Season ratings (so far)

[hcblue95]

I'm bored and wondering how people would rate our player's seasons in what has been a relatively dissapointing season. We don't know if the season has ended or not, but as I say I'm bored.

I've probably given quite harsh marks, but I'm holding to the high standards of 17/18 & 18/19. If the season resumed and we added the Champions League and FA Cup to the League Cup I'd look like a bit of a twat for these ratings I guess.


1 GK Claudio Bravo 7
2 DF Kyle Walker 7
5 DF John Stones 5
7 MF Raheem Sterling 6.5
8 MF İlkay Gündoğan 6
9 FW Gabriel Jesus 7
10 FW Sergio Agüero 6.5
11 MF Oleksandr Zinchenko 6
14 DF Aymeric Laporte 6.5
16 MF Rodri 6.5
17 MF Kevin De Bruyne 8.5
19 MF Leroy Sané N/A
20 MF Bernardo Silva 5
21 MF David Silva 6
22 DF Benjamin Mendy 6.5
25 MF Fernandinho 7
26 MF Riyad Mahrez 7
27 DF João Cancelo 6
30 DF Nicolás Otamendi 6.5
31 GK Ederson 6
33 GK Scott Carson N/A
47 MF Phil Foden 6.5
50 DF Eric García 6.5

 

[GX Blue]

1 GK Claudio Bravo 6
2 DF Kyle Walker 8
5 DF John Stones 5
7 MF Raheem Sterling 7
8 MF İlkay Gündoğan 6
9 FW Gabriel Jesus 7
10 FW Sergio Agüero 7
11 MF Oleksandr Zinchenko 5
14 DF Aymeric Laporte -
16 MF Rodri 5
17 MF Kevin De Bruyne 9
19 MF Leroy Sané -
20 MF Bernardo Silva 6
21 MF David Silva 6
22 DF Benjamin Mendy 5
25 MF Fernandinho 6
26 MF Riyad Mahrez 7
27 DF João Cancelo 5
30 DF Nicolás Otamendi 6
31 GK Ederson 6
33 GK Scott Carson -
47 MF Phil Foden 7
50 DF Eric García 6.5

 

[DontLookBackInAnger]

1 GK Claudio Bravo 5
2 DF Kyle Walker 7.5
5 DF John Stones 5.5
7 MF Raheem Sterling 7
8 MF İlkay Gündoğan 6
9 FW Gabriel Jesus 7
10 FW Sergio Agüero 7
11 MF Oleksandr Zinchenko 6.5
14 DF Aymeric Laporte 6
16 MF Rodri 6.5
17 MF Kevin De Bruyne 9
19 MF Leroy Sané NA
20 MF Bernardo Silva 6
21 MF David Silva 6
22 DF Benjamin Mendy 6.5
25 MF Fernandinho 7
26 MF Riyad Mahrez 7.5
27 DF João Cancelo 4.5
30 DF Nicolás Otamendi 5
31 GK Ederson 6.5
33 GK Scott Carson N/A
47 MF Phil Foden 6.5
50 DF Eric García 6.5

 

[Millwallawayveteran1988]

I’ll assume 3 Terrible 4 Poor 5 Below average 6 average, 7 good 8 very good 9 excellent 10 Outstanding


1 GK Claudio Bravo 6
2 DF Kyle Walker 7
5 DF John Stones 5
7 MF Raheem Sterling 7.5
8 MF İlkay Gündoğan 6
9 FW Gabriel Jesus 7
10 FW Sergio Agüero 7
11 MF Oleksandr Zinchenko 6
14 DF Aymeric Laporte Can’t really score
16 MF Rodri 6
17 MF Kevin De Bruyne 8.5
19 MF Leroy Sané N/A
20 MF Bernardo Silva 6
21 MF David Silva 6.5
22 DF Benjamin Mendy 6
25 MF Fernandinho 7.5
26 MF Riyad Mahrez 6.5
27 DF João Cancelo 5.5
30 DF Nicolás Otamendi 6
31 GK Ederson 6
33 GK Scott Carson N/A
47 MF Phil Foden 6.5
50 DF Eric García 6

 

[jimmygrimblesboots]

I'm bored and wondering how people would rate our player's seasons in what has been a relatively dissapointing season. We don't know if the season has ended or not, but as I say I'm bored.

I've probably given quite harsh marks, but I'm holding to the high standards of 17/18 & 18/19. If the season resumed and we added the Champions League and FA Cup to the League Cup I'd look like a bit of a twat for these ratings I guess.


1 GK Claudio Bravo 6
2 DF Kyle Walker 7
5 DF John Stones 4
7 MF Raheem Sterling 8
8 MF İlkay Gündoğan 7
9 FW Gabriel Jesus 7
10 FW Sergio Agüero 8
11 MF Oleksandr Zinchenko 6
14 DF Aymeric Laporte 7
16 MF Rodri 7
17 MF Kevin De Bruyne 9
19 MF Leroy Sané N/A
20 MF Bernardo Silva 6
21 MF David Silva 6
22 DF Benjamin Mendy 6
25 MF Fernandinho 8
26 MF Riyad Mahrez 7
27 DF João Cancelo 5
30 DF Nicolás Otamendi 6
31 GK Ederson 7
33 GK Scott Carson N/A
47 MF Phil Foden 7
50 DF Eric García 6

We have won two trophies and were virtually in the last eight of two more competitions and favourites to win both , the Dippers freak VAR assisted season has to be put into context , we are a brilliant team and on our day with a referee who made the correct decisions we would stuff the Dippers every time. The only time they beat us is when a referee hands the victory on a plate.

 

[mccity]

Walker 6.9

 

[ninjamonkey]

I’m working off the basis that a 5 is actually average and not 7 that seems to be the norm.

1 GK Claudio Bravo 6
2 DF Kyle Walker 8
5 DF John Stones 4
7 MF Raheem Sterling 7
8 MF İlkay Gündoğan 7
9 FW Gabriel Jesus 7
10 FW Sergio Agüero 8
11 MF Oleksandr Zinchenko 5
14 DF Aymeric Laporte - n/a
16 MF Rodri 4
17 MF Kevin De Bruyne 9
19 MF Leroy Sané - n/a
20 MF Bernardo Silva 6
21 MF David Silva 6
22 DF Benjamin Mendy 6
25 MF Fernandinho 7
26 MF Riyad Mahrez 8
27 DF João Cancelo 4
30 DF Nicolás Otamendi 5
31 GK Ederson 7
33 GK Scott Carson -n/a
47 MF Phil Foden 6
50 DF Eric García 5

Problem with our season has been too many 6/7’s with players only marginally better than the minimum expected and not enough 8/9’s and none of our summer signings have bedded in as we would have hoped.

 

[Esteban de la Sexface]

Very harsh on Rodri.

He's a terrific player. I bet he was signed to play alongside Dinho and learn the league, instead he's been asked to learn the league while being the main holding player at the club

He will be one of the best players in the clubs history

Having gundogan ahead of rodri is a farce. Rodri has as many goals as him and gundogan doesn't tackle (refuses to do so) or contest aerial challenges (refuses to do so)

 

[Stoned Rose]

The scores for Foden are a disgrace blues.

The kid has been magnificent whenever he's played.

 

[Stoned Rose]

Very harsh on Rodri.

He's a terrific player. I bet he was signed to play alongside Dinho and learn the league, instead he's been asked to learn the league while being the main holding player at the club

He will be one of the best players in the clubs history

Having gundogan ahead of rodri is a farce. Rodri has as many goals as him and gundogan doesn't tackle (refuses to do so) or contest aerial challenges (refuses to do so)

Javi Garcia reminisces to this post.