Who are our 5 best players in order?

[didactic]

Just a bit of fun since I cannot sleep, I will start and please let's not turn this into a fanboy drama thread.

1. Yaya Toure.
2. Sergio Aguero.
3. Joint 3rd Vincent Kompany and David Silva.
5. Pablo Zabaleta.

Your turn blues :)

 

[Citizenhill]

1. Sergio Aguero.
2. David Silva.
3. Vincent Kompany.
4. Yaya Toure.
5. Pablo Zabaleta.

Same players, just a different order. Considered Nasri over Zabaleta, but Zaba has been far more consistent over the past 3 years.

 

[blue_paul]

Aguero
Silva
Toure
Kompany
Negredo

Honourable mentions for Nasri and Fernandinho

 

[foetus]

1. Aguero
2. Silva
3. Toure
4. Kompany
5. Nasri

 

[i kne albert davy]

Hmmm tough one

I'd go for
1. Aguero
2. Silva
3. Kompany (when not injured of course)
4.Toure ( when he's in the mood)
5. Negredo.

 

[There is a Light]

1. Garcia
2. Dzeko
3. Kolarov
4. Lescott
5. Scott Sinclair

 

[Jack74]

This season

Nasri
Aguero
Toure
Negrado
Zabs

 

[TCIB]

To subjective for me, and i am not being awkward.

I can't begin to compare Kompany's value to the squad to say Aguero.

Nastasic last season was a amazing and helped keep us from being really fucked in CD many times i feel.
He still is young and was in a new league, he was immense, the fact he was not nominated for young player totally made me fuck awards off now.

Zabba, another who dragged us last season, Aguero and Negredo are storming.
Nasri has seemlesly filled a huge HUGE void.
Remember last season how we moaned and even this about lack of creativity with no El Mago ?.
He has really stepped up.

tl;dr Impossible to quantify for my logical mind.

 

[SuperYaya]

1 - Silva
2 - Aguero
3 - Yaya
4 - Kompany
5 - Negredo

 

[foetus]

1. Garcia
2. Dzeko
3. Kolarov
4. Lescott
5. Scott Sinclair

was only a matter of time ;)

 

[Anonymous]

1. Sheikh Mansour
2. Sergio Aguero
3. David Silva
4. Yaya Toure
5. Alvaro Negredo

 

[cucumberman]

1. Aguero
2. Yaya
3. Kompany
4. Silva
5. Anyone on form

 

[Ray78]

Kompany, Silva, Yaya, Aguero and as the season draws on Nasri.

 

[Rösler von Stretfordbömber]

1) Aguero
2) Silva
3) Kompany
4) Toure
5) Zabaleta

Boy, Nasri is really pushing at the gates of this list on his current form. So happy to see that. Ferny has got to be in the conversation as well.

 

[jollylescott]

1. Merlin
2. Kun
3. Vinny
4. Yaya
5. Nasri

 

[krdskrm]

1. Silva
2. Yaya Toure
3. Agüero
4. Nasri
5. Kompany

(6. Negredo)

 

[Dax777]

If we are talking this season, then Zabaletta isn't in the top 5.

Aguero
Nasri
Silva
Negredo
Yaya

That has been the. Top 5 this season.

 

[NickGw2]

This year so far it's gotta be:

1. Aguero
Then in any order - Negredo, Nasri, Silva, Fernandinho over YaYa as he has been more consistent? Though I may just be too influenced by the YaYa is lazy contingent on here. Kompany's missed 80% of the season.

 

[sh249]

1. Merlin
2. Kun
3. Vinny
4. Yaya
5. Nasri

I'd go with this

 

[Dogtanian]

Silva
Aguero
Yaya
Kompany
Nasri