Season Ratings

[IcelandicBlue]

Well, sounds like a good idea for a thread.

Basically just rate first team players' seasons from 0-10

No. Pos. Player
2 DF Micah Richards - 8
4 DF Vincent Kompany (captain) -9
5 DF Pablo Zabaleta - 8
6 DF Joleon Lescott - 9
7 MF James Milner - 7
10 FW Edin Džeko - 7 (Brilliant runs of form but no real stability)
11 MF Adam Johnson - 5
13 DF Aleksandar Kolarov - 6
15 DF Stefan Savić - 5
16 FW Sergio Agüero - 9
18 MF Gareth Barry - 9
19 MF Samir Nasri - 7,5
20 MF Owen Hargreaves - 4
21 MF David Silva - 8
22 DF Gaël Clichy - 8
25 GK Joe Hart - 9
28 DF Kolo Touré - 6
30 GK Costel Pantilimon - 5 (Not played enough games to get a higher rating)
32 FW Carlos Tévez - 6,5 (Has been brilliant since he came back but...)
34 MF Nigel de Jong - 6
42 MF Yaya Touré - 9
45 FW Mario Balotelli - 7,5
Roberto Mancini - 9

 

[WNRH]

Johnson and de Jong too low, Nasri to high, apart from that i agree.

 

[Monkfish]

No. Pos. Player
2 DF Micah Richards - 8 ...7
4 DF Vincent Kompany (captain) -9 ...9
5 DF Pablo Zabaleta - 8 ...8
6 DF Joleon Lescott - 9 ...8
7 MF James Milner - 7 ...7
10 FW Edin Džeko - 7 ...6
11 MF Adam Johnson - 5 ...6
13 DF Aleksandar Kolarov - 6 ...6
15 DF Stefan Savić - 5 ...2
16 FW Sergio Agüero - 9 ...9
18 MF Gareth Barry - 9 ...8
19 MF Samir Nasri - 7,5 ...7
20 MF Owen Hargreaves - 4 ...5
21 MF David Silva - 8 ...8
22 DF Gaël Clichy - 8 ...8
25 GK Joe Hart - 9 ...8
28 DF Kolo Touré - 6 ...6
30 GK Costel Pantilimon - 5 ...5
32 FW Carlos Tévez - 6,5 ...5
34 MF Nigel de Jong - 6 ...5
42 MF Yaya Touré - 9 ...9
45 FW Mario Balotelli - 7,5 ...6
Roberto Mancini - 9 ...8

 

[BlueMooner87]

I am going to be a bit more harsh as how you can give owen hargreaves 4 is amazing, its a season rating so I am taking into consideration how much input they have had.

No. Pos. Player
2 DF Micah Richards - 7.5
4 DF Vincent Kompany (captain) -10
5 DF Pablo Zabaleta - 8
6 DF Joleon Lescott - 9.5
7 MF James Milner - 6.5
10 FW Edin Džeko - 7
11 MF Adam Johnson - 3
13 DF Aleksandar Kolarov - 6
15 DF Stefan Savić - 2
16 FW Sergio Agüero - 10
18 MF Gareth Barry - 9.5
19 MF Samir Nasri - 8
20 MF Owen Hargreaves - 0
21 MF David Silva - 9
22 DF Gaël Clichy - 8
25 GK Joe Hart - 10
28 DF Kolo Touré - 3
30 GK Costel Pantilimon - 1
32 FW Carlos Tévez -
34 MF Nigel de Jong - 7.5
42 MF Yaya Touré - 9.5
45 FW Mario Balotelli - 8
Roberto Mancini - 10

 

[kun]

No. Pos. Player
2 DF Micah Richards - 8
4 DF Vincent Kompany (captain) - 9.5
5 DF Pablo Zabaleta - 7
6 DF Joleon Lescott - 8.5
7 MF James Milner - 6.5
10 FW Edin Džeko - 6.5
11 MF Adam Johnson - 6
13 DF Aleksandar Kolarov - 5
15 DF Stefan Savić - 5
16 FW Sergio Agüero - 9
18 MF Gareth Barry - 8
19 MF Samir Nasri - 6.5
20 MF Owen Hargreaves - 2
21 MF David Silva - 8.5
22 DF Gaël Clichy - 7.5
25 GK Joe Hart - 9
28 DF Kolo Touré - 5
30 GK Costel Pantilimon - 2
32 FW Carlos Tévez - 6.5
34 MF Nigel de Jong - 6
42 MF Yaya Touré - 9
45 FW Mario Balotelli - 6.5
Roberto Mancini - 10

 

[CTID96]

No. Pos. Player
2 DF Micah Richards - 8
4 DF Vincent Kompany (captain) - 9.5
5 DF Pablo Zabaleta - 7
6 DF Joleon Lescott - 8.5
7 MF James Milner - 7
10 FW Edin Džeko - 7
11 MF Adam Johnson - 6
13 DF Aleksandar Kolarov - 6
15 DF Stefan Savić - 5
16 FW Sergio Agüero - 9
18 MF Gareth Barry - 8
19 MF Samir Nasri - 7
20 MF Owen Hargreaves - 2
21 MF David Silva - 8.5
22 DF Gaël Clichy - 8
25 GK Joe Hart - 9
28 DF Kolo Touré - 5
30 GK Costel Pantilimon - 5
32 FW Carlos Tévez - 6.5
34 MF Nigel de Jong - 6
42 MF Yaya Touré - 9
45 FW Mario Balotelli - 7
Roberto Mancini - 10

 

[stumpy_mcfc]

No. Pos. Player
2 DF Micah Richards - 8
4 DF Vincent Kompany (captain) - 9
5 DF Pablo Zabaleta - 7.5
6 DF Joleon Lescott - 8.5
7 MF James Milner - 7
10 FW Edin Džeko - 7
11 MF Adam Johnson - 6
13 DF Aleksandar Kolarov - 6
15 DF Stefan Savić - 4
16 FW Sergio Agüero - 9
18 MF Gareth Barry - 8
19 MF Samir Nasri - 7
20 MF Owen Hargreaves - 1
21 MF David Silva - 8.5
22 DF Gaël Clichy - 8
25 GK Joe Hart - 9
28 DF Kolo Touré - 6
30 GK Costel Pantilimon - 5
32 FW Carlos Tévez - 6
34 MF Nigel de Jong - 7.5
42 MF Yaya Touré - 9
45 FW Mario Balotelli - 7
Roberto Mancini - 10

 

[jakarta]

Yaya 9.5 good passing good vision good attitude colossus in midfield. Multi role player i have ever seen.