The Conservative Party

FPTP could have Vox getting 10% of the vote and 40 seats.
Not sure how you work that out. If Andalucía was set up on a constituency basis PSOE would win the majority and the ones they didn't win would have gone to Ciudanos or PP.
 
Not sure how you work that out. If Andalucía was set up on a constituency basis PSOE would win the majority and the ones they didn't win would have gone to Ciudanos or PP.
On the same basis that the SNP got 50 seats with a lower percentage under FPTP mate. PR goes a lot further to taking geographical spread out of it.
 
On the same basis that the SNP got 50 seats with a lower percentage under FPTP mate. PR goes a lot further to taking geographical spread out of it.
SNP are the biggest party in Scotland. Vox were the 5th biggest in Andalucía.
 
SNP are the biggest party in Scotland. Vox were the 5th biggest in Andalucía.
They could be the 5th biggest in Andalusia and be the biggest in one part of Andalusia hoovering up seats, just as the SNP were the fifth biggest in the UK by vote (I think? - Tory, Labour, Lib Dems, UKIP, SNP) but monopolized the seats in Scotland.
 
They were quite strong in Almería 19%, but everywhere else way behind. If you divided Andalucía up into UK sized bits not sure they'd have won any seats at all.
 
They were quite strong in Almería 19%, but everywhere else way behind. If you divided Andalucía up into UK sized bits not sure they'd have won any seats at all.
With the right spread of their support they could.
 
With the right spread of their support they could.
It's pretty difficult to say. But in part of the UK, the SNP were way ahead of Labour and the Tories. There is nowhere in Andalucía where Vox were anything else than a protest vote. A bit like UKIp in England.
 
It's pretty difficult to say. But in part of the UK, the SNP were way ahead of Labour and the Tories. There is nowhere in Andalucía where Vox were anything else than a protest vote. A bit like UKIp in England.
Protest vote or not, there's a serious problem with a system that produces the SNP and UKIP vote and seat numbers, it's an invitation to gerrymandering (not that I'm saying that has happened) and I don't think a fear of parties like Vox/UKIP getting a few seats justifies sticking with it.
 
Protest vote or not, there's a serious problem with a system that produces the SNP and UKIP vote and seat numbers, it's an invitation to gerrymandering (not that I'm saying that has happened) and I don't think a fear of parties like Vox/UKIP getting a few seats justifies sticking with it.
Tend to agree.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top