The Album Review Club - Week #195 (page 1310) - A New World Record - ELO

My nomination is for an old timer who along with Elvis, Chuck Berry, Little Richard and others created the genre we'd know today as rock'n'roll.

Not only did they help to create the genre, they were one of the first to create the idea that a rock front men is wild, dangerous and out of control. And quite honestly, they don't come more dangerous than this man. Multiple marriages, wives dying in controversial circumstances, marrying his 13-year old cousin, drink problems, drug problems, prison and shootings. Not many could match this wildman of rock and back in the 50s it must have been absolutely shocking! However, on stage he was utterly electric with a powerful, outrageous performance style that influenced anyone who played a piano.

It's "Live at the Star Club" by Jerry Lee Lewis.

I'm not a huge fan of live albums as a rule as you never quite seem to get the same experience from listening to it as to when you are there yourself. However, I'm making an exception for this album. It's a musical masterpiece by one of the greatest performers who's ever lived. I find it quite odd really as when you listen to his records, they sound quite tame nowadays and whilst the songs are good, they just don't have much "umph" about them. It captures the atmosphere and sheer, raw, physical power of his performance and makes you feel like you're sat on the front row. I get the distinct feeling that he was a very different person when playing live to the studio recordings!

It's said that he played the piano and got his band to play with the same phrenetic energy of what we'd see in a thrash metal band today and you get a real feel for that with the opening track "High School Confidential". It's absolute pure, undiluted rock n roll. If you don't like your rock'n'roll raw and primitive then the good news is that the Spotify doesn't have all the tracks on and he rattles through 8 songs in just 22 minutes!

The pace drops with his version of Money before it picks up with Great Balls Of Fire. It just gets you tapping along and you can't help but think what this must've been like watching it live.

"Good Golly Miss Molly" needs no introduction, it's a masterpiece and a great cover. No one will ever touch Little Richard's version, but this must've been absolutely sensational watching it live.

"Your cheating heart" hints at the country direction he would take later in his career. And he did that phenomenally well. He wasn't just a piano-hammering maniac, he was a seriously good musician.

"Long Tall Sally" ramps it back up to thrash-metal levels again. The recording just jumps out and you just feel like you're sat there. I can imagine people just being blown away by this. Finally it ends with his masterpiece "Whole lotta shaking goin on".

"The Killer" passed away last year and I rediscovered this album again. When I first listened to the songs on this album as a mid-teenager at the height of Acid House and The Stone Roses etc and just thinking 'wow', I couldn't help but be amazed at just how good these songs were. As much as I love The Roses and Acid House, there's just something you can't put your finger on when it comes to a band kicking the living shit out of their instruments!

I know every man and his dog who wants to be in a rock/indie/whatever band starts with a guitar but this album shows reminds you that rock has it's roots in piano too.

Every time I hear it I think I'd rather be better on the piano than guitar! I've not picked up my Fender for a few months now and try as I might, I'll never come anywhere close to being able to play like he does. He was a controversial character and I'm sure he's not up in heaven despite his religious leanings! But the way he hammers, kicks, punches and slams that piano makes you whether he's reuninted with Satan!

I hope you enjoy it as much as I do.
 
Another live album!

This has the potential to be a bit different though because there’s every chance that the recording will be as good as, if not better than, the original songs/albums.

I was going to say is this the first true rock and roll icon we’ve had, but we have had Roy Orbison as well.
 
I think it's very different to his recordings to be honest. The sound on the originals is never great due to when it was recorded, but with this album there's a visceral energy about it that you simply don't get on any of his recordings.

I never saw him live, but I get the impression that he was someone you'd need to see to appreciate!
 
You’ve reminded me that when I was first getting my thoughts together about reviewing the album that I was going to comment on that. I do like small p political, kitchen sink dramas or whatever you might want to call it. Squeeze and Elvis Costello come to mind as having been very good at it and Bragg is up there with them lyrically on that line.

Squeeze were masters of it. On the 'best first lines' thread there's a number of Squeeze tracks where they are straight into the story in the very first line.
 
I was going to say something flip and probably incorrect about how women know nothing about music but thought better of it. Interesting though that my partner, who was as indie as me when we met and as eclectic in her tastes has become quite narrow and conservative in her listening habits. It may be that she no longer feels the need to discover new music apart from very radio friendly stuff but to be fair she is open to some of the new stuff I play.

I’m often pleasantly surprised to hear the stuff my older son plays having evolved from a Kanye West heavy diet. Younger son a lost cause with his unaccountable fascination with country music. He has no interest in football either. Good job he’s a good lad otherwise.

The point I planned to make is that unless I’m very much mistaken we have no female contributors to this thread.

That's not an entirely dissimilar situation to me, Mr Spires was very much indie and interested in new music in our early to years but that has definitely waned. These days she's happy to listen to soul lite stuff on the radio. In fairness she's never really been that much into traditional rock. I'm particularly looking forward to her response to the vocals from the lad from Greta Van Fleet :-)

Elder son is like a musical sponge and showing good eclectic taste but his ear and music theory are now sufficiently good that it's like being in the car with bloody Rick Beato which can be slightly annoying at times. However he has no interest whatsoever in football. The little 'un has slightly dodgy taste in music but there's time for that to change and he gets a free pass by being City mad.

Nowt wrong with a bit of country, Alisson Moorer on my shortlist for this thread.
 
My nomination is for an old timer who along with Elvis, Chuck Berry, Little Richard and others created the genre we'd know today as rock'n'roll.

Not only did they help to create the genre, they were one of the first to create the idea that a rock front men is wild, dangerous and out of control. And quite honestly, they don't come more dangerous than this man. Multiple marriages, wives dying in controversial circumstances, marrying his 13-year old cousin, drink problems, drug problems, prison and shootings. Not many could match this wildman of rock and back in the 50s it must have been absolutely shocking! However, on stage he was utterly electric with a powerful, outrageous performance style that influenced anyone who played a piano.

It's "Live at the Star Club" by Jerry Lee Lewis.

I'm not a huge fan of live albums as a rule as you never quite seem to get the same experience from listening to it as to when you are there yourself. However, I'm making an exception for this album. It's a musical masterpiece by one of the greatest performers who's ever lived. I find it quite odd really as when you listen to his records, they sound quite tame nowadays and whilst the songs are good, they just don't have much "umph" about them. It captures the atmosphere and sheer, raw, physical power of his performance and makes you feel like you're sat on the front row. I get the distinct feeling that he was a very different person when playing live to the studio recordings!

It's said that he played the piano and got his band to play with the same phrenetic energy of what we'd see in a thrash metal band today and you get a real feel for that with the opening track "High School Confidential". It's absolute pure, undiluted rock n roll. If you don't like your rock'n'roll raw and primitive then the good news is that the Spotify doesn't have all the tracks on and he rattles through 8 songs in just 22 minutes!

The pace drops with his version of Money before it picks up with Great Balls Of Fire. It just gets you tapping along and you can't help but think what this must've been like watching it live.

"Good Golly Miss Molly" needs no introduction, it's a masterpiece and a great cover. No one will ever touch Little Richard's version, but this must've been absolutely sensational watching it live.

"Your cheating heart" hints at the country direction he would take later in his career. And he did that phenomenally well. He wasn't just a piano-hammering maniac, he was a seriously good musician.

"Long Tall Sally" ramps it back up to thrash-metal levels again. The recording just jumps out and you just feel like you're sat there. I can imagine people just being blown away by this. Finally it ends with his masterpiece "Whole lotta shaking goin on".

"The Killer" passed away last year and I rediscovered this album again. When I first listened to the songs on this album as a mid-teenager at the height of Acid House and The Stone Roses etc and just thinking 'wow', I couldn't help but be amazed at just how good these songs were. As much as I love The Roses and Acid House, there's just something you can't put your finger on when it comes to a band kicking the living shit out of their instruments!

I know every man and his dog who wants to be in a rock/indie/whatever band starts with a guitar but this album shows reminds you that rock has it's roots in piano too.

Every time I hear it I think I'd rather be better on the piano than guitar! I've not picked up my Fender for a few months now and try as I might, I'll never come anywhere close to being able to play like he does. He was a controversial character and I'm sure he's not up in heaven despite his religious leanings! But the way he hammers, kicks, punches and slams that piano makes you whether he's reuninted with Satan!

I hope you enjoy it as much as I do.
Brilliant selection , played this many times , not sure I enjoy it as much as you but I enjoy it immensely.
The Killer continues to kill as he thrills with chills. 8/10.
 
Obviously I've heard bits of Lewis live before but it is genuinely surprising how he can make a piano sound 'dangerous'. Even ignoring his dubious off stage antics, if I was a straight laced Dad in the early sixties with teenage daughters and I heard this, there's no way I'd be letting them go to see him! :-)
 
Enjoy. I think we’ll all be looking forward to you reporting your family’s reactions to our collective selections!

Be quite interesting to see what they make of certain stuff and who they want to hear more of beyond the ones they already know. If JJ Cale can weave his magic on the family too then it'll cement his status as the thread GOAT. Got high hopes for Rodriguez amongst others but we'll see.
 
Be quite interesting to see what they make of certain stuff and who they want to hear more of beyond the ones they already know. If JJ Cale can weave his magic on the family too then it'll cement his status as the thread GOAT. Got high hopes for Rodriguez amongst others but we'll see.
For what it's worth, here are the track picks from my selections (Album/Artists/Track):-

The Lonesome Jubilee / John Cougar Mellencamp / Paper in Fire
Earth & Sun & Moon / Midnight Oil / Truganini
So Runs The World Away / Josh Ritter / The Curse
King Swamp / King Swamp / Motherlode
Living With The Law / Chris Whitley / Phone Call From Leavenworth
Girlfriend / Matthew Sweet / Girlfriend
 
Be quite interesting to see what they make of certain stuff and who they want to hear more of beyond the ones they already know. If JJ Cale can weave his magic on the family too then it'll cement his status as the thread GOAT. Got high hopes for Rodriguez amongst others but we'll see.

There is perhaps something to be said for grouping/ordering the songs by nominator. Thinking how I would approach it, just a thought.
 
My word, nothing to do with this week's nomination but give this a try. I think some on here will enjoy this.

The only problem for me is that it places Rod Stewart suspiciously close to a lot of artists that I like and I don't really like Rod Stewart's music.

 
My word, nothing to do with this week's nomination but give this a try. I think some on here will enjoy this.

The only problem for me is that it places Rod Stewart suspiciously close to a lot of artists that I like and I don't really like Rod Stewart's music.


Tried 4 bands. 2 are 50-50 I'd say, maybe 60-40, as in I agree with some, disagree with others. Other 2 were pretty epic fails imo.
 
My word, nothing to do with this week's nomination but give this a try. I think some on here will enjoy this.

The only problem for me is that it places Rod Stewart suspiciously close to a lot of artists that I like and I don't really like Rod Stewart's music.


I've had a play with this before, it's interesting isn't it. As you say it's still got a lot to learn. Does it still throttle the number of searches you can do in a period?

Many years ago (talking when netscape navigator was still a thing) I signed up to as a public tester for an early music recommendation technology and it was incredibly good I think it was called firefly or something but it literally disappeared overnight, I assume it was incorporated into some commercial tech along the way but I still haven't come across anything as effective since.
 
I've never actually sat down and really listened properly to Lewis before. The piano playing is fascinating it's like standard boogie woogie but laminated with this extra layer of brutally. I'm no expert on piano playing but I think it shows huge talent because it sounds like a nutter hammering shit out the keys without sounding simply like a nutter hammering shit out of the keys.
 
Last edited:
I've never actually sat down and really listened properly to Lewis before. The piano playing is fascinating it's like standard boogie woogie but laminated with this extra layer of brutally. I'm no expert on piano playing but I think it shows huge talent because it sounds like a nutter hammering shit out the keys without sounding simply like a nutter hammering shit out of the keys.
Master of the keyboards threespires welcome aboard.

I can't think of too many for what he does that do it better.

Self taught and one of the most influential way beyond the piano.

At some stage every singer wanted him on the keyboards as they struck a chord or two (LOL).
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top