You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
The Album Review Club - Christmas Break Until 8th January
- Thread starter RobMCFC
- Start date
Wayneclarkemunchescarrots
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 7 Aug 2019
- Messages
- 131
- Team supported
- City
It is an 8 out of 10 score for me . It’s a superb album but it’s behind probably 5 other charlatans album for me . Such as some friendly , up to our hips and between the 10th and 11th .
Liked oasis and the stone roses in patches around this time and for my musical tastes the charlatans outlasted both by a long way in quality and longevity.
Liked oasis and the stone roses in patches around this time and for my musical tastes the charlatans outlasted both by a long way in quality and longevity.
OB1
Well-Known Member
I will check that album out too.Glad you enjoyed it. If there's time in the crowded listening space, I can recommend the album that came after this - Us and Us Only. There are times on that that the Dylan influence is even more apparent but they mix it up to good effect. Like I said in my review, it's a toss-up for which of these albums is the better.
OB1
Well-Known Member
It's really not.That's like saying Pep's influence on Steve Clarke is obvious, but his football is not like Pep's.
Liam's phrasing at times is Lennonesque but he sings in a Manc accent so they sound very different.
Mad Eyed Screamer
Moderator
A part of Get it on? Lol it's the whole basis of Cigarettes & AlcoholThere is a part of "Get On It" that sounds a bit like Oasis but that's being picky.
It's really not.
Liam's phrasing at times is Lennonesque but he sings in a Manc accent so they sound very different.
It was more a comment/comparison of quality.
'Yes yes, we get it, you don't like Oasis coat!'
Back to the album at hand, sorry everyone.
BimboBob
Well-Known Member
First listen.
It's a wall of weirdly produced noise with what sounds like a poor oasis tribute act singing over the top. I googled them, turns out they are from Birmingham.
11 songs all sounding the same apart from the rubbish end one and one in the middle that was a bit slower. I'll delve into that more when I listen again.
Not that I want to listen again really as it's quite dire. But 3 listens is what I give all of these albums and three listens it shall get. God help my ears.
It's a wall of weirdly produced noise with what sounds like a poor oasis tribute act singing over the top. I googled them, turns out they are from Birmingham.
11 songs all sounding the same apart from the rubbish end one and one in the middle that was a bit slower. I'll delve into that more when I listen again.
Not that I want to listen again really as it's quite dire. But 3 listens is what I give all of these albums and three listens it shall get. God help my ears.
I'll just go now while he pain is still fresh from bimbo ripping the plaster off.
Not for me, too oasisy, and I can't see past that. Sorry. I acknowledge some decent riffs and intent, but ultimately it is one of those, you either like it or don't.
One to another and Area 51 have a bit more to them than most oasis songs, but the rest I could have been convinced was a new reunion release.
Sorry. Credit for the surprise Rob, and gong off piste. But if I am being honest, which you'd likely want me to be, it is a 3, based on my tastes.
Not for me, too oasisy, and I can't see past that. Sorry. I acknowledge some decent riffs and intent, but ultimately it is one of those, you either like it or don't.
One to another and Area 51 have a bit more to them than most oasis songs, but the rest I could have been convinced was a new reunion release.
Sorry. Credit for the surprise Rob, and gong off piste. But if I am being honest, which you'd likely want me to be, it is a 3, based on my tastes.
A fine choice to lay before us all here Rob.
As I think I have mentioned before, one of my fave gigs was Charlatans at The Boston Arms Pub, in Tufnell Park. Back then so much energy to them and somethign that little bit different from what was out there. This choice has made me go back and revisit and does make me wonder why I dont spend more time with them.
I think for the overall variety and muscianship I think the Northwich boys are way ahead of the Burnage boys
As I think I have mentioned before, one of my fave gigs was Charlatans at The Boston Arms Pub, in Tufnell Park. Back then so much energy to them and somethign that little bit different from what was out there. This choice has made me go back and revisit and does make me wonder why I dont spend more time with them.
I think for the overall variety and muscianship I think the Northwich boys are way ahead of the Burnage boys
mrbelfry
Well-Known Member
The Charlatans are a more swampy southern (USA) roots rock band than Oasis to me. I don't know what the official genre is called. The guitar tone and the way it's played plus the organ sounds make it quite distinct in this era I think - like I said in my review they are a proper grown up band. I can't think of any Oasis song that grooves like Area 51 - actually the Charlatans do swing way more than Oasis.
Burgess' vocals have some of the same nasal inflections and elongated syllables as Liam G but the Charlatans predate Oasis so Burgess came first.
Burgess' vocals have some of the same nasal inflections and elongated syllables as Liam G but the Charlatans predate Oasis so Burgess came first.