and the Tories are as arrogant and power hungry as people suspect and it could do irrepreable damage to that party for decades.
 
Well what a great big fuck up this whole sorry saga has turned out to be. A pm nobody voted for backed by some Irish blokes nobody's even heard of, never mind voted for.
The con's rush to grab total power has failed spectacularly and now we find ourselves in what can only be described as a total fucking mess.
Strong and stable my fucking arse.
 
It's a wake up call, but a soft one as they are still in power. The Tory's 'worst case scenario' is still better than Labours 'victory' and sees them remain in power, just with a little bit of DUP ego massaging to contend with. Any Labour voters celebrating are celebrating a very hollow 'victory'. Unless of course they aspire to be a particularly annoying opposition/protest party, but not actually rulers.

Its like losing a boxing match and celebrating with your mates that you only broke your nose. Meanwhile your opposition took some blows/has some bruises, but he's still the one taking the good looking girl home and planning his next big fight.

(I'm drinking wine in a lounge before a long haul flight and I'm in an analogy mood. Apologies if they're not very good)
The analogy is a good one, the re-match in 5 years will be a cracker.
 
Labour's celebrations remind me of the Fa cup game against the rags. 3-0 down at half time and down to 10 men.
We put up a great fight and got close but we still got beat
 
Labour's celebrations remind me of the Fa cup game against the rags. 3-0 down at half time and down to 10 men.
We put up a great fight and got close but we still got beat

What was the score in the next derby? ;-)

Just getting that in before the Labour supporter do.
 
I'll just leave this here:

Sinn Fein - "Tory and DUP alliance is in contravention of the terms of the Good Friday Agreement".

If this coalition goes 5 years then it will only prove that May and the Tories are as arrogant and power hungry as people suspect and it could do irrepreable damage to that party for decades.

Jay. Not looking for an argument, but did you ever think that May and the Tories were anything but arrogant and power hungry?

As for irreparable damage, there are staunch conservatives and staunch labour, who will vote for their parties irrespective of what's gone before. It's the 'swingers' who would be affected, but barring the odd crisis of conscience they'll always go with whichever party offers them the best personal deal. Not sure irreparable damage exists in the world of political parties.
 
I'll just leave this here:

Sinn Fein - "Tory and DUP alliance is in contravention of the terms of the Good Friday Agreement".

If this coalition goes 5 years then it will only prove that May and the Tories are as arrogant and power hungry as people suspect and it could do irrepreable damage to that party for decades.
Her claim to govern in the national interest is wholly inconsistent with any form of alliance with the DUP. It is a manifest lie and completely irresponsible.
 
With respect, what's happened to the lib dems is as irrelevant as the lib dems themselves.

So if you're right, and if I was a Tory, with JC looming and all his 'momentum', why would I call an election in the next couple of years? That's the ultimate turkey voting for christmas analogy. Might as well stick it out for the full 5 years. Again, and it's a point a lot seem to be missing, the Tories have the power and they get to call when the next election is.

Labour were given an unexpected early shot, and they've missed. They might not get another one for 5 years. If you can predict what's going to happen between now and 5 years time you're wasted on Bluemoon, and should be earning millions on the stock exchange. Perversely, odds are you'd be a Tory voter if that were the case.

The Tories might be able to keep in power for a five year term but a lot will depend on what goes on in Northern Ireland.!issues ranging from gay marriage to prosecuting soldiers for doing their job in Northern Ireland could put the ConDUP's alliance under greater pressure.

Labour have a social / youth movement behind part of their support as we know. If this grows then the next election (when it comes) will be even closer. That said, Labour might have held the balance of power if Dianne Abbot had been ditched earlier.
 
And we completely lost the election which means 5 more years of austerity and failing support for the neediest in society, because people were more interested in feeling good about themselves than they were winning the election.

This isn't a win. Celebrating this result while failing to help the people who need it is an absolute disgrace and people should be ashamed for it.

Yeh I think you've made this point pretty clear.

Whilst not celebrating I don't think Corbyn or Labour could have done anymore, Torys called the election when they were certain they and all of us would get a huge outright majority.

Now they have infighting and a coalition with a very shady party in Northern Ireland, there is no guarentee they will hold on to power for the next 5 years - so whilst Labour are not in the hot seat yet they have the momentum and optimism which they didn't have previously.
 
Her claim to govern in the national interest is wholly inconsistent with any form of alliance with the DUP. It is a manifest lie and completely irresponsible.

Is there any chance of the Tories repaing the £143mil (lowest estimate of the cost of the election) because the General Election was only called to serve the Tories. I might be waiting a long time for this.
 
The Tories might be able to keep in power for a five year term but a lot will depend on what goes on in Northern Ireland.!issues ranging from gay marriage to prosecuting soldiers for doing their job in Northern Ireland could put the ConDUP's alliance under greater pressure.

Labour have a social / youth movement behind part of their support as we know. If this grows then the next election (when it comes) will be even closer. That said, Labour might have held the balance of power if Dianne Abbot had been ditched earlier.
I think you're agreeing with me. The election was there for the taking, and labour didn't have the right people in charge to get people to vote for them to take it.

That's not a victory, and whether it's 2,3,4 or 5 years from now, lots can happen and there are no guarantees for the next election. The only guarantee right now, is Labour are not in power today.
 
Morning guys. Well talk about your all time backfires.

Can't say I'm keen on a coalition involving the DUP. My Dad moved over from Belfast at the start of 'The Troubles' and his siblings, and then my grandparents followed a few years later. None of them have ever had a nice word to say about the DUP.

I'm aware of their rise within NI politics in the 70s and 80s, then the 'Chuckle Brothers' teaming up later on against all odds. But admittedly I've only ever heard it all from my family. Could anyone point me to any impartial, non-affiliated websites concerning the DUP that anyone knows of so I can form a more educated opinion for myself, please?
 
Her claim to govern in the national interest is wholly inconsistent with any form of alliance with the DUP. It is a manifest lie and completely irresponsible.
When direct rule and Northern Ireland is mentioned I don't think anyone quite thought it would be Stormont imposing direct rule on Westminster!
 
Apparently Ruth Davidson is demanding greater independence for the Scottish tories. The Scottish tories are against hard brexit (not really surprising). Another nail in the coffin of hard brexit.

I think hard brexit is dead and buried....we better lube up, heard those Europeans like it hard
 
I was over in Berlin for Thursday and Friday, so missed all the fun! ( proxy vote) It was great to get away from the insanity of the U.K., the relative calm of Berlin was a much needed tonic, loads of families riding bikes with kids around the city, cars and bikes happily sharing roads, I didn't hear one horn used in anger ( and I walked 16 miles the 2 days I was there) no litter on the floor, people whizzing round on electric scooters, and of course, that "quiet efficiency" we hear so much about.
They must be doing something right, they work less than us, yet are more productive, and it shows, more free time, less running round like headless chickens.
 
I think you're agreeing with me. The election was there for the taking, and labour didn't have the right people in charge to get people to vote for them to take it.

That's not a victory, and whether it's 2,3,4 or 5 years from now, lots can happen and there are no guarantees for the next election. The only guarantee right now, is Labour are not in power today.

I agree that this week, Labour would have needed a wider appeal that requires people to be in the right roles. If we compare this with say the Greek elections a few years back at least Alexis Tsipras had seasoned economists in his team.

I think Labour need to continue to grow their social movement and strengthen economic competence to Ben very competitive at the next Election, whenever it comes.

Maybe the Alliamce with the DUP will force the Tories to wake up from their post truth reliance e.g. Instead of lying about cuts in armed policing and 7p school breakfasts.
 
I posted this somewhere before mackenzie..A complete rig up. I said as soon as i heard the result today that its all a rig up. Theresa May(the remainer btw) quickly and very conveniently called a general election before the brexit talks began properly..she then acts the clown and the wonderful media give her a bit of a clobbering..meanwhile they ramp up ol' jezzas profile and the sheep just follow and chew the grass..then bingo,hung parliament,next step a 2nd referendum...its a total bolox. Get Nige back into the frame forthwith and let him smash into the lot of em.
You must have been watching and reading a different media than me, tory councillors acting as ordinary citizens to question the leader of the opposition, privately educated toffs in designer labels pretending to be a hard up student etc etc

Oh for god's sake, you've said it again. Give it up man. We understand your opinion. You may be right, OR NOT.

If Corbyn stays for a 3rd time and loses again, things may change. Hell, how old is he? 70-odd?

You have an opinion that may be right. Please stop trying to tell people it's fact, when it is simply your opinion.
Corbyn has motivated a marvellous amount of our youth to get involved in politics, that has to be encouraged by all. He has also had to deal with backstabbing within his own party, and the most venomous assault and character assassination of any politician in my lifetime, but still came within 3,000 votes of becoming Prime minister, he has also dragged the political discourse back to the centre ground.

Labour built and staffed much needed new hospitals,was that wrong?
Yes. It was funded by exceedingly expensive PPP & PFI contracts that we will be paying off for years, at a far higher cost than necessary.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top