Saddleworth2
Well-Known Member
You have just put me off the stuff.Aye they had that one in an episode of Friends at thanksgiving once!
Friends music and now Friends food. The buggers get everywhere.
You have just put me off the stuff.Aye they had that one in an episode of Friends at thanksgiving once!
As I’ve said before, I’m not too adventurous with food, but I have enjoyed the Andalusian Gazpacho a few times this week (even though we are in the People’s Republic of Catalunya).Somewhere in Spain @RobMCFC has suddenly inexplicably got the urge to nip to his nearest eatooterie for some berenjenas con miel..
Edit. Fun story, I did once confuse my berenjenas and my boquerones on a spanish menu! Expected aubergine, got fash!
As I’ve said before, I’m not too adventurous with food, but I have enjoyed the Andalusian Gazpacho a few times this week (even though we are in the People’s Republic of Catalunya).
love the line “If you don’t expect too much from me / You might not be let down”. In fact it neatly summarizes my view of this record.
Ha, sorry mate!Well that's me having to think of something else for the first sentence of my review.
First, let’s get this out of the way — I LIKE “Friends.” I watched it for a few seasons. I thought the premise was silly but the actors had good chemistry and often great comic timing. Sure, the guys are generally moany gimps and women slinky neurotic space cadets, and it’s no Bob Newhart Show or Cheers or Seinfeld. But it really was some harmless fun.
This record, darker undercurrents not withstanding, isn’t as good as “Friends” but has a few songs that are quite strong and one IMO that is great. I buy the argument that a reasonable portion is pretty slushy and generic. It’s why I don’t play this record much in an age when I can cut out the best tracks and keep the rest unplayed in the cloud.
What I hear here is REM guitar not as well played, not as creative and 6-10 years too late to matter. But it’s good enough that with snappy hi-hat/snare and a reasonable series of bass lines it gets by more often than not, especially on songs like Allison Road and Until I Fall Away.
But the masterpiece here is Found Out About You, in part because of the terrific schoolboy-obsessive lyrics but, musically, because of the choral harmonies, which for some odd reason only seem employed in this song and the opener Lost Horizons, which I also like. Now I can see the artists being worried that over employing such harmonies might render them one-note, but I think a number of songs here suffer without them.
Hey Jealousy is the big hit and I do enjoy it too, and love the line “If you don’t expect too much from me / You might not be let down”. In fact it neatly summarizes my view of this record. Things like the countrified Cajun Song and Cheatin’ overtax this band’s ability to be tuneful. The rest of the songs I didn’t mention I didn’t mention because they aren’t in the least memorable. So I don’t expect too much. And am rewarded with 4-5 songs that together would have made a fine EP. Under normal circumstances such a record would be a steady 6, but because the best one is so good and the good ones quite good, we will forgive the wheat the chaff and go 7/10.
Both out in September I believe.On a side note previous nominations who haven't released anything for a while in Grant Lee Phillips and Josh Ritter release new albums in September and November respectively if anyone wants to see where they've ended up
Given that Foggy has already got his revenge for me nicking 1980 on the other thread by nabbing the best line about this album, I’m going to veer off on a tangent — blame @Coatigan 's Del Amitri musings, @Black&White&BlueMoon Town 's Toad the Wet Sprocket nod, @Saddleworth2's Counting Crows reference, and the whole Friends-music debate.
The cliché says Americans are brash and over-expressive, while the British are emotionally repressed. If that’s true, how come there’s this entire flavour of intelligent, emotionally restrained American music—exemplified by the above—that completely dies on its arse over here? To us it often reads as bland, middle of the road. IMO there's a few reasons:
Thinking of other thread picks, Jimmy Eat World (fellow Arizonans) share some DNA with Gin Blossoms, but they’re easier for a British audience to “get.” They take that earnestness and attach it to something more dynamic and cathartic—tense, heavier guitars, a bit of a Biffy like release. Gin Blossoms ask you to accept something else: melancholy without disguise and without drama. If you don’t make that adjustment to your frame of reference, you’re left hearing “Friends music” in an American accent.
- Accent matters. Especially with more subtle, emotionally restrained music—Justin Currie sounds familiar, so his melancholy feels authentic.
- Production polish. UK alt/indie tends to exhibit more roughness round the edges, often political or socially edged. US “alt” can sound so polished it squeaks. Too clean for it's own good to our ears.
- Cultural cues. “Gentlemen, time please you know we can't serve anymore” is something we understand in our marrow. I’ve never been to Tempe, Arizona, but I’ve been to enough American suburbs to know their version of ‘nothing ever happens’ often comes with heat haze and wide roads that create a sense of space that can be paradoxically suffocating. These different reference points birth different types of songs, there's a reason driving songs are a bigger deal there.
- Emotional directness. This is the big one IMO. Ignoring clichés, I think it's fair to say Americans tend to be more emotionally direct. Brits, we might not be repressed but we are obtuse. We wrap the emotions in a veil, a dry aside, a raised eyebrow. Or conversely, almost as if in the grip of the inferior, we go big on them. Gin Blossoms are thoughtful, but totally straightforward and completely sincere. There’s no Pulp-style smirk, no Morrissey melodrama, no ambiguity. Just plain melancholy. It's pretty alien to us and to some ears, reads as naïve, or even worse: sentimental.
So where does that leave this album? I actually think there's two very different ways of reading it depending on how you take the juxtaposition between the lyrical content and the music.
The more benign version is that, once you shift your frame of reference, the emotional directness is part of the charm. These songs have a softness or gentleness I’ve come to appreciate. It’s catchy, melodic jangle-pop with a summery lilt, but shot through with a wistfulness, even sadness that never tips into angst. The tales of emotional drift, failed relationships, lost loves—they’re there without any artifice or cleverness, but are carried by music that keeps them from collapsing into self-pity.
The much darker reading is that the contrast between the jangle pop and the content is actually pretty disturbing. That reading says the plainspoken melancholy isn't gentle acceptance of what life sometimes throws at you or that it's ok to sit with those feelings. The jangle pop is essentially a mask to hide the numbness, the jealousy and the self-sabotage. the fact that it's done seemingly without angst hints at either resignation or despair or ironically even repressed rage. Maybe this reading doesn't really exist without Doug Hopkins sad story, but whichever way you cut it a track like Found Out About You has a catchily unsettling quality to it which is one of the reasons I think it stands out.
Overall I lean towards the former rather than latter view of what's going on but either way I’m with Doogle in that it’s a pretty consistent album, apart from “Cajun Song” and “Cheatin’” which do let the side down pretty badly imo. I'm probably in a minority of one here but it's sufficiently 'other' in it's approach to it's feeling that I find it almost exotic rather than bland. So that'll be 8/10 from the threads most generous scorer.
Grant Lee Philips on Friday.Both out in September I believe.
Well, thank you for explaing to me why I like one band over another, aye! Want to tell me why I prefer fried to boiled gnocci as well mate? ;).
Tbh, enjoyed that, and the only one I disagree with is the accent. For one, Currie sings with a quasi American accent of some fashion, which kinda always did and didn't bother me. But have to say I prefer it to singing in overly stressed/forced British accents. Otherwise, vslid points and observations. Don't think it applies that universally, as there are so many US bands I love. Just no country pish!
An excellent and well written review. Quite brilliant in fact. Loved it.Given that Foggy has already got his revenge for me nicking 1980 on the other thread by nabbing the best line about this album, I’m going to veer off on a tangent — blame @Coatigan 's Del Amitri musings, @Black&White&BlueMoon Town 's Toad the Wet Sprocket nod, @Saddleworth2's Counting Crows reference, and the whole Friends-music debate.
The cliché says Americans are brash and over-expressive, while the British are emotionally repressed. If that’s true, how come there’s this entire flavour of intelligent, emotionally restrained American music—exemplified by the above—that completely dies on its arse over here? To us it often reads as bland, middle of the road. IMO there's a few reasons:
Thinking of other thread picks, Jimmy Eat World (fellow Arizonans) share some DNA with Gin Blossoms, but they’re easier for a British audience to “get.” They take that earnestness and attach it to something more dynamic and cathartic—tense, heavier guitars, a bit of a Biffy like release. Gin Blossoms ask you to accept something else: melancholy without disguise and without drama. If you don’t make that adjustment to your frame of reference, you’re left hearing “Friends music” in an American accent.
- Accent matters. Especially with more subtle, emotionally restrained music—Justin Currie sounds familiar, so his melancholy feels authentic.
- Production polish. UK alt/indie tends to exhibit more roughness round the edges, often political or socially edged. US “alt” can sound so polished it squeaks. Too clean for it's own good to our ears.
- Cultural cues. “Gentlemen, time please you know we can't serve anymore” is something we understand in our marrow. I’ve never been to Tempe, Arizona, but I’ve been to enough American suburbs to know their version of ‘nothing ever happens’ often comes with heat haze and wide roads that create a sense of space that can be paradoxically suffocating. These different reference points birth different types of songs, there's a reason driving songs are a bigger deal there.
- Emotional directness. This is the big one IMO. Ignoring clichés, I think it's fair to say Americans tend to be more emotionally direct. Brits, we might not be repressed but we are obtuse. We wrap the emotions in a veil, a dry aside, a raised eyebrow. Or conversely, almost as if in the grip of the inferior, we go big on them. Gin Blossoms are thoughtful, but totally straightforward and completely sincere. There’s no Pulp-style smirk, no Morrissey melodrama, no ambiguity. Just plain melancholy. It's pretty alien to us and to some ears, reads as naïve, or even worse: sentimental.
So where does that leave this album? I actually think there's two very different ways of reading it depending on how you take the juxtaposition between the lyrical content and the music.
The more benign version is that, once you shift your frame of reference, the emotional directness is part of the charm. These songs have a softness or gentleness I’ve come to appreciate. It’s catchy, melodic jangle-pop with a summery lilt, but shot through with a wistfulness, even sadness that never tips into angst. The tales of emotional drift, failed relationships, lost loves—they’re there without any artifice or cleverness, but are carried by music that keeps them from collapsing into self-pity.
The much darker reading is that the contrast between the jangle pop and the content is actually pretty disturbing. That reading says the plainspoken melancholy isn't gentle acceptance of what life sometimes throws at you or that it's ok to sit with those feelings. The jangle pop is essentially a mask to hide the numbness, the jealousy and the self-sabotage. the fact that it's done seemingly without angst hints at either resignation or despair or ironically even repressed rage. Maybe this reading doesn't really exist without Doug Hopkins sad story, but whichever way you cut it a track like Found Out About You has a catchily unsettling quality to it which is one of the reasons I think it stands out.
Overall I lean towards the former rather than latter view of what's going on but either way I’m with Doogle in that it’s a pretty consistent album, apart from “Cajun Song” and “Cheatin’” which do let the side down pretty badly imo. I'm probably in a minority of one here but it's sufficiently 'other' in it's approach to it's feeling that I find it almost exotic rather than bland. So that'll be 8/10 from the threads most generous scorer.