VAR impact and consequence log - game 27

[Ballet-on-ice]

The two sweethearts of Stockley park play against each other tomorrow. I wonder who'll get the magic wand.

 

[cheekybids]

"Latest research" broadly agrees with this thread

https://www.mirror.co.uk/sport/foot...-2Dl-aj3zTDtQv3yj-mA_pF3jKBucWikryVtIGk6Apcso

I wonder why the algorithm doesn’t look at the non handball before Liverpool scores their 1st.

 

[flook]

I wonder why the algorithm doesn’t look at the non handball before Liverpool scores their 1st.

that's the one game where their assessment differs from mine, I had that as a draw

 

[cheekybids]

that's the one game where their assessment differs from mine, I had that as a draw

I had a 5:0 to us ;)

 

[flook]

updated for the villa game

 

[Metalartin]

There's a mistake on the review of the Wolves game, Jota dipped his shoulder and leaned into Ederson, looking for the contact the second Ederson missed the ball. An honest mistake from Eddie and he tried to pull out/avoid contact. Not a red card for those two reasons, ontop of that wasn't there a rule change which specified that a yellow can be given if there was no intent to deny a goalscoring opportunity? You've gone with the commentary's call on the incident. Watch the replay without audio it's obvious IMO.

 

[flook]

There's a mistake on the review of the Wolves game, Jota dipped his shoulder and leaned into Ederson, looking for the contact the second Ederson missed the ball. An honest mistake from Eddie and he tried to pull out/avoid contact. Not a red card for those two reasons, ontop of that wasn't there a rule change which specified that a yellow can be given if there was no intent to deny a goalscoring opportunity? You've gone with the commentary's call on the incident. Watch the replay without audio it's obvious IMO.

you've pretty much said exactly what I said?? Pretty much every situation like that results in a red for the keeper if he doesn't get the ball

 

[Metalartin]

you've pretty much said exactly what I said?? Pretty much every situation like that results in a red for the keeper if he doesn't get the ball

No you said:

Jota pops the ball over his head and basically runs into eddie. Red card for Eddie and upheld by VAR, correct decision (probably) only doubt is that Jota made no effort to avoid eddie, but why should he?

Wrong for the reasons stated in my post, which I don't feel the need to repeat. Wrong decision and no it's not always a red card when a player looks for the contact, it's not even always a penalty. They saw an opportunity and took it with both hands.

 

[flook]

No you said:


Wrong for the reasons stated in my post, which I don't feel the need to repeat. Wrong decision and no it's not always a red card when a player looks for the contact, it's not even always a penalty.

we'll just agree to differ then

 

[Metalartin]

we'll just agree to differ then

You do that mate, you're still wrong.