simonk
Well-Known Member
deafmanstevo said:Its a myth that Magpies kill all the songbirds , if it was true they would be no songbirds at all.
Cats kill more songbirds than Magpies and Birds of Prey put together.
And no i dont hate cats or suggest a cull on cats, besides my mum would have something to say about that.
what about all the pesticides people use in gardens too, songbirds eat the contaminated seeds and insects.
And millions of songbirds get slaughtered every year in places like Italy,Greece and Cyprus.
Ive Birdwatched with my dad in places where its been overrun with Magpies and there have also loads of songbirds too,which blows that thoery out of the water.
Many of the larger Birds of Prey that prey on Magpies such as Goshawks have been persecuted in England so Magpies dont have many natural predators in Britain.
That said Magpies do predate some songbirds nests but its very over the top to suggest they are solely responsible for the decline on songbirds.
Cats, squirrels, crows, woodpeckers, sparrowhawks, weasels stoats foxes , all prey on songbirds at some time. Thats nature .
Kill cats I say
They were thought to kill 27 million birds pa in the UK. That figure is now thought to be hugely underestimated and it could be 2 or 3 times that
And cats dont have natural predators in this country. Except cars