southamptonblue
Well-Known Member
Anything other than 2/3 U2 songs, total borefest for me.....this isn't one of 2/3 ;)
The Bluemoon Song Cup 2024 - Round 4/M5 - P277 - The Mamas & The Papas (California Dreamin') v The Beach Boys (God Only Knows)
- Thread starter BlueHammer85
- Start date
southamptonblue
Well-Known Member
Not sure you've ever listened to the Scott albums ;)
roman totale
Well-Known Member
I immediately voted for Jose without even listening to it.
jimharri
Moderator
U2, by a distance.
BlueHammer85
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 13 Oct 2010
- Messages
- 36,433
14-14
Battle declared!
Battle declared!
I've voted U2.
The trouble with I Still Haven't Found (and also Where THe Streets Have No Name & With Or Without You) is the radio overkill.
It's a really good song, but people are fed up hearing it.
The Joshua Tree is one of my favourite ever albums, but even I often skip to the fourth track and then listen to it from there.
The other thing which will go against the song is the anti Bono aspect - which is a shame because they really have done some great songs (up to and including The Joshua Tree) but Bono, unfortunately, became very pretentious and alienated a lot of folk
The trouble with I Still Haven't Found (and also Where THe Streets Have No Name & With Or Without You) is the radio overkill.
It's a really good song, but people are fed up hearing it.
The Joshua Tree is one of my favourite ever albums, but even I often skip to the fourth track and then listen to it from there.
The other thing which will go against the song is the anti Bono aspect - which is a shame because they really have done some great songs (up to and including The Joshua Tree) but Bono, unfortunately, became very pretentious and alienated a lot of folk
mancity2012_eamo
Well-Known Member
The whole album is great. No doubt whatsoever.
For me it’s where they peaked.
Bono however, didn’t become pretentious, he seems to have bee born that way.
When they started and played in the Dandelion Market on Sunday afternoon me and my mates wouldn’t pay 50p to go watch them.
There was a ton of better Dublin bands that were not as well managed as U2.
Good luck to them however, I’m sure they couldn’t give a damn what we thought of them.
Wasn’t there myself but a few of my mates were at s house party in Portmarnock, where the U2 boys were preaching God in the kitchen and obviously being ridiculed by my teenage mates.
Bono was always preaching.
Having said that, I went to them twice at the end of the 70’s in Croke Psrk and they were great.
Simple chords, but they learned how to deliver. Kudos where it’s due.
Still voted for Jose.
MellowJoe
Well-Known Member
Jose was here last year wasn't he? Same song and I voted for him again, It's a cover The Knife did the original, still Swedish, but Gonzalez made it his own and better
NZBlue
Well-Known Member
Well I have! Don't get me wrong I actually like them but they are a small doses band. It's a bit like I find Alanis Morissette- Jagged little Pill has great songs but is too much of a listen at one time