A moral dilemma...league or Cup?

[trotsky]

Problem posed to me in my boozer...

You have the choice, City win the league but lose the Cup Final to United or

finnish second to the Rags but beat them in the FA Cup final.

After much nut scratching, I went for the Cup. A head to head final would be ours forever (plus we've already pipped them in the league once before).


Which would you choose?

 

[Anonymous]

Re: A moral dilemma...

the cup final i would say i couldnt take losing a cup final to them, it would send me over the edge.

 

[johnmc]

A moral dilemma...

Depends. Would the league go to the last game but we get beat on the last day?

 

[City Raider]

league every time, it's not about them, its about as and the league is the top trophy

 

[PaulPowre]

I'd take top 4 and either cup right now.

 

[trotsky]

Re: A moral dilemma...

the cup final i would say i couldnt take losing a cup final to them, it would send me over the edge.

Yeh, that's how I felt. I know the league title is a bigger prize, but to do them toe to toe would be magic.. and of course Tevez scores the winner!

It might even happen!

 

[Didsbury Dave]

Of course you'd choose the league. Madness to suggest anything else

 

[trotsky]

Re: A moral dilemma...

Depends. Would the league go to the last game but we get beat on the last day?

Mmm, I know what you're saying "how much pain?" . I'll make it that we 're second by 5 points. Still pain but not too excrutiating.

 

[Gelsons Dad]

League. No question.

 

[trotsky]

Of course you'd choose the league. Madness to suggest anything else

Really?

I know that is rational, but come on, just imagine that day at Wembley...