I dont want to distract from the amazing effort and show last night that brought Manchester together in front of the world and the great comments in the other thread so just as a discussion and some fun debate, should Noel have joined Liam onstage last night? Im cold light of day I can see both sides of the arguement. As other Blues have said it was bigger than a Oasis reunion but also if this was the time to show Manchester and the world about healing, unity and coming together that was the moment. I fear these brothers will never get past there problems. What do you think fellow Bluemooners?