Vinny wouldn't do that, so it's a non-starter.<br /><br />-- Sat Aug 13, 2011 2:22 pm --<br /><br />pudge said:Let me put this HYPOTHETICAL situation out there, for those saying he should have been sent off and is disgrace for pulling Gervinho up and shoving him; taking away the oscar winning fall. If say, Nani did that in the derby, had dived for a penalty, and Kompany took exception and dragged him up and told him, how many of you would be cheering Vinny?
Cross to whom this game?MCFC BOB said:No end product whatsoever. A winger who can't cross is like a defender who can't tackle.taconinja said:I agree.Prestwich_Blue said:I thought he's looked their major threat.
It's HYPOTHETICALtaconinja said:Vinny wouldn't do that, so it's a non-starter.pudge said:Let me put this HYPOTHETICAL situation out there, for those saying he should have been sent off and is disgrace for pulling Gervinho up and shoving him; taking away the oscar winning fall. If say, Nani did that in the derby, had dived for a penalty, and Kompany took exception and dragged him up and told him, how many of you would be cheering Vinny?
lee-mcfc said:^^ Correct.jimharri said:Don't talk shite. Barton grabbed the gooner by the collar of his shirt. Violent conduct, therefore a red card. Should have been a yellow card for Gervinho and a red for the scouse twat.stavros said:FOR WHAT?????? HE DID FUCK ALL WRONG ARSENAL GETTING TASTE OF THEIR OWN MEDICINE. BARTON GOT HIM SENT OFF GERVINHO WAS STUPID ENOUGH TO RAISE HIS HANDS. IF BARTON DID THAT, THAT PRICK GERVINHO WOULD HAVE GONE DOWN.
plus he got stamped on before and kept his cool.
well done barton
And song(i think it was) should of been off a long time aswell
Quite likely Vinnie would go down in blue folklore. Nevertheless, it would (should?) be a red card offence. You often hear the comment ''you can't lift your arms towrds an opponent''. So, how do you define grabbing someone by the collar?pudge said:Let me put this HYPOTHETICAL situation out there, for those saying he should have been sent off and is disgrace for pulling Gervinho up and shoving him; taking away the oscar winning fall. If say, Nani did that in the derby, had dived for a penalty, and Kompany took exception and dragged him up and told him, how many of you would be cheering Vinny?
The Newcastle defence has looked really solid today and he's not had too many clear cut opportunities to deliver a final pass.MCFC BOB said:No end product whatsoever. A winger who can't cross is like a defender who can't tackle.taconinja said:I agree.Prestwich_Blue said:I thought he's looked their major threat.
Ah, well it wouldn't matter as the hypothetical asteroid will have already smashed into Earth and ended all life.pudge said:It's HYPOTHETICALtaconinja said:Vinny wouldn't do that, so it's a non-starter.pudge said:Let me put this HYPOTHETICAL situation out there, for those saying he should have been sent off and is disgrace for pulling Gervinho up and shoving him; taking away the oscar winning fall. If say, Nani did that in the derby, had dived for a penalty, and Kompany took exception and dragged him up and told him, how many of you would be cheering Vinny?
If the FA fail to act on Song, after our recent dealings with them (the FA), it will reek of hypocrisy.Seasideblue said:Agree song should have gone before but would imagine a retrospective ban may follow that incident