The Album Review Club - Week #128 - (page 1587) - Pretty Vicious - The Struts

Well, my Maggie Rogers pick stumped everyone but very few liked it. It’s from a bit ago (2018?) but I heard it for the first time this year on my wife’s playlist and fell in love with it. There’s something about catchy, carefully-crafted earworm pop that really appeals to me — Vanessa Carlton’s “A Thousand Miles” from 20 years ago with its insane piano hook is another one I just can’t get over.
Hey, I gave you an enjoyable live ACL link here a few pages back, and we both barely made each other's top 10, so I don't know what else you could possibly want here? ;-)

Your song is from 2019, so given that one strike from me, you should be impressed it beat out Chocolate Samurai and Troglodyte for the limited space I had left for an oldie! :-)

I figured someone with your vast music catalog that you'd be choosing something current, so you got me good in 2023. As Montgomery Burns would say, "I'll remember that" for next year.

As always a lot of fun and I wish I’d had time to research some guesses — hopefully 2024 brings a bit more free time. Happy New Year Bluetune — I mean, Bluemoon!
Happy New Year, and hoping for a bit more of the same!
 
Hey, I gave you an enjoyable live ACL link here a few pages back, and we both barely made each other's top 10, so I don't know what else you could possibly want here? ;-)

Your song is from 2019, so given that one strike from me, you should be impressed it beat out Chocolate Samurai and Troglodyte for the limited space I had left for an oldie! :-)

I figured someone with your vast music catalog that you'd be choosing something current, so you got me good in 2023. As Montgomery Burns would say, "I'll remember that" for next year.


Happy New Year, and hoping for a bit more of the same!
I saw that — I liked that ACL clip but couldn’t “like” it for fear of giving away my pick :)

As I’ve noted, I don’t have much time for “new” music — so much of what I pick up in a year is older music that is new to me, and 80% comes from this thread or my wife! The other 20% is from my kids, random stuff I hear places and Shazam, or browsing music criticism.

Happy new year to you too — great to have your contributions here this year!
 
I’ve got quite abroad taste but Americana and singer song writers being my particular faves, so my closest contributors on here would be Rob ,B&W&BMT,and Bennyboy who also shares my distaste for Rush! i think I’ve been to quite a few gigs OB1 has been to, Sadds2 for his love of Springsteen ,Foggy for his American indie.but special mention to Coatigan for introducing me to Frightened Rabbit nice and dour lol
Dour.Never.Happy New Year everybody.
 
I saw that — I liked that ACL clip but couldn’t “like” it for fear of giving away my pick :)
No worries on missing the "like" on the link, but for full disclosure I had already submitted and pegged @LGWIO for your selection. That will teach me to read too much into his prior "Super Shy" reference and not knowing any new material in 2023. That clicked 2 for 2 boxes in your song department! So how could I possibly miss now?

As I’ve noted, I don’t have much time for “new” music — so much of what I pick up in a year is older music that is new to me, and 80% comes from this thread or my wife! The other 20% is from my kids, random stuff I hear places and Shazam, or browsing music criticism.

Happy new year to you too — great to have your contributions here this year!
The New Year has just landed for our mates across the pond, so after a nice takeout meal here, it is family time now.
 
Wouldn't mind hearing about this now, as I was still wondering on the back catalog given I couldn't guess your track. Viagra Boys?

On that last note, I immediately thought of my nomination.

It wouldn't surprise me as I know of Jason Isbell fans who will skip over that track on his new album for the same reason.

I do like his 2023 album Weathervanes, but it isn't my favorite of his and not even as good as his last few ones of original material, IMO.

However, there wasn't a more powerful song I heard in 2023 that moved me as much as this one did that has stayed with me weeks and months after first hearing it. Did I think it would win? No. But I did think it important to not deny its overall effect on me.

Other artists, including Drive-By Truckers, have written songs about the mass shooting epidemic in the US, but Jason's is quite different.

In “Guns of Umpqua”, the DBT address it from the point of view of someone simply going about their day and thinking about their weekend past before the unexpected. In “Thoughts and Prayers”, they specifically call out those in power that do nothing but repeat the same old sentiments with no action or resolve to listen to consider any possible change.

Here, Jason's lyrics and the music go hand in hand from the viewpoint of a parent. This anxiety is something most any parent can relate to as it pertains to the safety of their kids and their feeling of overall helplessness at times. The guitar chords on the verses have that anxiousness feeling that really sets the mood of the song. On the chorus, it is a straightforward rocker from the 400 Unit that drives the point right home in a plea to his spouse to help him when he's not strong enough. It isn't the first time he's asked for help in overcoming his past battles with alcoholism and his current years of sobriety.

The song overall is one of this relationship with his spouse and for needing the help in not being able to do it alone on such a subject. Something we all need at times if concerned we'll lose our grip.

I'll end it with this excerpt from Jason himself in this interview about his album, as well as an alternate acoustic version of the song I found very touching as well.


As the link notes:
Isbell wrote "Save the World" last year after 19 children were killed in Uvalde, Texas.

It's a dive into a modern parent's simmering mental illness, in which every busted balloon makes us jump, and we have our phones alerting us to school shootings while Elmo's on our TV singing of sunny days, and somehow we're supposed to keep hope in the space between.
  • I’m still dreaming in my heart of hearts / but something's changing in my head.
  • And later: Something's drowning out the light.
Isbell compares his feelings for the song to John Prine's for "Sam Stone," about a drug-addicted veteran.

"It's a catch-22 for a songwriter. You try to write songs that resonate with people. But if you're writing about things that are societal problems, you hope that those songs won't hold up."

Of course, it held up.

In March, long after he recorded "Save the World," but about two months before he would release it, three children and three staff members were killed at The Covenant School in Nashville, not far from Isbell’s home.

I asked whether the song's meaning changed for him after that. It did, he said, but …
  • "Something happening in your backyard shouldn't feel any different than it happening on the other side of the world. It all sucks," he said. "I think we've gotten to a point where a lot of people in America, unless they see something with their own eyes, have a hard time empathizing with people who are directly involved in it."
My thought bubble: For the past couple of weeks I've been playing my preview copy of "Weathervanes" for my son on the way to day care. We skip that song. Sorry, Jason.

An acoustic version if interested:



One final thought from me on a positive and thankful note:

Happy New Year to all the Blue Moon Album reviewers. Much appreciated on the music you've shared in this thread this year and prior. Hoping you have safe celebrations tonight and looking forward to 2024 with some interesting albums to come in January!

I do like this song but not having children it doesn’t resonate as much as it would
If I did and lived in the US permanently.
 
Well, my Maggie Rogers pick stumped everyone but very few liked it. It’s from a bit ago (2018?) but I heard it for the first time this year on my wife’s playlist and fell in love with it. There’s something about catchy, carefully-crafted earworm pop that really appeals to me — Vanessa Carlton’s “A Thousand Miles” from 20 years ago with its insane piano hook is another one I just can’t get over.

As for my top ten:

1. Water Underground
2. The Trench Coat Museum
3. Where The Devil Don’t Stay
4. Dance In The Desert
5. Troglodyte
6. Tropic Morning News
7. RISE
8. Chocolate Samurai
9. Save The World
10. Sunshine in 1929

I really, really dug that Real Estate tune and since then have listened to another dozen of their songs. They’re from New Jersey, like my beloved Fountains of Wayne, but have been compared to yet another fantastic New Jersey band from many moons ago, The Feelies. It is an absolute crime that The Feelies’ brilliant “Only Life” record from the late 80s is not on Spotify — imagine the Byrds meet the Velvet Underground and you just about have it.

Elsewhere I was a big fan of that Yard Act tune and unsurprised by the fine DBT effort (I’ve heard little from them I don’t really enjoy). As noted I did think the Pigs thing was a Black Sabbath rip-off and was hoping Ian Hunter (and his All-Stars) would have done something a little less, I don’t know, traditional? Bog standard? It was more disappointing than dislikable I guess.

As always a lot of fun and I wish I’d had time to research some guesses — hopefully 2024 brings a bit more free time. Happy New Year Bluetune — I mean, Bluemoon!

Well, my Maggie Rogers pick stumped everyone but very few liked it. It’s from a bit ago (2018?) but I heard it for the first time this year on my wife’s playlist and fell in love with it. There’s something about catchy, carefully-crafted earworm pop that really appeals to me — Vanessa Carlton’s “A Thousand Miles” from 20 years ago with its insane piano hook is another one I just can’t get over.

As for my top ten:

1. Water Underground
2. The Trench Coat Museum
3. Where The Devil Don’t Stay
4. Dance In The Desert
5. Troglodyte
6. Tropic Morning News
7. RISE
8. Chocolate Samurai
9. Save The World
10. Sunshine in 1929

I really, really dug that Real Estate tune and since then have listened to another dozen of their songs. They’re from New Jersey, like my beloved Fountains of Wayne, but have been compared to yet another fantastic New Jersey band from many moons ago, The Feelies. It is an absolute crime that The Feelies’ brilliant “Only Life” record from the late 80s is not on Spotify — imagine the Byrds meet the Velvet Underground and you just about have it.

Elsewhere I was a big fan of that Yard Act tune and unsurprised by the fine DBT effort (I’ve heard little from them I don’t really enjoy). As noted I did think the Pigs thing was a Black Sabbath rip-off and was hoping Ian Hunter (and his All-Stars) would have done something a little less, I don’t know, traditional? Bog standard? It was more disappointing than dislikable I guess.

As always a lot of fun and I wish I’d had time to research some guesses — hopefully 2024 brings a bit more free time. Happy New Year Bluetune — I mean, Bluemoon!
Interesting when you mentioned there was a track which you thought was a rip off, I thought you might be referring to Real Estate as the lead vocalists sounds a lot like Chris Collingwood of FOW although the lyrics don't have the humour of FOW a band I also love. I Know of the Feelies but not heard much by them but I will definitely investigate, Byrds meet the VU what’s not to like.
 
I found that too on the Song Cup. Great minds! ;-)


I knew who I hit the post with, but narrowing yours down was tougher than anticipated! In my pre-prediction to Rob, I selected the "Cast Iron Skillet" track.

Two swings and misses for me. I just took the heaviest track and gave it to OB1 once out of clear options. I had RISE for homerdog as I believe I found that in another obscure thread, so I knew OB1 wasn't giving me a Clarkie on his discussion of that one.

Yeah, I got that one from the playlist thread too.

Happy New Year as well!
I knew who I hit the post with, but narrowing yours down was tougher than anticipated! In my pre-prediction to Rob, I selected the "Cast Iron Skillet" track.

Not a bad shout as that’s one of my favourites from the album.
 
I knew who I hit the post with, but narrowing yours down was tougher than anticipated! In my pre-prediction to Rob, I selected the "Cast Iron Skillet" track.

Not a bad shout as that’s one of my favourites from the album.
Wow, that's a bit more than hitting the post with the track bullseye to boot!

Happy New Year all officially now in EST. We leave Foggy still in 2023 for now. ;-)
 
Well, my Maggie Rogers pick stumped everyone but very few liked it. It’s from a bit ago (2018?) but I heard it for the first time this year on my wife’s playlist and fell in love with it. There’s something about catchy, carefully-crafted earworm pop that really appeals to me — Vanessa Carlton’s “A Thousand Miles” from 20 years ago with its insane piano hook is another one I just can’t get over.

As for my top ten:

1. Water Underground
2. The Trench Coat Museum
3. Where The Devil Don’t Stay
4. Dance In The Desert
5. Troglodyte
6. Tropic Morning News
7. RISE
8. Chocolate Samurai
9. Save The World
10. Sunshine in 1929

I really, really dug that Real Estate tune and since then have listened to another dozen of their songs. They’re from New Jersey, like my beloved Fountains of Wayne, but have been compared to yet another fantastic New Jersey band from many moons ago, The Feelies. It is an absolute crime that The Feelies’ brilliant “Only Life” record from the late 80s is not on Spotify — imagine the Byrds meet the Velvet Underground and you just about have it.

Elsewhere I was a big fan of that Yard Act tune and unsurprised by the fine DBT effort (I’ve heard little from them I don’t really enjoy). As noted I did think the Pigs thing was a Black Sabbath rip-off and was hoping Ian Hunter (and his All-Stars) would have done something a little less, I don’t know, traditional? Bog standard? It was more disappointing than dislikable I guess.

As always a lot of fun and I wish I’d had time to research some guesses — hopefully 2024 brings a bit more free time. Happy New Year Bluetune — I mean, Bluemoon!

I Was actually intrigued enough by your Maggie Rodgers pick, to explore her stuff more. Which is what led me to the Kississippi comparison, which I think is worth checking out, if you are into that Chvrches meets Swift type of thing.

Speaking of your 1000 miles song, here is a chance to see it in a slightly different light. More 'fun' than good, but a bit of fun is always good.


Finally I do suggest you give the little set of circa 5 Viagra Boys songs I mentioned earlier a spin in a onner. As someone who likes 'music to move to', I challenge you to stay still with a couple of those.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.